'The Bachelor Presents: Listen to Your Heart': Natascha and Ryan eliminated, fans say they didn't deserve it

Arie Luyendyk said he didn't find their performance genuine after Ryan and Natascha added their own twist to Ed Sheeran's 'Perfect'
Natascha, Ryan (ABC/John Fleenor)
Natascha, Ryan (ABC/John Fleenor)

Ryan Neal and Natascha Bessez's romance on 'The Bachelor Presents: Listen to Your Heart' came to a sad end on Monday night, May 11 and fans believe the couple didn't deserve it. 

'The Bachelor Presents: Listen to Your Heart' premiered recently, but it already feels like its been on air for ages. The six week spin-off season is nearing its end with just one week remaining and the competition is getting tougher. With just four couples remaining, it was anyone's game this week. 

Last week we saw Julia and Brandon's over the top drama come to an end. We also witnessed Bri and Chris take their relationship to the next level by confessing their love for each other. 

Back again this week, the couples make their way to Las Vegas in their very own tour bus. Though it was barely a five-hour drive, they sure enjoyed their time. But Rudi and Matt found themselves taking some time out and having a date. Later, Rudi did find herself in a rocky position after she confessed her feelings to Matt but got no clear response from him. 

Meanwhile, this week, the couples performed where Lady Gaga performed. The judges this week were Bachelor franchise couple, Arie Luyendyk Jr and Lauren Burnham, Pat Monahan from Train, Ashley Simpson and Evan Ross. Ryan and Natascha had to perform, 'Perfect' by Ed Sheeran. Instead of keeping it the way it is, Ryan decided to add his twist to it, but didn't end up well. The judges weren't impressed. 

Arie revealed he didn't find their performance genuine. Sadly, Ryan and Natascha end up getting eliminated tonight. Taking to Twitter fans were upset claiming the didn't deserve it. "So I’m currently balling my eyes out hyperventilating because Ryan and Natasha got sent home!! The amount of crying snapchats I have rn is soo bad but I just love them," a fan said. 

While another added, "Sad Ryan is leaving, he & Natascha are super talented. I know this isn’t the last we’ve seen of them, not together but you know, can’t have everything." 

"I don’t agree with these judges using just this ONE performance to judge if they get to go to the finale. It doesn’t seem fair because Natascha and Ryan have been SOLID #LTYH," a fan said. Adding to that another said, 'Ryan and Natascha didn't deserve to be sent home." 

'The Bachelor Presents: Listen to Your Heart' airs every Monday night only on ABC. Check your local listings for more information. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘House of the Dragon’ Season 3 episode 7 quietly references Nettles, the missing ‘Fire & Blood’ character whose story changed in the HBO series.
3 hours ago
Alan Ritchson is set to lead a heist thriller described as ‘Fast & Furious’, but with motorcycles.
5 hours ago
In the Season 14 finale, Dom Pascal returned to speak to Kelly Severide about the future of his career
7 hours ago
Cole Hauser opens up about battling heat and ice storms while filming ‘Dutton Ranch’ Season 1
8 hours ago
‘Chicago Fire’ Season 15 will welcome a doctor, possibly to deal with the repercussions of the Season 14 finale.
8 hours ago
‘Ted Lasso’ is finally set to return with Jason Sudeikis, Hannah Waddingham, and others playing pivotal roles in Season 4
9 hours ago
Warner Bros. delays Taylor Sheridan’s big-screen venture by a month to avoid competition.
10 hours ago
‘Superman’s’ untitled HBO Max spinoff has finally cast its female lead opposite Skyler Gisondo
11 hours ago
Ryan Hurst was initially cast for the role in January 2026, but suffered a torn bicep while filming for the series
12 hours ago
Helaena’s visions connect her children, Dreamfyre and the Dragonpit to the deaths still ahead, with many fans left wondering about her fate.
1 day ago