‘Irresponsible to cast him’: ‘American Psycho’ has a new Patrick Bateman, and fans are split

The role, famously brought to life by Christian Bale is considered a challenging one, for obvious reasons
Christian Bale as Patrick Bateman in a still from ‘American Psycho’ (2000)
Christian Bale as Patrick Bateman in a still from ‘American Psycho’ (2000)

Austin Butler is stepping into one of the most infamous roles in modern fiction. The Oscar-nominated actor, known for his portrayal of Elvis Presley, has been cast as Patrick Bateman in Luca Guadagnino’s new take on ‘American Psycho’.

Guadagnino, known for his work on 'Call Me by Your Name' and 'Challengers', has promised a new interpretation of Bret Easton Ellis’s controversial novel. Unlike Mary Harron’s cult 2000 adaptation, Guadagnino’s vision aims to reimagine the material with a script penned by Scott Z Burns. However, this casting news comes after weeks of speculation and has sparked mixed reactions from fans online.

‘American Psycho’ has a new Patrick Bateman, and its Austin Butler

Austin Butler cast as Patrick Bateman in ‘American Psycho’ (Getty Images)
Austin Butler cast as Patrick Bateman in ‘American Psycho’ (Getty Images)

For weeks, rumors swirled that 'Euphoria' star Jacob Elordi was in talks for the lead role. However, Guadagnino has now confirmed that Butler will take on the part of the narcissistic investment banker and serial killer, as per Variety. The role, famously brought to life by Christian Bale and later by Matt Smith in a stage musical, is considered a challenging one, for obvious reasons.

The project adds to Guadagnino’s busy slate, which includes his award-season contender 'Queer' and 2025's 'After the Hunt', starring Julia Roberts and Andrew Garfield. Butler, meanwhile, continues his meteoric rise, following his turns in 'Dune: Part Two' and 'The Bikeriders'. He is also set to star in Ari Aster’s 'Eddington' and Darren Aronofsky’s 'Caught Stealing'.

Internet split over Austin Butler's casting as Patrick Bateman

BEVERLY HILLS, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 10: Austin Butler attends the 80th Annual Golden Globe Awards at
Austin Butler attends the 80th Annual Golden Globe Awards (Getty Images)

Fans have been quick to weigh in on Austin Butler’s casting as Patrick Bateman, and opinions are sharply divided. While some believe his talent and versatility make him a strong choice, others argue he lacks the edge. One wrote, ""1. Why do we need an American Psycho remake? 2. You couldn't find ANYONE more suited for the role than Austin Butler??? Be so ffr." Another said, "Austin butler is the worst choice for American psycho."



 



 

One X user wrote, "Idk if it was smart for Austin butler to be chosen for Patrick Bateman like someone that couldn’t get out of an elvis impression for 2 years probably shouldn’t play a psychopath but what do I know." Echoing the same emotion, another said, "After seeing how hard it was for Austin Butler to shake the Elvis out of his system it seems almost irresponsible to cast him for American Psycho." An X user wrote, "Austin Butler as Patrick Bateman makes me sad, however." 



 



 



 

Meanwhile, not all reactions were rash, a huge part of the Internet is celebrating his casting as the "perfect choice." One user tweeted, "Austin butler in American psycho is perfect casing, in my opinion. I’m eager to have a new favorite film." Adding onto this another said, "Anyways man Austin Butler in American Psycho is a perfect cast." 



 



 

A fan wrote, "Austin Butler is the perfect choice for American Psycho and Luca will make an incredible film. This is going to be one people talk about for decades." Talking about Butler's new look a fan tweeted, "Guys, somehow I feel that Austin with the buzz cut now is perfect for him to film the American psycho right away, somehow I think the look matches the character."



 



 

With a cast and crew of this caliber, Guadagnino’s ‘American Psycho’ is already generating major buzz. Whether Butler can deliver a performance that lives up to Bale’s iconic turn remains to be seen, but the actor’s commitment to bold roles shows he’s ready to take on the challenge.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jared Padalecki and Leighton Meester’s Netflix romance ‘Guarding Stars’ used a real Christmas parade, but one filming location is still a mystery.
2026-11-21T13:59:51.000Z
Three years after ‘Succession’ ended, Culkin and Armstrong are joining forces again for a new screen project
2026-11-21T09:00:24.000Z
Critics have raised questions about generative AI in the film, while Fincher has shared his views on the technology
2026-11-21T08:20:09.000Z
Culkin pitched Kevin as a father locked out of his own house at a 2025 anniversary event
2026-11-21T04:30:35.000Z
The film makes some major changes to Suzanne Collins' novel, including a shocking death that changes Haymitch's journey.
2026-11-20T12:35:13.000Z
Nick Jonas plays a Manhattan bachelor whose carefree routine takes a turn when he becomes responsible for a baby
2026-11-20T09:32:34.000Z
A ‘Hulk War’ reveal gives Tony Stark a monstrous new name and a body bigger than the Infernal Hulk
2026-11-20T07:27:39.000Z
The trailer for 'Ice Age: Boiling Point' promises plenty of dinosaurs and lava
2026-11-20T03:30:59.000Z
The latest 'Hunger Games' prequel revisits Haymitch's brutal Second Quarter Quell and reunites Jennifer Lawrence, Josh Hutcherson and Woody Harrelson.
2026-11-19T19:35:05.000Z
Jeff Bezos reveals why he personally backed Robert Pattinson for James Bond after the actor impressed during screen tests.
2026-11-19T13:01:29.000Z