'Doctor Odyssey' opens strong but fans have a bizarre problem with the way the cast 'looks'

Ryan Murphy's latest procedural drama 'Doctor Odyssey' debuted with first episode on ABC, on September 26
UPDATED SEP 27, 2024
'Doctor Odyssey' opens to negative reviews from fans on social media (Disney/@tinathorpe)
'Doctor Odyssey' opens to negative reviews from fans on social media (Disney/@tinathorpe)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Joshua Jackson starrer 'Doctor Odyssey' premiered on ABC on Thursday, September 26 amid high expectations and strong online chatter. Created by Ryan Murphy and Jon Robin Baitz, the procedural drama revolves around a medical team's ordeals and hustle to deal with unique emergencies on board a luxury cruise ship.

'Doctor Odyssey' Episode 1 introduced us to Dr Max (Joshua Jackson), an extremely dashing healthcare provider who boasts an exceptional resume that includes experience with the Peace Corps and the United Nations. Soon after we are introduced to his nurses Avery (Phillipa Soo) and Tristan (Sean Teale), their first medical hurdle comes up a case of Iodine poisoning from the overconsumption of shrimp cocktail. The episode is loaded with rush, hotness, and heart-to-heart conversations and yet it seems to have missed the mark.

Fans expected 'more' from 'Doctor Odyssey'

Don Johnson, Joshua Jackson, Sean Teale, and Phillipa Soo in 'Doctor Odyssey' (@disney)
Don Johnson, Joshua Jackson, Sean Teale, and Phillipa Soo in 'Doctor Odyssey' (@disney)

Fans had high expectations from 'Doctor Odyssey', primarily because it's a Ryan Murphy show and secondly because it's led by 'Dawson's Creek' star. However, from the debut episode, it appears that the show may have missed the opportunity of becoming the next fan-favorite show.

Expressing disappointment, a fan wrote on X, "'Doctor Odyssey' just felt empty like just a bunch of hot people with romance drama on a ship which is fair for people who like it, but I didn’t vibe with it", while another fan added, "'Doctor Odyssey' didn’t hit like I hoped it would which is a shame because it’s Phillipa Soo and Joshua Jackson lol."



 



 

A fan said, "I was expecting something more from it and just wasn’t there."

The negative reviews come as a shocker as Ryan Murphy, whose another procedural drama '9-1-1' has delivered seven successful seasons and is awaiting the release of Season 8 on ABC.



 

Fans feel frustrated with alleged 'AI-Generated' background'

Joshua Jackson in 'Doctor Odyssey' (@disney)
Joshua Jackson in 'Doctor Odyssey' (@disney)

The scenic backdrop of the luxury ship in the middle of the ocean may not have impressed a lot of fans. An X user wrote, "Can’t stand the background, looks AI generated so distracting. Too many emergencies in one show focus on two per episode and build the characters. So pace yourself. Is the show a drama or a comedy? It was very sugary and cutesy. I don’t think it’ll last."

Agreeing to this, someone else added, "I completely agree it won't last and way over-hyped..Total Snooze-Fest. Noticed the AI generated background right away."



 



 

An unhappy fan said, "I wanted to like this show so much but it’s a big no! For me lol." "My goodness 'Doctor Odyssey' is terrible," added another viewer of the show.



 



 

'Doctor Odyssey' will have weekly release with a fresh episode dropping every Thursday, only on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

MORE STORIES

A forgotten friend becomes a key threat as Erica Sinclair’s past comes crashing into the final season’s hilarious mission.
4 hours ago
A year after its breakout debut, the medical drama gears up for a high-stakes return, with tensions ready to erupt inside Pittsburgh’s busiest ER.
7 hours ago
'Maxton Hall' Season 3 was officially greenlit in June 2025, and now some leaked photos offer clues about what may happen
16 hours ago
Episode 5 of 'Pluribus', titled 'Got Milk', saw an unexpected cameo from a 'Better Call Saul' star
22 hours ago
There will be no new episode of ‘Ghosts’ Season 5 on November 27, 2025, due to Thanksgiving holiday.
1 day ago
Here are the 5 shows that will make you feel like you’re in a different universe as ‘Pluribus.’ 
1 day ago
'Percy Jackson and the Olympians' Season 2 is scheduled to premiere in December, on Disney+ and Hulu
1 day ago
Unlike last season, there will be no Thanksgiving episode in 'Georgie and Mandy's First Marriage' Season 2
1 day ago
There have been multiple fan theories talking about Carol's discovery in the previous episode
1 day ago
The Thanksgiving Day Thursday slate on NBC will instead see NFL Thanksgiving Game Day
1 day ago