Is 'The Circle' rigged? Most obvious winners raise questions on Netflix show

'The Circle' has been subjected to several rumors over the last few seasons, with fans calling the show 'fake'
Viewers of Netflix series 'The Circle' feel that editing might be used to create a more dramatic narrative (@netflix)
Viewers of Netflix series 'The Circle' feel that editing might be used to create a more dramatic narrative (@netflix)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Questions about whether Netflix's 'The Circle' is rigged have arisen due to concerns over the apparent predictability of the show's winners and the transparency of its voting system. Many viewers have noticed a pattern where contestants with "heartfelt stories" or strong personal narratives often end up winning. This trend leads some fans to believe that the show might be manipulating outcomes to favor certain contestants, rather than allowing the competition to play out naturally. For example, in recent seasons, winners who have had emotional backstories or who seem to be portrayed as the "good guys" are often seen as obvious choices for victory.

There are other concerns about how contestant ratings are calculated and presented too. Some fans argue that the ratings don’t always align with the actual dynamics of the game. For instance, there might be inconsistencies in how contestants are rated, especially when the results seem to defy logical expectations. This has led to speculation that the show’s producers might influence the ratings or the outcome to enhance drama.

Unlike the UK version of 'The Circle', which sometimes releases detailed ratings after the season ends, the US version does not. According to fans, this lack of transparency prevents viewers from seeing how each contestant was rated throughout the game. Also, there are concerns about how the show is edited. Some viewers feel that the editing might be used to manipulate perceptions and create a more dramatic narrative, like selectively showcasing certain interactions or downplaying others to fit a desired storyline.

How is the winner of Netflix’s ‘The Circle’ chosen?

In Netflix’s 'The Circle', the winner is determined through a process of player ratings and a final vote. Throughout the game, contestants, who live in separate apartments and only communicate 'The Circle' social media platform, privately rate each other based on their interactions.

The players with the highest ratings become "Influencers," who have the power to block or eliminate others from the game. As the game progresses, these ratings continue until the final round, where all remaining players rate each other one last time. The player with the highest average rating in this final round is declared the winner, securing the cash prize. This means the winner is the contestant who has managed to maintain the highest popularity and strategic gameplay throughout the competition.

'The Circle' Season 6 contestant Kyle Fuller is a prod dog dad (@netflix)
'The Circle' Season 6 contestant (@netflix)


'The Circle’ Season 6 winner Brandon Baker says he’s ‘unsure’ how he won the show

Brandon Baker, the winner of 'The Circle' Season 6, admitted that he’s still unsure how he managed to win the competition. Throughout the season, Brandon played the game using emotions and kindness while catfishing as a character named "Olivia." Despite his unconventional approach and lack of strategic planning, he was surprised to find himself in first place.

Brandon explained that he didn’t expect to win, especially after ranking other players highly in the final ratings. "I thought I gave [the win] away," he said, reflecting on his decision to put QT and Kyle at the top. Even seven months after filming, he struggled to believe that he had actually won, saying, "Honestly, it still doesn't feel real," he told Entertainment Weekly.

Brandon Baker winner of the series )@netflix)
Brandon Baker winner of the series (@netflix)

'The Circle’ fans call Season 6 ‘most fake’ season of the Netflix show

Fans of 'The Circle' are voicing their disappointment with Season 6, labeling it the "most fake" season of the Netflix show so far. Longtime viewers who have followed both the UK and US versions of the show have noticed a significant shift in how this season feels compared to earlier ones.

Many fans believe that the contestants this season were being overly dramatic, with exaggerated reactions to alerts and events in the game. This has led some to suspect that the producers may have encouraged them to act this way, making the show feel more scripted and less authentic.

The conversations between contestants have also been criticized for being shallow and uninteresting, lacking the depth and genuine connections that made previous seasons so entertaining interesting. Additionally, the absence of multiple catfishes, which was a hallmark of the series, has left the gameplay feeling less exciting and predictable.

The 5  worst contestants on 'The Circle' (X/CircleNetflix)
'The Circle' (@netflix)

'The Circle' Season 7 premieres September 11, 2024 on Netflix, with new episodes rolling out each Wednesday

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Sarah explains her boundaries after John’s reaction to a bill raises concerns on ‘Love Is Blind’.
2026-10-24T15:35:44.000Z
Bravo expands its 'Next Gen' franchise to Atlanta, introducing rising personalities navigating careers, relationships, and family dynamics.
2026-10-23T18:55:37.000Z
Bravo drops exciting 'In the City' Season 2 update as Amanda Batula’s relationship with West Wilson reshapes the 'Summer House spinoff.
2026-10-23T17:43:02.000Z
After his suspension from the dance reality show, fans have been waiting for Val to return.
2026-10-23T12:21:08.000Z
Victor sticks to his Fruitgate theory, but the fellow Faithfuls aren't convinced
2026-10-23T03:13:18.000Z
Among the cast members is a former ‘Big Brother’ Season 15 contestant, who will appear alongside her husband
2026-10-23T02:50:43.000Z
The celebrity contestant and his pro dance partner earned the season’s first perfect 10 in their score.
2026-10-22T10:30:31.000Z
Tyler Cameron dedicated his Contemporary routine with Sharna Burgess to mothers everywhere
2026-10-22T08:59:11.000Z
With the upcoming season, viewers can vote for their favorite participants and help them move closer to winning.
2026-10-22T08:24:06.000Z
During Episode 5, one duo used their express pass after they found themselves among the last two teams
2026-10-22T06:38:27.000Z