‘American Idol’ winner finally revealed after emotional 2025 finale — fan says 'America got it right'

"It's been season after season of nonsense for years - finally America got it right. So happy for him," a happy 'American Idol' viewer said.
UPDATED MAY 19, 2025
(L-R) Screenshots of John Foster, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
(L-R) Screenshots of John Foster, Breanna Nix and Jamal Roberts from 'American Idol' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

'American Idol' Season 23 came to a spectacular close on May 18, with finalists John Foster, Breanna Nix, and Jamal Roberts delivering jaw-dropping performances. Soon, the energy on the reality show's set got intense after Ryan Seacrest announced Nix's elimination, leaving Foster and Roberts. After stalling the viewers and increasing the nerves, finally came the moment America had been waiting for: "Dim the lights, and here we go," said Seacrest as the top two finalists stood on the stage. "The winner of American Idol is Jamal Roberts," he announced. As soon as his name left Seacrest's mouth, it sparked a wave of cheer in the audience and the judges.



 

Roberts, who sang his new hit single, 'Heal,' for his grand finale performance, garnered a roaring standing ovation from the judges, who were left stunned by his magical vocals. Fans were so happy with Roberts' win, they also took to social media to express their joy. A fan tweeted, "HE DESERVES THIS. CONGRATULATIONS, JAMAL." The YouTube comment section was also flooded. One 'American Idol' viewer wrote, "Magical voice, congratulations for winning tonight, well deserved. I am in. I'm 70 and cry every time I hear your beautiful voice. Stay safe and enjoy your family!" Echoing Jamal's social media popularity and adoring his voice, a netizen wrote, "I haven't watched American Idol for years because I felt it catered more to the judges than the contestants. However, I'm glad to see this young man win. He is truly a great talent. I got chills just listening to him here on Twitter."



 

"Jamal’s voice has so much weight to it, I couldn’t even explain the feeling I get when I hear him sing! With every one of his performances, I’ve had full-body chills and tears brought to my eyes. This man is something beyond special. God bless him," a fan wrote. Celebrating Jamal's win, a viewer said, "It's been season after season of nonsense for years - finally America got it right !!! so happy for him!" 



 

Not many know it was not his first attempt at the show. In a recent interview with Billboard, ahead of the finale, the 27-year-old P.E. teacher revealed that he had auditioned to be on the show twice before. But he did not cut the first time because the judges told him he needed more vocal training, and the second time because he didn't have enough material the second go-round.



 

Not the one to give up easily, Roberts shared, "I didn’t get defeated," he said. "I never gave up. I took the number. I’ve always been able to take constructive criticism and use it for my gain and try again. This has always been me." Roberts has proved by example that with persistence, one can achieve anything. He has been an inspiration not only to the Meridian community and his students at the Crestwood Elementary School but also to the numerous hopefuls who come to the show year after year with a hope to win the 'Idol' trophy.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Fans will need to wait a bit longer for Mateo Diaz, one of the recurring characters from season 1
9 hours ago
HBO Max renewed the series for a second season just after the fourth episode aired
9 hours ago
Following the controversial 'Squid Games' ending, Hwang Dong-hyuk signs another deal with Netflix for his show 'The Dealer.'
10 hours ago
The series will comprise six episodes, and has already been renewed for a second season
10 hours ago
'Percy Jackson and the Olympians' Season 2 finale promises big twists, with high expectations as the cast promotes the last episode
11 hours ago
'Euphoria' is back with its third season after a long four-year hiatus due to multiple challenges faced by HBO's top show.
11 hours ago
A jaw-dropping twist left viewers reeling and questioning Billy Bob Thornton’s future on 'Landman', but there’s more to the story.
11 hours ago
With 'Palm Royale' Season 2 now streaming, fans are anxiously waiting to learn if Apple TV will renew the Kristen Wiig drama for Season 3.
11 hours ago
Could we see Kate and Anthony's return in 'Bridgerton' Season 4? The subtle detail in the novel answers all the questions
11 hours ago
Marvel fans are dissecting the 'Wonder Man' teaser after a small detail links to a wider Thunderbolts* connection.
12 hours ago