Will Carol and Zosia reunite? 'Pluribus' theories we wish would come true in season 2
The season 1 finale of 'Pluribus', titled "La Chica o El Mundo," arrived on December 24, as per Comic Book Club. And it left viewers with more questions than answers, setting the stage for an already-confirmed second season. While the finale offers a sense of emotional closure, it deliberately avoids tidy resolutions, making it clear that Carol's journey is far from over. From the beginning, 'Pluribus' has challenged audiences to wrestle with moral ambiguity. The series' central threat, an alien RNA that transforms humanity into a euphoric Hive Mind, isn't framed as purely monstrous. Life under the 'Joining' is peaceful, content, and free of conflict.
Yet the finale sharpens the show's thesis: happiness imposed from the outside, no matter how pleasant, strips humanity of its agency. Carol (Rhea Seehorn) arrives at this realization at enormous personal cost. Over the course of the season, her resistance to the Hive indirectly leads to multiple mass casualties. By the finale, Carol understands what truly unsettles her about the hive-mind: it has stopped creating. Art, science, curiosity, the very things that once defined human identity, have vanished. That's precisely why the hive is fascinated by Carol's book. And the emotional heart of the finale lies in Carol's relationship with Zosia (Karolina Wydra).
Carol's bond with her emerges during the worst crisis of her life, following the loss of her wife and the collapse of the world she knew. Falling in love with someone who is also everyone in the Hive Mind is both comforting and deeply unsettling. Importantly, the series suggests that Zosia and the Hive did not consciously manipulate Carol. Instead, their actions are driven by the alien RNA's programming, including the plan to forcibly convert Carol using stem cells derived from her frozen eggs. When Carol learns the truth, Zosia and the other Joined leave her behind, as per DMT. That separation raises lingering questions about identity and consent. Who is Zosia without the infection?
Would she still choose Carol if she were fully human? The finale doesn't answer these questions, but it implies that Carol may have avoided seeking those answers because, for the first time in her life, she experienced sustained happiness. Season 2 is expected to revisit that unresolved emotional thread. Carol's frozen eggs, in particular, remain a looming mystery. While the Hive intended to use them to create stem cells, it's unclear whether that plan is even viable. If it isn't, the eggs may become leverage, or bait, setting up a potential rescue mission that forces Carol back into direct conflict with the Hive.
Meanwhile, Manousos remains the most volatile wildcard. Immune to the alien RNA and uniquely attuned to the strange radio transmissions that bind the Hive together, he understands the technical weakness holding the collective consciousness intact. His willingness to commit mass violence in the finale proves just how dangerous that knowledge can be. Yet he may also be humanity's best hope. Carol and Manousos now represent two extremes: empathy and annihilation. Season 2 will likely hinge on whether they can find a path that dismantles the Hive without erasing what remains of humanity in the process.
