MEAWW.COM / ENTERTAINMENT / TV

'LOTR' fans can't stand 'The Rings of Power' Season 2, and there's a good reason why

Ratings for 'LOTR: The Rings of Power' Season 2 have hit an all-time low, with both critics and fans expressing the same complaints

MIDDLE EARTH: As a Tolkien enthusiast, I'm still reeling from the crushing disappointment that is 'The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power'. The Prime Video series, that pats itself in the back for being a loving tribute to Middle-earth, has instead ravaged the very essence of Tolkien's world.

The show's creative team would have you believe that critics are merely "trolls" or "haters," but the truth is far more nuanced.

'LOTR: The Rings of the Power' must do better, and we can't emphazise on this enough

The real issue lies in the show's fundamental disregard for Tolkien's source material, this itself immediately makes you want to disregard the show. Characterizations are transformed beyond recognition, and time scales are compressed. The plot devices are convenient, I'll give them that, but we can't miss out on the fact that it's nonsensical. Galadriel, once a bright character, is now childish and narcissistic. 

The show's overreliance on "mystery box" storytelling and cringe-worthy dialogue makes conversations feel forced and unnatural. And let's not even get you started about the nonsensical geographical and temporal inconsistencies have severed the connection to Tolkien's world, leaving fans frustrated.

On the other hand, diversity and world-building, while well-intentioned, are poorly executed. Inconsistent representation and lack of distinct cultural identities have compromised the show's potential for authentic storytelling. It's diversity for diversity's sake, rather than thoughtful integration.

What's most heartbreaking is the wasted potential. With a rich source material and talented cast, 'The Rings of Power' could have been a masterpiece. Instead, it's a soulless, creative catastrophe that prioritizes shock value over substance.

Fans aren't attacking the show out of malice; we're mourning the loss of a beloved world, butchered by careless writing. We're not "trolls" or "haters"; we're passionate enthusiasts who want to see Tolkien's world done justice. To the show's creators, I implore you: listen to the fans. Engage with our concerns, and strive for a more nuanced understanding of what went wrong.

As it stands, 'The Rings of Power' has lost the trust of its audience. Unless drastic changes are made, this once-promising series will remain a cautionary tale of creative arrogance and tone-deaf storytelling.

Fans bash 'LOTR: The Rings of Power' for multiple reasons, call the show 'disgusting'

As mentioned earlier, fans have been frustrated by the show's failure to adhere to the source material. On X, one fan said, "Wait, is Tom Bombadil supposed to be Eru explicitly in Rings of Power? Like … removed all ambiguity and mystery that the source material had? Without even an explanation for non-Tolkien nerds as to what that means??? The worst of both worlds. P**s off fans, confuse non-fans lol."

"I'm trying trying trying you enjoy Rings of Power but I'm only 10 minutes into season 2 and I don't see how it's possible they read the source material," added another fan. One fan wrote, "I think the biggest problem with Rings of Power is that it's about characters who are high-minded, wise, and good...but it consistently depicts them as petty and foolish so that Sauron can play them like fiddles, even characters who always distrusted him in the source material."

One fan criticized the show's creators, saying, "The Rings of Power series is absolutely disgusting. It has a stupid and bad script, shameful dialogue, a visually disgusting cast for all the elves and very bad acting, except for Adar. The production is poor in everything except the city views from Veta Workshop."

Another fan wrote, "It is not fair to associate the Rings of power with the lord of the rings, episode 6 was a s**t show with bad writing and sloppy plots it made numenorians look weak and like children, elfs of eregion are stupid and Galadrial looks like she was casting for a school play...."

'LOTR: The Rings of Power' trailer

Disclaimer: This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.