'AGT' Season 19: Watch Joey & Jordan's unique rendition of 1994 dance hit that split the judges' panel

'AGT' Season 19 fans criticize NBC for allowing Joey & Jordan, likening their singing to that of a local bar duo
Joey & Jordan's 'Cotton Eyed Joe' rendition gets big thumbs down from 'AGT' Season 19 fans (@nbc/@traepatton)
Joey & Jordan's 'Cotton Eyed Joe' rendition gets big thumbs down from 'AGT' Season 19 fans (@nbc/@traepatton)

PASADENA, CALIFORNIA: Joey and Jordan, hailing from Wyoming and Los Angeles respectively, have been friends for six years. They showcased their bluegrass talents this week on Season 19 of 'America's Got Talent'. While the judges were divided in their votes, their performance failed to win over internet followers.

Following their traumatic breakups, the two found solace in performing bluegrass music together. During their Season 19 audition, they performed "Cotton Eyed Joe".



 

One of the vocalists climbed onto the other's shoulders to sing while playing an upright bass. Unfortunately, the vocals were less than stellar, and the poor guy struggled to get back down to the floor.

On X, one fan described the duo, saying, "I’d like to see that in the local bar, but not the big stage I’m afraid." Another added, "Some people SHOULDNT sing."



 



 

One fan wrote, "Okay, why are we singing Cotton-eye Joe? That's not for the talent show. More like a square dance." Another fan quipped, "New tag line for the show “it beats the local bar”."



 



 

One fan noted, "I was gonna be excited when they said blue grass but they just suck." Another gasped, "Wait a minute. What are those guys doing?"



 



 

Joey & Jordan get booted despite 'AGT' Season 19 judges' Yesses

Sofia Vergara appeared to smell something unpleasant, while Simon Cowell found it amusing. Simon highlighted that the best part of their performance was the climbing. Howie Mandel concurred. However, Sofia and Heidi Klum both voted no, resulting in the duo's elimination from the competition.

'AGT' Season 19 is structured into two parts, mirroring previous seasons: Auditions and Live Shows. To qualify for the Live Shows, an act must receive at least three 'Yes' votes from the judges following their performance to avoid elimination.

'Acts face elimination if they receive more than one red X vote. Alternatively, an act can advance directly to the Live Shows if they receive a Golden Buzzer from a judge. Joey & Jordan, having received only two votes, were eliminated directly from the audition round.

'AGT' Season 19 judges find Joey & Jordan's act amusing (NBC)
'AGT' Season 19 judges find Joey & Jordan's act amusing (@nbc)

Who are Joey & Jordan in 'AGT' Season 19?

Also known as Baxter Elkins, Joey & Jordan is an American music duo from Echo Park, California. They released an album titled 'Hard Times and Hootenannies' in March.

'AGT' Season 19 musician duo Joey & Jordan (Facebook/baxterelkinsmusic)
'AGT' Season 19 musician duo Joey & Jordan released an album titled 'Hard Times and Hootenannies' in March (Facebook/@baxterelkinsmusic)

When will 'AGT' Season 19 Live Show air?

Once the season's Live Shows begin, 'AGT' Season 19 will screen one-hour Live Results episodes on Wednesdays at 8/7c. Please see the schedule for 2024 below:

Live Shows: Every Tuesday and Wednesday, August 13 - September 18

'AGT' Season 18 judges (Instagram/agt)
'AGT' Season 19 Live Shows to begin from August 13 (Instagram/@agt)

Stream 'America's Got Talent' Season 19 airs on Tuesdays on NBC at 8 PM ET.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

After the Boston reunion, casting calls and restaurant sightings offer fresh clues about where Netflix’s ‘Love Is Blind’ could head for Season 12.
2026-11-09T18:29:01.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Boston weddings and reunion aired four days apart on Netflix, but there’s more than a year of cast history between those episodes.
2026-11-09T16:23:06.000Z
Ashe takes on the ‘Love Is Blind’ reunion stage to perform a fitting song
2026-11-09T09:55:24.000Z
Benita arrived at the reunion with an engagement ring and surprised everyone
2026-11-09T08:34:59.000Z
John and Sarah were the only couple to get married on ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11
2026-11-09T07:02:42.000Z
The two dated after Michaella’s engagement with Rob ended at the pod squad’s mixer.
2026-11-09T06:34:12.000Z
Sarah and John were the only couple to get married on the ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 finale.
2026-11-09T04:14:32.000Z
Janelle and her boyfriend shed light on their first date in the latest episode of the show
2026-11-09T03:27:31.000Z
‘The Bachelor’ is set to return after almost two years since its last season on air
2026-11-07T11:25:50.000Z
The ‘Love Is Blind’ Season 11 cast has more to unpack, and here’s what to know about catching the reunion before its Netflix release.
2026-11-05T19:30:37.000Z