'Stranger Things' on Netflix: Here's why Barb Holland's death in Season 1 will remain the most controversial
LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: The world of Hawkins, Indiana, in Netflix's 'Stranger Things' is a haven for geeky friendships, inter-dimensional creatures, and bicycles. But beneath the surface of flickering lights and nostalgic 80s vibes lies a darkness that claimed one character in a way that continues to spark outrage and discussion.
Barb Holland (Shannon Purser), the quiet and loyal best friend to the show's protagonist, Nancy Wheeler (Natalia Dyer), wasn't initially expected to be a central figure. Yet, her sudden and gruesome demise in the Upside Down, an alternate dimension harboring monstrous threats, left a lasting impact.
Fans weren't just sad to see Barb go; they were angry. Why did this seemingly innocent character have to meet such a horrific fate, seemingly forgotten by the narrative as the main characters focused on their own survival?
This controversy surrounding Barb's death goes beyond a simple emotional response. It delves into deeper questions about character development, the portrayal of female friendships, and the show's mortality treatment. Let's delve into the 'Justice for Barb' movement and explore why her death continues to resonate with viewers long after the credits roll on Season 1.
How did 'Justice for Barb' movement start after 'Stranger Things' Season 1?
The brutal death of Barb in 'Stranger Things' Season 1 sparked the #JusticeforBarb movement. Fans were upset that the show didn't properly acknowledge her disappearance and gruesome demise.
In Season 2, the writers attempted to address this outcry. Nancy, visibly haunted by Barb's fate, teams up with Jonathan Byers (Charlie Heaton) to investigate what happened. They uncover a government conspiracy involving Hawkins Lab and its experiments with the Upside Down.
However, the execution of this 'justice' plot fell flat. Instead of a deep dive into Barb's fate and the characters' emotional response, it felt like fan service. The scenes focused on Nancy and Jonathan uncovering the conspiracy, with Barb's memory primarily used as a motivator for them.
The resolution resulted in a bittersweet discovery of Barb's body and a scene of Nancy confronting a lab official, demanding the truth. While it acknowledged Barb's death, it didn't fully address the depth of the fans' anger, leaving the #JusticeforBarb movement unsatisfied.
In addition once during an interview with BUILD Series, actress Shannon Purser who played Barb shares her thoughts on the fan movement demanding justice for her character Barb in 'Stranger Things'.
The #JusticeforBarb movement has garnered over 68,000 posts on Instagram alone, sparking discussion across various social media platforms.
Barb gets remembered again in 'Stranger Things 4'
Similar to how Season 2 explored Nancy's guilt over Barb's death, season 4 delivers another moment that validates Barb's significance. Nancy finds herself transported to the Upside Down and faces the season's villain, Vecna.
Here, Vecna uses Barb's demise to torture Nancy, forcing her to confront her friend's decaying body. He taunts Nancy, questioning if she's forgotten Barb's agonizing death. This encounter goes beyond mere fan service (though #JusticeForBarb supporters would likely cheer). Season 4 justifies Barb's death by making it a crucial plot point. We see that Nancy remains haunted by the tragedy, and Barb is far from forgotten.
Barb's brief return also serves a narrative purpose. Occurring just before the show's first mid-season break, it creates real tension. With Nancy trapped in Vecna's mind, the audience faces an agonizing month-long wait to see if she escapes.
While Barb's Season 2 funeral provided some closure the town finally acknowledged her existence and death Season 4 reinforces the idea that her demise deserved more attention. The Duffer Brothers, the show's creators, remind viewers that Barb, though gone, still impacts the story. Season 4 emphasizes that her death wasn't meaningless.
'Stranger Things' is available for streaming on Netflix