'AGT' 17: Fans slam Simon Cowell for judging 'pole dancer' Kristy Sellars before her performance

'Love this! Loved Simon being put in his place too and then standing to clap. So quick to judge and ended up eating humble pie real quick,' said a fan
Australian dancer Kristy Sellars on 'America's Got Talent' Season 17 (AGT/ YouTube)
Australian dancer Kristy Sellars on 'America's Got Talent' Season 17 (AGT/ YouTube)

Love him or hate him, there's no debating over Simon Cowell being an excellent judge of talents! Over the years the 'America's Got Talent' judge has earned a reputation for doling out really harsh critcism to performers on the talent hunt show, as well as his occassional generosity with compliments towards some of the acts. When Australian dancer and mother-of-three children- Kristy Sellars stepped onto the NBC show's stage ready to showcase her pole dancing skills, Simon wasted no time in declare it as "pointless".

The judge sat back in his chair while rolling his eyes even before Kristy began her performance. Despite Simon's negative attitude and pre-judgment, Kristy remained undeterred and went on to give one of the best pole dancing performances ever seen on 'AGT'. She effortlessly fused art and story-telling into her performance, with her clever usage of animated backdrop and including it in her performance. By the time she was done, the judges including Simon were on their feet giving a standing ovation to Kristy's impeccable talent and creativity.

RELATED ARTICLES

Australian dancer Max Ostler wows judges with his performance, 'AGT' fans say 'he is on wrong show'

'AGT' 17: Simon Cowell slammed for giving 'mediocre' Sara James golden buzzer, fans say 'just not fair'

You can watch Kristy Sellars' performance here:



 

While giving his feedback to Kristy, Simon admitted that he wasn't excited to watch yet another pole dancer on the show, but Kristy's ability to add a story to her performance left him bowled. All the four judges unanimously gave a resounding yes to the Australian dancer and expressed their interest in seeing what she would do next. After watching Simon do a 180 on his opinion about Kristy's performance, several fans took to the show's YouTube page to slam him for judging Kristy without watching her performance.

A fan commented, "Lot of us know Simon is a really good talent finder and I give him that credit for sure but I don’t understand why he still giving hard time to some clients by his body languages or his speech before they start, even though Simon got surprised many times after he underestimated some clients before they perform. Please don’t judge them before their performances start Simon." "Simon is always too quick to judge, he's the type of guy that you wouldn't want to hang out with lol. She didn't even start performing yet and his reaction was like "eh, don't care" whilst the other judges were looking forward to it. Simon you need to judge after the performances, not before it 😂," wrote another fan. "Simon Cowell had his eye rolling Susan Boyle moment. Don't judge a person before his or her act. He should have known better," added a fan. "Love this!!! Loved Simon being put in his place too and then standing to clap.. So quick to judge and ended up eating humble pie real quick..," seconded a fan.

Fans also lauded Kristy's flawless performance which they felt "shut" Simon and his biases down. A fan shared, "She "shut" Simon up with that amazing performance. Beautiful and very creative. 🤗👍🤗." "I really dislike the attitude Simon carries and this is not just the first act that he has responded like this!! The act was PHENOMENAL 😍," pointed out a fan. "That was literally one of the most creative act's I've ever seen. Incredible! True tale of never judge a book by its cover... Simon," observed a fan. "I love how you could practically see Simon's eyes rolling back in his head before she started to giving her a standing O. That was absolutely amazing!" echoed a fan.

Simon Cowell watches Kristy Sellars' performance on 'AGT' (AGT/ YouTube)

America's Got Talent' Season 17 airs Tuesdays, at 8 pm on NBC. Following the show's premiere, you can catch all-new episodes every Tuesday from 8 to 10 p.m. ET/PT. For viewers who wish to tune in to the show without cable, they can do so using any of the following streaming services: Sling TV, fuboTV, Hulu With Live TV, AT&T TV, or YouTube TV.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Chicago Fire' Season 15 will introduce Violet's mother in an episode titled 'Over the Edge'
2026-11-03T06:27:27.000Z
The latest episode of 'FBI' hinted at trouble in paradise for a much-loved couple
2026-11-03T04:59:13.000Z
The Hulu anthology moves from the Natalia Grace adoption saga to the 1993 Bobbitt case in Season 2
2026-11-03T04:34:19.000Z
A familiar face from ‘Lost’ joins ‘Tracker’ Season 4 as a rewardist whose priorities clash with Colter Shaw’s, setting up an uneasy partnership when their assignments overlap.
2026-11-02T21:05:03.000Z
Druski brings his viral megachurch pastor to Netflix in a semi-scripted comedy co-starring Mike Epps as his deacon.
2026-11-02T17:09:22.000Z
HBO Max’s ‘Gilmore Girls’ documentary explores the show’s lasting appeal through cast interviews and never-before-seen footage.
2026-11-02T15:48:05.000Z
Emaline West is a new character who does not appear in the original Stephen King novel
2026-11-02T11:58:15.000Z
Dave Bautista, who looks unrecognizable, began weight training in September after being cast as the Norse god, following Ryan Hurst’s exit from the series
2026-11-02T09:31:15.000Z
Tovah Feldshuh addresses reports of tension on the set of ‘Nobody Wants This’ after Adam Brody’s comments on the Israel-Gaza conflict
2026-11-02T09:21:34.000Z
The HBO period drama brings two unexpected faces to its carefully recreated 1880s New York setting
2026-11-02T07:37:24.000Z