HOME / ENTERTAINMENT / MOVIES

'My Nanny Stole My Life': Cast and character guide on who's playing who in Lifetime's thriller film

'My Nanny Stole My Life' is about a mother who suspects that her nanny is trying to steal her baby and husband

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: 'My Nanny Stole My Life' is set for its premiere on Lifetime on Thursday, May 16, 2024. The thriller is directed by Matthew Toronto and written by Naomi L Selfman and it tells the story of a mother Molly (Katerina Eichenberger) who is dealing with depression when she suspects that her nanny is trying to steal her baby and husband Noah (Jonathan Stoddard).

The official synopsis of 'My Nanny Stole My Life' reads, "A new mother begins to suspect that her nanny is scheming to steal her baby and her husband–but no one believes her due to the postpartum depression she suffered after the child was born."

'My Nanny Stole My Life' formerly known as 'She Wants My Baby' features  Jonathan Stoddard, Katerina Eichenberger, Shailene Garnett, Laura Dennis, and Caroline Codd among others. Here is an in-depth look at the cast before the film premieres. 

Jonathan Stoddard as Noah

Jonathan Stoddard was born in San Rafael, California, USA on March 31, 1984. The actor and producer is known for his work in 'A Furry Little Christmas' which came out in 2021. 

He impressed with his performances in 'Somewhere in Montana' where he played the role of Spencer Chase and 'Black Monday' where he played the role of Cabana Boy Dave featuring in two episodes. 

He also featured in 'The Young and the Restless' as Young John from 2017 to 2020 and was part of 11 episodes. 

Katerina Eichenberger as Molly 

Katerina Eichenberger shot to prominence when she played the role of Emma Marwood in 'I Will Never Leave You Alone' in 2023. She was also part of an episode in 'Monarch' in 2022. 

The actress and producer also featured in the TV movie 'Secrets Beneath the Floorboards' where she played one of the main roles of Whitney. She reunites with the director of the film Matthew Toronto for 'My Nanny Stole My Life' playing the lead role of Molly

Caroline Codd as Nicci

Caroline Codd is an actor who gets her first big break with 'My Nanny Stole My Life'. She has previously acted in the short film 'Ethereal' where she played the lead role of Maren.

She has a few upcoming projects like 'Cedric & Alysia' where she plays one of the lead roles of Lady Alysia. 

Laura Dennis as Rachel 

Laura Dennis is a professional wrestler turned actor who performed for All Elite Wrestling in the character of The Bunny. She then switched to an acting career. 

She has previously acted in 'Givers of Death' and 'Puppet Master: Doktor Death'. She has been married to Jesse Guilmette since 2013. 

Shailene Garnett as Lindsay Collins

Shailene Garnett is an actor who became popular after her stint in the series 'Shadowhunters'. She has done recurring roles in many series such as 'Between', 'Teenagers' and 'Murdoch Mysteries'. 

She has also been a part of shows like 'Incorporated' 'Single Ladies', 'Covert Affairs', and 'The Strain'.

'My Nanny Stole My Life' trailer 

'My Nanny Stole My Life' will premiere on Lifetime on May 16, 2024.