'American Idol’ fans deem Julia Gagnon's 'Rock and Roll Hall of Fame' performance 'unauthentic,' question her longevity
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: Fans of 'American Idol' Season 22 expressed disappointment with Julia Gagnon's recent performance at the 'Rock and Roll Hall of Fame' night, feeling that it fell short of expectations. Some were unimpressed, expressing doubts about her ability to progress further in the competition. Julia chose to sing "Run to You" by Whitney Houston, a challenging song that impressed the judges with her vocal prowess. However, despite the judges' positive feedback, some fans found her rendition to be lacking authenticity.
"Wasn’t impressed, if you gone perform a Queen Whitney Houston song you gotta sing it like the worlds watching, nice effort though Julia you were brave," said a user on X. "This lady cosplaying what she thinks a black singer is really irritates me. She's a phony and it's weird that she's made it this far along into the competition. Julia will not make it in music because she's inauthentic and borderline minstrel," said another.
Wasn’t impressed, if you gone preform a Queen Whitney Houston song you gotta sing it like the worlds watching, nice effort though Julia you were brave #AmericanIdol
— Lester walnuts (@LesterWalnuts) April 22, 2024
#AmericanIdol #Idol
— Duke Loves Rasslin (@DLovesRasslin) April 22, 2024
This lady cosplaying what she thinks a black singer is really irritates me. She's a phony and it's weird that she's made it this far along into the competition. Julia will not make it in music because she's inauthentic and borderline minstrel.
Some attacked the singer for using her past stories for clout. "Not voting for #Julia. So sick of the poor me crap. She has had far more than most. Everyone is bullied, everyone feels they don’t belong, it’s human. To still use it as a crutch as old as she is is attention seeking & I am over it. As good as she is, nope." "Everyone so far has been great except Julia," said one. :Julia was one of my favs but she is starting to lose it," added another.
#AmericanIdol Not voting for #Julia. So sick of the poor me crap. She has had far more than most. Everyone is bullied, everyone feels they don’t belong, it’s human. To still use it as a crutch as old as she is is attention seeking & I am over it. As good as she is, nope.
— Kim (@LoveLakeLifeKim) April 22, 2024
Everyone so far has been great except Julia #AmericanIdol
— ~*Tavia*~ (@ItsTaviBaby24) April 22, 2024
Julia was one of my favs but she is starting to lose it. #AmericanIdol
— Trin 😊 (@trin_j20) April 22, 2024
Ryan Seacrest surprises Julia Gagnon on stage
During her performance, Julia Gagnon disclosed that she dedicated the song to her fiancé. Host Ryan Seacrest further revealed that he had been on a Facetime call with Julia's fiancé while she was singing on stage.
Julia made a heartfelt decision to pay homage to her fiancé, deeply moved by his unwavering love and support throughout their journey together. Despite her own struggles with self-acceptance and perception, she felt thankful for his unconditional love, which remained steadfast even during her darkest moments.
Katy Perry appreciates Julia Gagnon's 'confidence'
Katy Perry praised Julia for her newfound confidence, acknowledging that confidence is a choice and tonight, Julia decided to embrace it fully. “Confidence is a mental decision and you decided tonight to switch it on," she said.
Luke observed that Julia transformed like a butterfly emerging from a cocoon during her performance. Lionel emphasized that to earn respect, one must exude command, and Julia did just that on stage. “If you want respect you have to command, and you commanded that stage," he said. Even Gene Simmons recognized Julia's star quality after she shared her struggles with confidence regarding her appearance.
'American Idol' Season 22 airs on Sundays and Mondays at 8 pm ET on ABC.