‘Sins in the Suburbs’ Review: Sam Fichtner's Lifetime thriller is dramatic but lacks suspense

The plot centers around a sadist who desires nothing more in life than love and who also happens to murder women who do not return his feelings
Monique Sypkens  and Brandon Santana in 'Sins in the Suburbs' (IMDb)
Monique Sypkens and Brandon Santana in 'Sins in the Suburbs' (IMDb)

'Sins in the Suburbs' is unnerving for all the flaws and the lack of suspense. Have you ever walked past a serial killer? Maybe it was a bump into one in a  crowded commuter train or a brushed shoulder in the supermarket's refrigerated aisle. Or he may be your new next-door neighbor. You most likely didn't... but who knows? You'd have no idea where they were if they were anyplace. That is until they began murdering you.

The Lifetime original thriller is about a serial killer on the prowl who kills ladies who aren't in love with him. Heather Bailey (Monique Sypkens) is a young attractive lady who works as a restoration artist in a small town. She has a best friend named Jess and lives a good life. Until one day, new neighbors Tyler (Brandon Santana), who is charming, gorgeous, and appears to be highly successful, moves in. Tyler and Heather hit it off right away. They began to date one another after flirting with each other. However, dating someone new who you just met might be dangerous at times.

RELATED ARTICLES

‘Drowning in Secrets’: 5 things you need to know about the Lifetime thriller movie

'Stolen By Their Father' Review: An emotional roller coaster ride of a mom battling for her kids

Directed by Sam Fichtner, the film is written by John F Hayes and David Ian McKendry. The movie does have a thriller element, but it lacks suspense. Because you'll get the impression from early that Tyler is the killer that the cops are looking for, but the movie displays the thrill of the journey as Tyler stalks Heather from the beginning. The thriller is pacy and dramatic at the same time.

Coming back to the film, Tyler had no intention of murdering her, but he did want her to love him. Heather, on the other hand, couldn't stand him after learning his true self. In the end, they confronted one other and things got fairly nasty, resulting in Tyler's arrest, but you'll have to see the movie to find out what happened to Heather.

Monique Sypkens in 'Sins in the Suburbs' (Lifetime)

Brandon Santana's acting is outstanding, especially in the character of the serial murderer who appears to be normal in front of everyone but has a dark persona inside. Monique Sypkens, on the other hand, was quite remarkable. This flick is a one-time watch. However, I believe the film was trying to convey a message in which a man who craved nothing more than love in his life becomes a serial killer because he was unable to find it.

The more extravagant, manic form of the serial murderer fascinates us in movies, and these stories excite us even as they distract us from the more immediate threat and mundanity of daily evil. That's pretty much 'Sins in the Suburbs' for you.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Nearly two decades later, Jason is ready to return. Here's what we know about his next movie
2026-11-18T20:00:17.000Z
Denis Villeneuve opens up about the qualities he wanted in his new 007.
2026-11-18T19:56:17.000Z
‘The Comeback King’ trailer sends Glen Powell’s country singer back to college after a breakup scandal involving Madelyn Cline’s pop star.
2026-11-18T17:39:32.000Z
Brad Pitt wants to play Robert Pattinson's villain in Denis Villeneuve's 'James Bond' movie
2026-11-18T03:38:08.000Z
Josh O'Connor reportedly hesitated over screen tests as concerns about fame and the franchise's demands factored into his decision
2026-11-18T03:08:21.000Z
Tom Holland’s ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ adds 10 minutes of unseen footage as fans await ticket sales and showtimes for the film’s return to theaters.
2026-11-17T15:33:01.000Z
Brad Pitt shares ‘Ocean’s 14’ filming is delayed to late 2027, though the original cast praises the script
2026-11-17T10:16:01.000Z
The 'Hunger Game' co-stars Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson joined Woody Harrelson and other familiar faces at the New York premiere of 'Sunrise on the Reaping'
2026-11-17T08:24:16.000Z
Christopher Nolan's ambitious retelling of Homer's Greek epic made history at the box office, and fans can now bring it home
2026-11-17T06:31:26.000Z
The film follows a Chicago baker whose dream of owning a business eventually leads to an unexpected reunion
2026-11-17T02:54:46.000Z