Carrie Underwood's ‘American Idol’ BTS video draws heat for ‘disrespecting’ a music icon: ‘She's no...’

Looks like Carrie Underwood just can’t catch a break — every move is under a microscope amid whispers she might skip ‘American Idol’ Season 24
Screenshots of Carrie Underwood from an 'American Idol' behind-the-scenes video (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @carrieunderwood)
Screenshots of Carrie Underwood from an 'American Idol' behind-the-scenes video (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @carrieunderwood)

'American Idol' Season 23 has finally come to a close with Jamal Roberts winning this season's ultimate title. Carrie Underwood was season 23's latest addition to the panel of judges, replacing Katy Perry as the latest judge. However, since Underwood's first appearance on the show, there has been growing animosity amongst fans against the former 'Idol' winner. While some fans state she doesn't seem interested in the show, others have a problem with her personal politics. Now, Underwood is facing criticism yet again for performing Whitney Houston's 'I Wanna Dance With Somebody (Who Loves Me)'. W


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood)


 

In a behind-the-scenes video of 'American Idol', Underwood was seen performing Houston's iconic song as the 'American Idol' judge was getting her makeup done sitting on the judges' table. Whitney Houston's official YouTube account even reuploaded the clip on their official YouTube page with the caption, "Whitney Houston—Carrie Underwood feels like dancing with somebody on American Idol!" However, fans didn't take kindly to this.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Carrie Underwood (@carrieunderwood)


 

"Girl, Whitney Houston would not like your MAGA a**," one fan wrote on X (formerly Twitter), as reported by Parade. Other fans took to Instagram to raise their concern about Underwood's behavior as they wrote, "I voted for her on American Idol and was a fan, but something started to make me dislike her phony, fake self." Another user shared this sentiment as they wrote, "I didn’t think there was anyone who could reck that song, what the heck? She needs to stick to her genre." A few even found this disrespectful to Houston, as one wrote, "She's no Whitney. This is so disrespectful." Another added, "Whitney Houston is crying rn!"



 

While everyone flocked to berate Underwood, there were also some voices of reason. "So, I guess no one is allowed to sing in their car to ANY Whitney song? Get a life, people," one fan wrote. "Carri can sing anything she wants there’s nothing that says she can’t do it you guys are so prejudiced and jealous shut your mouths." One fan wrote under Underwood's clip of her singing the song. "And Carrie sings along with all songs. She's beautiful and a great singer!!! Leave her alone!"



 

That said, this is not the first time Underwood is performing a Whitney Houston song. She performed Houston's iconic ballad 'I Will Always Love You' with Dolly Parton as a duet. Underwood even performed the song along with Martina McBride, Kacey Musgraves, Jennifer Nettles, and Reba McEntire as a tribute to Dolly Parton. Parton originally wrote and recorded the song. Whitney Houston went on to cover the song, which became one of her all-time classics.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Charles’ British rival makes a poor first impression as the ‘Only Murders in the Building’ Season 6 trailer previews the trio’s London case.
2026-11-17T17:50:47.000Z
An alien offer of peace clashes with Thomas Wade’s warning in the first ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2 teaser ahead of its Netflix return.
2026-11-17T16:27:21.000Z
‘Line of Fire’ Episode 8 takes Nia’s investigation in a new direction as another killing pushes her to seek Jane’s help.
2026-11-17T14:03:00.000Z
Sonny has a breakthrough in the latest episode when he discovers Tracey, Ellen's long-lost sister
2026-11-17T09:01:57.000Z
Jubal helps Nikki hunt for a former asset who vanished with his family from a quiet suburban street
2026-11-17T08:05:38.000Z
Amaury Nolasco takes over the role previously played by Juan Francisco Villa, with his character set to bring major complications to Baez's family
2026-11-17T07:09:32.000Z
Scola and Nina face a major relationship crossroads on 'FBI' as John Boyd addresses his future on the show
2026-11-17T06:36:49.000Z
Steve Carell, John Krasinski and 14 other ‘The Office’ stars will reunite for NBC’s three-hour anniversary broadcast, alongside Tina Fey and other familiar faces.
2026-11-17T05:33:47.000Z
Several actors, including Benedict Wong, will reprise their roles in ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2
2026-11-17T05:01:11.000Z
A shortened 13-episode order puts the Max Thieriot drama on a very different calendar than last season
2026-11-17T04:14:04.000Z