'AGT: All-Stars' 2023: Viewers slam superfans' Top 3 ranking, call them 'most AVERAGE of the night'

Saxophonist Avery Dixon made it to the final whereas Peter Antoniou, a psychic, was eliminated from the competition
UPDATED JAN 17, 2023
Peter Antoniou, Avery Dixon, and Keren Montero in 'AGT: All-Stars'  (NBC)
Peter Antoniou, Avery Dixon, and Keren Montero in 'AGT: All-Stars' (NBC)

PASADENA, CALIFORNIA: This week on 'AGT: All-Stars,' comedian Mike E Winfield, a Season 17 finalist on 'America's Got Talent,' was the lucky recipient of Simon Cowell's proceed-straight-to-the-finals Golden Buzzer. However, people are unhappy with the second act that made it to the finals week and have criticized the makers for basing it on votes from mysterious SuperFans.

The judges were ecstatic to see the Season 17 stand-up comedian return to the stage, and he did not disappoint with his act on life after 'AGT', including how fame had gone to his stepson — uh, step-— man's head. The SuperFans then concluded that Peter Antoniou, Keren Montero, and Avery Dixon were the best three acts from this week's episode. Keren dropped out of the race after coming third. The 'Dominicana's Got Talent' winner ended in third spot after singing 'Rescue' by Lauren Daigle.

RELATED ARTICLES

'AGT: All-Stars' 2023: Fans thank Simon Cowell as mentalist Peter Antoniou gets 'much-needed red buzzer'

'AGT: All Stars' 2023: Avery Dixon's 'Happy' performance makes Simon Cowell 'almost' hit Golden Buzzer

Terry Crews, Peter Antoniou, Keren Montero, and Avery Dixon in 'AGT: All-Stars' (NBC)
Terry Crews, Peter Antoniou, Keren Montero, and Avery Dixon in 'AGT: All-Stars' (NBC)

Saxophonist Avery Dixon made it to the final whereas Peter Antoniou, a psychic, was eliminated from the competition.

Fans on Reddit were shocked to see the ranking as they write, "ARE YOU SERIOUS! How do Viviana and Keiichi not make the Top 3?! THIS IS BS!" Unhappy with the act that made it into the finals, another person wrote, "Avery is overrated." Calling Avery a 'good recovery' a user wrote, "Avery is a good recovery, but Kechii or Bir Khalsa were robbed." Calling them the trio the most 'average' of the night, a Redditor commented, "My ranking for the night didn't outright HATE any of those acts, but they were certainly the most AVERAGE three of the night. Viviana, Keiichi, and Bir Khalsa were far and away the best of the night. At least Avery was the best of those three."



 



 



 



 

Seeing Peter making it to the top 3 despite getting buzzed by Simon, confused fans wrote, "Who the hell picked this top 3? Is there a wildcard?" Another person added, "Peter possibly advancing is embarrassing." Disappointed at the SuperFans, another person wrote, "Wow, these fans are idiots." Feeling sorry for the Bir Khalsa group, one Redditor wrote, "I’M SORRY THOSE MEN JUST SMASHED WATERMELONS AND COCONUTS WHAT DID EVERYONE ELSE DO."



 



 



 



 

'America's Got Talent: All-Stars' airs every Monday at 8/7c on NBC.

This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online.

RELATED TOPICS AMERICA'S GOT TALENT (2006)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The six-episode thriller series starring Thompson and Bernthal releases on January 8, 2026
6 hours ago
Idris Elba reprises his role as the negotiator, this time in a different mode of transport
8 hours ago
Anson Mount shared an album on social media that put Spock and Pike in focus
9 hours ago
'Pushing Daisies' premiered on ABC in 2007 and ran for two seasons before being cancelled in 2008
11 hours ago
While you wait for Glen Powell’s ‘Chad Powers’, all six episodes of Season 1 are available for streaming on Hulu
11 hours ago
'Ripple' chronicles the lives of four strangers living in New York City who develop a newfound sense of fraternity
14 hours ago
Mickey Haller is on the defense of his life as Netflix confirms ‘The Lincoln Lawyer’ Season 4 will return in early 2026
16 hours ago
The film unites Spielberg with several of his long-time collaborators, including David Koepp, the writer behind the screenplay for 'War of the Worlds'
17 hours ago
A fan-favorite star is returning to CBS, and his high-stakes cameo on 'Ghosts' may unravel more chaos than anyone living or dead is ready for
18 hours ago
The new instalment introduces Miya Cech's Toph Beifong in live-action for the first time.
1 day ago