'Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist' Episode 9: Is Max toxic for Zoey? Fans say not just that, he is also a douche

Max has not been subtle when it comes to his feelings for Zoey, let it be via his inner emotions when he breaks out into a song or just telling her how he feels
Zoey Clarke, Max (NBC)
Zoey Clarke, Max (NBC)

Is Max getting a little toxic with his feelings for Zoey? Well, fans sure think so.

'Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist' Season 1 returned on Sunday night for Episode 9 titled 'Zoey's Extraordinary Silence'. While everything was back to normal for Zoey when it came to her superpower, in reality, things weren't all that great for her this week. 

Last week, we saw Zoey face a glitch when it came to her powers. She sang Jason Mraz's 'I'm Yours' to Max, and then went on to sing 'I Want You To Want Me' to Simon, which ended with them kissing. 

Picking up right where they left off, the next day Zoey is depressed not knowing what to do. But she is determined to get clarity from Simon. Sadly, he doesn't seem to know what he wants. Simon is torn between Jessica and Zoey. Meanwhile, on the other hand, Max is still upset with Zoey. 

Max has not been subtle when it comes to his feelings for Zoey. Let it be via his emotions when he breaks out into a song or just telling her how he feels, especially in the recent episodes. But Zoey is definitely confused since her feelings still lead her toward Simon. "I just feel like the universe keeps pointing me to Max, but if that's the case then why can't I stop thinking about Simon?" Zoey tells Mo.

Despite Zoey's feelings leaning more towards Simon, fans have always been rooting for her and Max. But, it looks like that took a turn after tonight's episode as some fans called Max toxic because of his behavior. Max gets offered a job on the 6th floor and asks Zoey if he should take it up. 

It seemed like all he wanted was for Zoey to confess her love for him and hold him back. But instead, Zoey told him to follow his heart because as much as she would miss sitting across from him, she can't stop him. Max doesn't like the answer and storms away. 

Taking to Twitter, fans share their disappointment with his behavior. "This might be an unpopular opinion, but I think Max is a little toxic. He’s mad at Zoey for not knowing exactly what she wants, but she was honest and open about that. But it’s making me question has he only been friends with Zoey bc he wanted a relationship (sic)," a fan wrote. 

"Ok, so my feminist, well-adjusted daughter did not get why Max was upset. If she loves him, why wouldn't she want him to get that job and be successful? Why would she want him to stay behind just to be with her? She's not wrong. We raised her right," a fan shared.

While another added, "Idk if anyone else here is watching #ZoeysPlaylist but am I the only one who's not really a fan of Max? He just rubs me the wrong way...superficially, he's the nice guy-next-door type, but his actions make him more the kind of douche who believes the friendzone exists...yikes." 

"I'm not team Max because he keeps pushing it, let her come to you #ZoeysPlaylist," a fan shared.

'Zoey's Extraordinary Playlist' airs every Sunday night only on NBC. Check your local listings for more information.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Jubal helps Nikki hunt for a former asset who vanished with his family from a quiet suburban street
2026-11-17T08:05:38.000Z
Amaury Nolasco takes over the role previously played by Juan Francisco Villa, with his character set to bring major complications to Baez's family
2026-11-17T07:09:32.000Z
Scola and Nina face a major relationship crossroads on 'FBI' as John Boyd addresses his future on the show
2026-11-17T06:36:49.000Z
Steve Carell, John Krasinski and 14 other ‘The Office’ stars will reunite for NBC’s three-hour anniversary broadcast, alongside Tina Fey and other familiar faces.
2026-11-17T05:33:47.000Z
Several actors, including Benedict Wong, will reprise their roles in ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2
2026-11-17T05:01:11.000Z
A shortened 13-episode order puts the Max Thieriot drama on a very different calendar than last season
2026-11-17T04:14:04.000Z
Following ‘Dark Wolf’ and the upcoming ‘Savage Son,’ Prime Video has another Jack Carr adaptation in the works for the franchise.
2026-11-17T03:50:27.000Z
Nicola Coughlan has explained why her love for the ‘Harry Potter’ books won't bring her back to the wizarding world.
2026-11-17T03:24:16.000Z
The early order makes the Emayatzy Corinealdi-starrer the second-longest-running original drama on Hulu
2026-11-17T03:18:14.000Z
CBS confirms winter returns and new premieres, with changes ahead for ‘Matlock’, ‘Ghosts’, ‘Cupertino’ and Matthew Gray Gubler’s ‘Einstein'.
2026-11-16T20:28:45.000Z