An ‘American Idol’ singer started crying after fumbling lyrics — but Katy Perry saved the whole moment

Hunter Metts couldn't stop crying after forgetting ‘Falling Slowly’ lyrics on ‘American Idol’ but Katy Perry had the perfect response
PUBLISHED APR 7, 2025
Screenshots of Katy Perry and contestant Hunter Metts from 'American Idol' episode April 2021 (Cover Image Source: YouTube| Talent Recap)
Screenshots of Katy Perry and contestant Hunter Metts from 'American Idol' episode April 2021 (Cover Image Source: YouTube| Talent Recap)

Hunter Metts, a singer-songwriter from Franklin, Tennessee, remains one of the most notable contestants on 'American Idol' Season 19. Sadly, Metts was eliminated during the Mother's Day round, despite finishing among the top seven judges' and audience's favorites. During his time on the show, the young software engineer experienced an intense moment and openly broke down on the live stage after fumbling with the lyrics. Metts couldn't hold back after he lost the words to his rendition of Glen Hansard and Markéta Irglová's 'Falling Slowly' while honoring the Oscar-nominated song during the Academy Awards month, USA Today reported. Katy Perry instantly consoled him, saying, "Hunter, perfection is an illusion. It doesn't matter," she said. 



 

"Hunter, that was the best performance you have ever given," she comforted. "That shows that you are human and vulnerable. It's amazing. It's emotional, and that's what music is," she added. "I know this is a lot of pressure, but it's not about perfection, it's about resonating with people and you just did," she continued. Perry commended his song choice and reassured him that he had struck a chord with the audience and that it was completely acceptable to sing while losing oneself in passion, People reported. "You kept your eyes open, your heart open. You were so connected that you forgot where you were, and that is perfect," she said. 

Katy Perry attends ABC's 'American Idol' - Finale on May 21, 2018, in LA, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by David Livingston)
Katy Perry attends ABC's 'American Idol' - Finale on May 21, 2018, in LA, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by David Livingston)

"Man, it was intense for me to watch you," Luke Bryan followed next in consoling Metts. "It was a series of emotions. You took me on a crazy ride. I don't even know what happened at the end. But I didn't care. You could do no wrong in that moment." Lionel Richie had a humorous, positive take on the verbal faux pas; he remarked that the little mistake had made the night even more memorable. He explained that had Metts sung the song with ease, the audience would have forgotten it over time, but since he was moved by his emotions, it will live on. "What I'm saying to you, if you had not done that, it was called a perfect run. Now that you did that, it was absolutely a perfect run."



 

During the 'American Idol' auditions, Metts charmed the judges with his rendition of Kaleo's 'All The Pretty Girls'. It was also revealed that his elder sister quit her Disney job so that he could pursue his dreams. The young artist also acknowledged that he had made two unsuccessful attempts to enter the competition. After reaching the top seven, Metts impressed the judges and Coldplay's frontman, Chris Martin, with his powerful performance of 'Everglow' during the Mother's Day round. For the second round, he chose 'The River', an original track composed by him, ScreenRant reported. 



 

Metts posted a farewell note on his social media minutes after being eliminated, and fan expressed their concern over his mental health. "I don’t know how I feel about him having posted on Instagram at 10:03 pm tonight, saying thank you and farewell. Dude was apparently on his Insta the second he walked off stage. For their own mental health, I feel like these contestants should be coached to live a little, experience life, and process things. They’d cry less," @MarionCotesworthHayes wrote on a Reddit thread. Meanwhile, most of the fans remained shocked and disappointed over the unfair elimination.  

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

While working on 'Wonder Man', Osorio suffered a fatal accident at Stage 3 of the Radford Studio Center in Studio City
40 minutes ago
Ahead of the Season 3 premiere, big moves behind the scenes hint that Shrinking's future on Apple TV+ is far from finished
2 hours ago
Secrets explode as a wedding turns into a public reckoning, exposing hidden pasts, broken trust, and choices that could doom the Vault forever
3 hours ago
As fans eagerly await the return of 'Yellowjackets', here's a closer look at the Season 4 timeline and why Season 5 will not happen
3 hours ago
'Stranger Things' Season 5 came to an end on Netflix on December 31 with 'Rightside Up', but now we've another exciting chapter coming up.
11 hours ago
The recently released 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 2 trailer was previously unveiled at the New York Comic Con, and now the release date is out.
13 hours ago
'America's Next Top Model' aired for 24 cycles between 2003 and 2018; now, a documentary featuring the BTS of the show will be released by Netflix.
15 hours ago
Cristin Milioti, who played the character of Sophia Falcone, gives an underwhelming update on 'The Penguin' Season 2.
16 hours ago
With an executive producer teasing a special bonus episode, 'Heated Rivalry' may make a surprise return before Season 2
23 hours ago
Prime Video moved up the final episodes of 'Fallout', shifting the release schedule as Season 2 races toward its explosive finale
1 day ago