'American Idol' 2023: Katy Perry slammed for 'gaslighting' Matt Wilson as she falsely praises him

'American Idol' Season 21 contestant Matt Wilson sang 'Speechless' on Hawaii night, reliving his wedding day
'American Idol' judge Katy Perry slammed for giving false hopes to Matt Wilson (YouTube@AmericanIdol)
'American Idol' judge Katy Perry slammed for giving false hopes to Matt Wilson (YouTube@AmericanIdol)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: 'American Idol' Season 21 judge Katy Perry once again came into the limelight after being accused of "gaslighting" one of the contestants Matt Wilson. Well, it seems that instead of giving an honest review of the singer, the judge chose to praise him. Indeed, fans slammed Katy for giving false hopes.

Matt sang 'Speechless' on Hawaii night. The song reminded the singer of his wedding day, which he recalled as the "best day of his life." In order to celebrate love, the singer even brought his wife into his mentor session with Allen Stone. After Matt's performance, the judges complimented him. Katy was the one who praised the unpopular singer a little more than everyone else. Well, this seems to have instantly got caught in fans' eyes and the judge was slammed in no time for giving false hopes to budding singers.

RELATED ARTICLES

Will Katy Perry and Lionel Richie skip 'American Idol'? Stars to perform at King Charles' coronation

Katy Perry feels like a 'third wheel' in fellow 'American Idol' judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie's bromance



 

Did Katy Perry 'gaslight' Matt Wilson?

On Hawaii night, Matt chose to relive her wedding day with his wife, Melisa, who happened to cheer her husband while standing in the crowd. Even though the singing was not much liked by the fans online but Katy was sold in no time. She gave a standing ovation to the singer and showered him with praises. Listening to her praises a few fans took to the Reddit thread and asked the question, "Why are they gaslighting Matt so hard? Like… don’t encourage him as there is literally no way he can make a future with his voice. He is a fine singer in a crowd of 100, but he is not good enough." Another claimed, "He hasn’t been a huge standout to me this far, so the absolutely glowing feedback from the judges has been surprising." Another called out the singer, "I don’t get it are they trying to make being married Matt’s storyline??? It’s not a very good storyline." "matt is great but someone’s gotta teach him how to hold that mic and also tell him to keep it in front of his mouth. great vocal tho," commented a fan.



 

Katy Perry slammed for being 'ignorant' and 'unsupportive' towards contestants

This is not the first time where Katy's judgment has been slammed by the fans. The judge has been previously called out for being 'ignorant.' She recently uploaded a video where the star is seen talking with one of the contestants. The contestant Haven Madison admitted on the show, "I watch the show and I would have never even thought that it was this intense." Despite being sensitive, Katy made fun of the singer saying, "Wait 'til they put music behind this." Seeing Katy being ignorant towards the emotion, a fan commented, "You've been really snappy lately.... I hope all is well or you feel better." Another called out the judge, "That young lady is in for a rude awakening." Another fan ripped apart the judge saying, "Malicious and jealous because she is younger and more beautiful than you." "This is intense," wrote another.

‘American Idol’ Season 21 airs every Sunday and Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Mary Camden, aka Jessica Biel, talks about the storylines and the safe set she wants around the Camdens
2026-10-26T09:57:21.000Z
The show has adapted two of Jack Carr's novels so far, and the third book sends Reece to a ranch
2026-10-26T09:14:16.000Z
Show creator Erin Foster explains how her own marriage could shape Joanne and Noah’s future
2026-10-26T05:32:46.000Z
‘Tracker’ Season 4 introduces Brian Stepanek as Elias Williams, a religious fanatic whose disturbing actions lead Colter Shaw to a missing woman and a dark family secret
2026-10-26T04:57:18.000Z
After Cal finds a lead, the team is sent to investigate the potential threat, ending with a dangerous cliffhanger.
2026-10-26T04:29:43.000Z
Eddie and Susie plan a casino in the Middle East as the Netflix series returns with a changed cast.
2026-10-24T16:38:18.000Z
An unanswered call sends Sean’s girlfriend to the precinct after news of a police shooting.
2026-10-24T14:03:15.000Z
In an exclusive interview, Donnie Wahlberg shares whether Tom Selleck is open to working in ‘Boston Blue’
2026-10-24T08:19:19.000Z
‘Fire Country’ welcomes a Grammy-winning artist to Smokey's in their latest episode
2026-10-24T06:24:48.000Z
Episode 3 of ‘Sheriff Country’ delves deeper into Eva Santos's (Rachel Ticotin) past
2026-10-24T05:05:00.000Z