‘DWTS’ judges slammed for playing favorites with two couples in particular on 'Hair Metal Night'

'DWTS' Season 33's 'Hair Metal night' saw two shocking double eliminations
'DWTS' Season 33's 'Hair Metal Night' episode included anthemic classic rock (@abc)
'DWTS' Season 33's 'Hair Metal Night' episode included anthemic classic rock (@abc)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: During 'Dancing With the Stars' Season 33's 'Hair Metal Night' episode, the scoring by the judges raised fans' suspicions who felt a certain bias displayed in the scoring. The night included some anthemic classic rock, and even featured guest judge Gene Simmons of KISS who made headlines for all the wrong reasons, along with complicated routines to timeless rock hits.

One of the major complaints was that some contestants scored way higher than others when they clearly made blatant mistakes. For instance, Jenn Tran's performance was full of energy and rock attitude, but it had many technical flaws that should have been reflected in her score. Yet the judges seemed to go easy on her, and many felt like her popularity might have come into play with the judges' scores. Meanwhile, Brooks Nader and her partner Gleb Savchenko got high-energy praise and higher scores, including Gene Simmons even trying to give them the season's first perfect score, which brings up even more questions about impartiality. More importantly, the judges appeared to be more interested in some contestants' charisma and stage presence over others, which worked to disadvantage those contestants who were indeed more technically sound. This inconsistency in judging criteria sparked suspicion that the panel may favor contestants based on personality and appeal to fans rather than based on dance merit alone. This could surely affect viewer trust in the show's outcome as the season progresses.

Who got the highest score on 'DWTS' Hair Metal Night?

During the Hair Metal Night episode of 'Dancing with the Stars' on October 8, 2024, model Brooks Nader was top for the night. Guest judge Gene Simmons gave her a 10 for her performance -- the first time the season had seen the perfect score. It was then clarified that Simmons had actually keyed in a 9.

Nader delivered an energetic performance, and Simmons complimented her personality and vibe, adding it was great even if not the most technically spot-on.

Ilona Maher got the most scores (@abc)
Brooks Nader got the most scores on 'DWTS' Hair Metal Night (@abc)


Who received the lowest score on 'DWTS' Hair Metal Night?

Rugby star Ilona Maher received the worst score on Hair Metal Night. Ilona struggled through the choreography, noticeably making several mistakes in jiving to 'Cum On Feel the Noize'.

The judges were supportive, but her footwork and rhythm issues did diminish from her performance. With her passion and energy, she still managed to get a score of 26 out of 40, which was the lowest of the night. During this emotive performance, Ilona was in tears, but the judges encouraged her to come back strong next week.

Ilona Maher received the lowest score (@abc)
Ilona Maher received the lowest score (@abc)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Katie and Victor got into a heated exchange during the finale, with neither backing down from their claims
2026-11-20T03:07:04.000Z
‘The Traitors: New Blood’ fans have more than a winner to look forward to as NBC shares news about the show’s future
2026-11-19T19:19:13.000Z
The show follows a group of women and their partners as they navigate friendships, relationships, and secrets
2026-11-19T08:38:53.000Z
After completing the Route Info Task, the teams had to kayak to the Pit Stop
2026-11-19T05:04:45.000Z
Aaryn Williams expressed regret about the 2013 controversy as she spoke to her husband, Nick Williams, in Episode 1
2026-11-19T04:06:27.000Z
The remaining castaways took part in an endurance test to secure immunity in Season 51 Episode 9
2026-11-19T03:15:37.000Z
Christine Quinn and Heather Rae El Moussa return as ‘Selling Sunset’ Season 10 introduces new agents and says goodbye to familiar faces.
2026-11-18T16:02:58.000Z
The reality competition has a new streaming home and a new host, who has some thoughts on its revamped format
2026-11-18T11:30:13.000Z
‘Grey's Anatomy’ star Harry Shum Jr. chose a meaningful song from his 'Glee' days for his 'DWTS' semifinals performance that earned a perfect score
2026-11-18T08:01:23.000Z
The remaining five celebrity dance couples will be featured in the highly anticipated ‘DWTS’ Season 35 finale.
2026-11-18T05:11:46.000Z