'Paradise' fans baffled with the fate of Annie and her baby in Season 2: 'Man that is...'

'Paradise' Season 2 episode 4 showed an unexpected twist with Annie and her baby, and the fans shared their reactions on the internet.
A still of Sterling K. Brown and Shailene Woodley in 'Paradise' Season 2 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @paradiseonhulu)
A still of Sterling K. Brown and Shailene Woodley in 'Paradise' Season 2 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @paradiseonhulu)

The recently aired fourth episode of 'Paradise' on Hulu was titled 'A Holy Charge' and featured an unexpected set of twists and turns. As a direct consequence of the events in the episode, the character Annie, played by Shailene Woodley, found Xavier Collins, played by Sterling K. Brown. Annie is depicted as a former Gracland tour guide from Memphis, Tennessee, who survived the devastating events that occupied much of the screen time in the show's debut season. Several years after that, a group of survivors runs into Annie at the Elvis Presley estate. This story contains spoilers.

The leader of the said group was Thomas Doherty's Link. After developing a romantic relationship and spending a night together, Annie became pregnant. However, she didn't inform Link about her pregnancy, and he departed the following day in search of the bunker in Colorado. Since Annie is a former medical student, she was able to help Xavier after they crossed paths. When Xavier expresses his desire to travel to Atlanta, Georgia, to find his wife, Teri, Annie tells him that he must first take her to Colorado to locate Link. The two set forth on the journey together, with Annie on horseback and Xavier travelling on foot. During the course of the journey, Annie's condition worsens as she suffers from pregnancy-related complications. They run into a group of dangerous-looking people, followed by Annie almost giving birth on the road. 

The group, however, proved helpful and assisted Annie in delivering the baby. Unfortunately, her placenta wouldn't come out, and the bleeding wouldn't stop. Once Annie realized that her condition couldn't improve, she accepted her fate and eventually died, but not before making Xavier promise that they would look after her child. She also gave him a note for him to read to her daughter. The letter contained the emotional lines, "There are good people in this world, there always have been, and there always will be. I trust that you’ve become one of them. I trust that love travels across death, across time. That it bridges impossible distances and binds people who’ve never known each other. I will always imagine you grown and brave and beautiful. I love you so much, my beautiful baby. Love, your mama.” The episode ended with Link and his group arriving outside the bunker, and Xavier finally reaching the location in Atlanta from which Terri had broadcast the radio signal earlier. 

Sterling K. Brown as Xavier Collin in a still from 'Paradise' season 2 (Image Source: Instagram | @paradiseonhulu)
Sterling K. Brown as Xavier Collin in a still from 'Paradise' season 2 (Image Source: Instagram | @paradiseonhulu)

The episode caused considerable heartbreak among fans of 'Paradise', who were disheartened to see the appalling conditions of Annie's death. Taking to the r/ParadiseHulu sub-Reddit, one user wrote, "Man that is NOT what I wanted to happen, I am devastated. I so badly wanted her & that baby to make it back to Link. I wanted her to get her back back 😫💔". Another user commented, "Yeah I was really sad that they didn’t have Annie bring her daughter to meet Link and reunite. Shailene Woodley was outstanding in the time she had on screen, her character was a great addition. Hopefully we get more flashbacks scenes with Annie like Billy and Cal." A third user wrote, "I just finished the episode. Talk about a devastating loss. 😭💔 Every Mom’s worst nightmare. Annie was my favorite new character. Last season it was Billy. Ughhh." 'Paradise' season two airs new episodes on Hulu

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Bob Hope Humanitarian Award was established in 2002, with Oprah Winfrey being the first recipient
3 minutes ago
‘The Traitors’ takes home the Outstanding Reality Competition Program award at the 2026 Primetime Emmy Awards
4 minutes ago
Olivia Cooke shares a new update on ‘House of the Dragon’ Season 4 filming while reflecting on her return as Alicent Hightower.
25 minutes ago
Matthew Rhys just became the first actor to win two lead acting Emmys on the same night
36 minutes ago
Jean Smart now has an Emmy for each eligible season of her show ‘Hacks’
50 minutes ago
After three disappointments, Rhea Seehorn finally snags her long-overdue Emmy Award
1 hour ago
Mark Ruffalo, Rufus Sewell, Sterling K. Brown, and Gary Oldman were also nominated in the category
1 hour ago
‘Widow’s Bay’ has added a ninth Emmy to its name, with Kate O’Flynn bagging her first win
1 hour ago
Dale Dickey reveals the one rule that shaped ‘Widow’s Bay’ as she reacts to her first Emmy nod.
2 hours ago
Omar Sy returns as Assane Diop for another high-stakes mystery in the next chapter of Netflix’s hit French crime series.
8 hours ago