Aubrey Plaza became a 'Hot Ones' legend with one wild moment that we never saw coming

Fans couldn’t get enough of Aubrey Plaza’s wild antics, as she turned up the heat on 'Hot Ones'
PUBLISHED FEB 18, 2025
A screenshot of Aubrey Plaza from the 'Hot Ones' segment on 'First We Feast' June 20, 2019 (Cover Image Source: YouTube| First We Feast)
A screenshot of Aubrey Plaza from the 'Hot Ones' segment on 'First We Feast' June 20, 2019 (Cover Image Source: YouTube| First We Feast)

'Parks & Recreation' alum Aubrey Plaza created history on YouTube by trending to the number one spot in 2019 with her wild antics while appearing on First We Feast's 'Hot Ones' segment with social media star Sean Evans. The show is renowned for placing guests in a tricky scenario where they must respond to questions while consuming ten spicy chicken wings. As per The Things, during the episode, Evans and Plaza turned to confront the paranormal, her ascent to fame, and intimate inquiries. But as the questions progressed, the hot wings got spicer, and the 'White Lotus' actress did the unthinkable and chugged a glass of milk, even snorting it to cool her taste buds. 



 

The crazy stunt has since raked in 24 million views on the streaming giant, fans couldn't get enough of her witty remarks and funny anecdotes. "She set the bar as the coolest guest. Hard to top that one," an X user complimented. "The sarcasm levels were through the roof! Loved this episode," a fan chimed. "Killed it. I was dying it went in through the nose and out the mouth," an online user agreed. 



 



 



 

"I need more people snorting things on hot ones," another fan joked. "Fantastic episode. Possibly the best this season. @evilhag is a true entertainer and so genuine," an online user gushed. Evans celebrated the viral moment on X by tweeting about the video trending on the platform. "Aubrey Plaza snorting milk No. 1 on the YouTube charts," he wrote along with crying face emojis. 



 



 



 

During the interview, in response to a question about whether she believed in ghosts, Plaza narrated a funny yet eerie story about her dead cat coming back to life. "Yeah, I believe in ghosts. My cat was hit by a car and then a couple of weeks later crawled right out of the cemetery right back onto our back deck and um you know when that happens you just have to let it inside and go like cool I wonder if this is like your seventh life or your ninth one," she said. She also confessed to being tricked into performing a stand-up act before landing the role in 'Park & Recreation'. 



 

In September 2024, Plaza raised the heat by performing an ASMR video while promoting her new Marvel show - 'Agatha All Along'. She proceeded to lick a knife by creating a stimulus sound on the microphone. According to The Guardian, Plaza's deadpan brand of humor has earned her the nickname "crazy." One casting director even called her "the weirdest girl I've ever met." However, the 'My Old Ass' actress confessed that she was a normal person in real life and deeply cared about what people thought about her. 

Aubrey Plaza at AOL Studios on June 21, 2016, in NYC. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Jenny Anderson)
Aubrey Plaza at AOL Studios on June 21, 2016, in NYC. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by Jenny Anderson)

Despite her funny moments trending on YouTube, she maintained that people mistook her shyness and awkwardness for eccentricity. “Maybe it confuses people that I just don’t take things that seriously. You see actors all the time who take themselves so seriously and you’re like, ‘Oh my God, you’re talking about a movie. I try not to lose that spirit because it’s got me where I am today,” she concluded. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'NCIS: Sydney' was supposed to air the ninth episode of its third season on Tuesday, December 16
15 minutes ago
The new season will premiere January 8 with plenty of chaos in the ER
12 hours ago
The sitcom premiered this November, and has fast become one of the network and streamer's best shows
13 hours ago
The Bethesda boss was widely expected to make an appearance at some point in season 1
16 hours ago
After months of setbacks, CBS has finally unveiled the first trailer for 'CIA', signaling the 'FBI' spinoff is officially back on track
20 hours ago
Emily is heading to Rome in 'Emily in Paris' Season 5, and the drama promises to be spicier than ever
23 hours ago
Netflix cancels ‘Boots’ after one season, ending the coming-of-age queer military drama despite strong viewership and cultural buzz
23 hours ago
Dexter is coming back sooner than expected, and a new serial killer is about to cross his path
1 day ago
The hit series starring Ella Purnell now releases a day earlier than the originally announced date
1 day ago