'Survivor' star Richard Hatch shares controversial take on his 51-month jail sentence

'Survivor' star Richard Hatch claims his homosexuality contributed to his tax evasion prosecution
'Survivor' star Richard Hatch failed to pay taxes on the $1 million he won on the show (Instagram/@hatch_rich)
'Survivor' star Richard Hatch failed to pay taxes on the $1 million he won on the show (Instagram/@hatch_rich)

NEWPORT, RHODE ISLAND: 'Survivor' Season 1 winner Richard Hatch famously served a 51-month prison sentence after being convicted of three counts related to tax evasion and fraudulent tax returns in January 2006. The news made headlines as the CBS star failed to report his winnings from the show to the IRS to avoid paying taxes. Notably, Richard never truly made good friends during the program. However, his cutthroat determination to win earned him a lavish prize and a prestigious title. 

The 33-year-old's life took a drastic turn shortly after his uncharted win. Richard believes his openness about his sexuality during the reality TV competition played a significant role in the devastating aftermath of his life. While he was found guilty of tax evasion, Richard claims his homosexuality contributed to his prosecution. "Well, it devastated my life, frankly. I didn't anticipate it. It's the reason I was prosecuted," he stated in an interview with the Daily Beast. Going into detail, Richard alleged that he faced homophobia from prospective jurors, who referred to him using derogatory terms like "homo," "a queer," and "a f**." However, the judge refused to question the jurors about their biases. "I mean, it was crazy that that happened," he remarked.

Richard Hatch at 62 years of age. (Instagram/@hatch_rich)
Richard Hatch alleged that he faced homophobia from prospective jurors (Instagram/@hatch_rich)

1. 'Survivor' star Richard Hatch still receives messages from loyal fans

Despite his haunting legal woes, 'Survivor' legend Richard maintains a positive outlook on life. He expresses pride in being openly gay during his season, a move that has resonated deeply with his fans, who continue to applaud him for his authenticity. "But it's one of the most important, most prideful things that have ever happened in my life, the way that gay guys — young gay boys and men — reached out to me and thanked me or just connected with me and were so shocked that they saw themselves on TV," he shared in the interview. Richard revealed that he didn't anticipate such a positive response and noted that many people have approached him to discuss the significant impact he has had on their lives simply by being himself.

(Instagram/@hatch_rich)
'Survivor' legend Richard Hatch maintains a positive outlook on life (Instagram/@hatch_rich)

2. Richard Hatch claims 'Survivor' host Jeff Probst has 'lost sight'

In an interview with Parade, Richard shared his candid thoughts on 'Survivor' host Jeff Probst, stating that Jeff has "lost sight." He elaborated, saying, "He's a great host, but he's too involved, from my perspective." Richard went on to praise Joel McHale for his hosting style, noting that Joel doesn't try to overshadow the show or intervene in ways that disrupt the flow. Interestingly, Jeff did not include Richard in 'Survivor: Winners at War', explaining that due to Richard's history of getting naked on the show, it would have been "inappropriate" to have him back, given how much times have changed. It seems that both stars seize every opportunity to take jabs at each other.

'Survivor' host Jeff Probst speaks about Dan Spilo's elimination (Instagram/@jeffprobst)
 Jeff Probst did not include Richard Hatch in 'Survivor: Winners at War' (Instagram/@jeffprobst)

3. What is the Richard Hatch - Susan Hawk controversy from 'Survivor: All Stars'?

In the fifth episode of 'Survivor: All-Stars' in 2004, Susan Hawk accused Richard Hatch of sexual assault during a challenge, claiming that he rubbed his genitals against her while competing naked. This incident caused significant turmoil on the show, resulting in Susan choosing to quit. Hatch was also voted out for different reasons. While Susan contemplated filing a lawsuit against CBS, she ultimately decided against it after resolving the situation with the network's assistance.

Well, the situation could have been handled more decisively, suggesting Richard should have been booted immediately and faced disgrace for his actions. There are claims that Susan was motivated by the prospect of a significant paycheck and was aware she might not win the season. Moreover, Boston Rob had informed her that Richard was following that path during the competition, yet she insisted on taking the same route. Overall, it is surprising to see Richard's reputation still intact despite the serious accusations against him.

(@cbs)
Susan Hawk accused Richard Hatch of sexual assault during a challenge in 'Survivor: All-Stars' (@cbs)

4. Did Richard Hatch serve in prison twice?

According to the United States Attorney's Office in Providence, Rhode Island, Richard Hatch failed to report his winnings from 'Survivor' on his federal income tax returns. Moreover, he allegedly did not disclose approximately $321,000 in earnings that year. This led to his imprisonment, and he was released in 2009 after a three-year sentence. However, during this period, he failed to comply with a court order to refile his 2000 and 2001 taxes and pay the taxes owed. As a result of his actions, he was ordered to return to jail for neglecting to pay taxes on his $1 million prize. Hatch was then released from prison on December 12, 2011, after serving an additional nine months.

Richard Hatch was left out of 'Survivor' season 40 owing to his problematic behavior. (Instagram/@hatch_rich)
Richard Hatch was ordered to return to jail for neglecting to pay taxes on his $1 million prize (Instagram/@hatch_rich)

5. Richard Hatch also faced a second-degree child abuse charge

The 'Survivor' star was arrested in April 2000 and faced a felony charge of child abuse. According to police reports, Hatch was accused of grabbing his son, Chris, during an early-morning jog on April 27. Allegedly, he grabbed his son by the ear and neck when Chris became tired and stopped running, expressing concern that his son had gained a lot of weight while he was away filming the show. However, in August 2000, Richard was cleared of the charges, as reported by the Washington Post. The court documents filed by prosecutors did not provide any explanation for the dismissal.

Richard Hatch has run into trouble with the law over evasive tax returns. (Instagram/@hatch_rich)
Richard Hatch faced a felony charge of child abuse (Instagram/@hatch_rich)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The two eliminated housemates joined Angela and Lala in the Season 28 Jury House
4 hours ago
After choosing two Traitors, the host, Alan Cumming, introduced an exciting twist
5 hours ago
The new season will kick off on Monday, September 21 with a three-night run
7 hours ago
Titled ‘The Traitors: New Blood,’ the fan-favorite reality show welcomes 22 civilians to the iconic castle this year
9 hours ago
The new season leans into love, reinvention and a lot of unfinished business
10 hours ago
Chris Harrison’s new show ‘The Vow’ premieres on November 11 only on Fox Nation
1 day ago
‘RHOSLC’ Season 7 premiered on an emotional note as Mary reflected on her late son's life
1 day ago
Jenna Dewan, Maura Higgins, Ciara Miller, Sarah Jane Nader, Julia Stiles, and more took the stage during Night 2 of the premiere
1 day ago
All final acts from ‘America’s Got Talent’ Season 21 will perform one last time on September 22
1 day ago
‘The Challenge’ Season 42 Episode 8 came with an unexpected twist as the host announced that three contestants were removed from the series
1 day ago