'The Bachelor': Matt James branded 'literal clown' for leading Abigail on for weeks before eliminating her

Bachelor fans are in an angry tizzy after he sends fan-favorite Abigail Heringer home with a "bulls**t" apology
PUBLISHED FEB 16, 2021
Matt James and Abigail Heringer in 'The Bachelor' (ABC)
Matt James and Abigail Heringer in 'The Bachelor' (ABC)

'The Bachelor' Season 25 just aired one of its most gut-wrenching episodes on Monday night. Fan-favorite Abigail Heringer was sent home in a brutal elimination. Season lead Matt James whisked her away for a private conversation during the group date where he dropped the bomb on her.

For the uninformed, Abigail was seen ruing about the fact that she's the only woman in the room along with Jessenia, who is yet to receive a one-on-one date card. Abigail was the recipient of the first impression rose and she's been a darling of Bachelor Nation fans from the very beginning. 

Coming back to Matt and Abigail's conversation, he began by telling her how comfortable he was in their relationship. He told her that he was very secure about the bond they shared and that is the reason he began exploring his bond with the other women during which he felt more drawn towards others than her. "You deserve someone that will put you first," Matt told Abigail before apologizing to her for leading her on. He then walked her to the car and sent her home. 

RELATED ARTICLES

Did Katie Thurston deserve to be eliminated? 'The Bachelor' fans slam Matt James for being 'conservative'

Why did Matt James dump Mearg Tareke aka Magi? ‘The Bachelor’ fans say ‘she deserved better’



 

Bachelor Nation fans are super annoyed that their unproblematic queen was sent home without a one-on-one date and with a "bullsh**" apology. "Matt makes no sense. He was so into Abigail, that he left her hanging for weeks.... literal clown. I’ll be mad about this for weeks #TheBachelor," wrote a fan.

"I’m a heavy Abigail advocate and the fact that she just went home before hometowns is devastating Should I even finish watching the rest of this season?! I’m down bad on this one," wrote another. "That was a bullshit apology. He was too comfortable so he just never talked to her? #TheBachelor" read another tweet.

"Matt is trash and he deserves trash. We should have known from the very first red flag: being named Matt. Yes, this is still about him eliminating Abigail without even giving her a chance. #TheBachelor," read another tweet. 



 



 



 



 



 

This is the second week in a row where Matt James is being bashed for sending a favorite home. Just last week, he eliminated Katie Thurston, who was regarded as a voice of reason on the show for standing up to the bullies in this season and for just being her funny, authentic, sex-positive self.

What do you think about the decisions Matt has been making in his season? Let us know in the comments. 

Catch new episodes of 'The Bachelor' every Monday at 8 pm ET on ABC. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

CBS will air the last episode of 'The Late Show with Stephen Colbert' on May 21, 2026
59 minutes ago
Ryan Murphy Productions dropped three set photos, each showing Jessica Lange as she returns to 'American Horro Story' after eight years.
9 hours ago
Marvel Studios' EP appeared as a surprise guest on The Escape Pod and teased an exciting 'Zombies' Season 2 update.
10 hours ago
While 'Tracker' Season 4 was confirmed last week, CBS has now dropped a major update on the Season 3 finale, and fans are probably not going to like it.
13 hours ago
With 'Shrinking' Season 3 finale airing on Wednesday, showrunner Bill Lawrence opened up about the show's future and a possible division.
14 hours ago
'Marshals' Episode 5 also featured Kayce haggling over selling his late wife Monica's horse after it was involved in an accident with their son Tate.
15 hours ago
Monica Dutton previously took the initiative to investigate the disappearance of Indigenous girls
16 hours ago
The sophomore season of 'High Potential' consists of 18 episodes in total, instead of the debut season's 13
17 hours ago
'Malcolm In The Middle: Life's Still Unfair' is scheduled to premiere on April 10 on Hulu and Disney+
18 hours ago
The 'Dark Winds' Season 4 finale featured a tragic death, heightening anticipation for the next installment of the series
19 hours ago