'Santa Tell Me' Review: Hallmark's rom-com is a perfect recipe for a holiday movie done right

Hallmark's 'Santa Tell Me' delivers a delightful holiday romance that combines magic realism with festive charm
Erin Krakow stands out with her perfect portrayal of Olivia in 'Santa Tell Me'(@hallmark)
Erin Krakow stands out with her perfect portrayal of Olivia in 'Santa Tell Me'(@hallmark)

Contains spoilers for 'Santa Tell Me'

What's great about holiday movies is their comfortable vibe, which wraps around you like a warm blanket, warming you and making you experience positive emotions. While this analogy is about how Christmas movies can elicit emotions in you, I must agree that Hallmark's 'Santa Tell Me' fits right into this category. The film's greatest strength is its ability to transport you away from the everyday grind of life and convince you that love triumphs against all odds.

'Santa Tell Me' is a lovely holiday romance that adds a fresh twist to the ordinary Christmas movie formula by combining classic romantic vibes with festive feelings and, of course, a touch of magic realism. While a key narrative aspect appears to be far from realistic, it propels the storyline ahead in generating a joyful and engaging viewing experience. 

'Santa Tell Me' delivers a whimsical twist on classic holiday romance

A still from 'Santa Tell Me' (YouTube/@hallmarkchannel)
A still from 'Santa Tell Me' (YouTube/@hallmarkchannel)

The premise of Santa Tell Me is a fresh take on the traditional holiday romance, blended with Hallmark's classic holiday romance style. The film follows Olivia (Erin Krakow), a woman who receives a mysterious letter from Santa Claus that guides her romantic life. Olivia’s discovery of an old letter promising her true love by Christmas Eve, with a specific name, Nick, establishes a delightful and engaging premise. Instead of a straightforward romance, Olivia is thrown into a whirlwind of possibilities when she meets three handsome men named Nick, each with a distinct personality. This setup leads to both amusing and poignant moments as she tries to determine which Nick is “the one” for her. But what’s a rom-com without a twist? Here, it’s Olivia’s growing attraction to her coworker, Chris (Daniel Lissing).

Though Olivia is set on following Santa's prediction, her heart seems to be leading her in a completely different direction. As the film progresses, Olivia races against time, with Christmas Eve heightening the urgency. The plot unfolds like a delightful puzzle, keeping audiences guessing about Olivia’s choice. Ryan Landels impresses in his dual role as director and writer, expertly blending romantic suspense with festive cheer. I thought I knew who Olivia would end up with, but I was more interested in her journey to finding her prince charming, which adds excitement to the storyline. The film is filled with touching scenes, and one of my favorites is Chris helping Olivia recreate a nostalgic family tradition she cherishes from childhood: family sleigh rides through the snow. While this scene may appear simple, it highlights Chris's thoughtfulness toward Olivia.

Erin Krakow’s captivating performance stands out in Santa Tell Me

Erin Krakow in a still from 'Santa Tell Me' (@hallmark)
Erin Krakow in a still from 'Santa Tell Me' (@hallmark)

The cast of Santa Tell Me brings warmth and charm to the screen, adding depth to the Christmas romance. Erin Krakow delivers a mesmerizing performance as Olivia, leaving audiences enchanted and likely interested in seeing more of her work. Krakow connects with viewers even though her character can sometimes come across as a bit of a player, moving from one Nick to the next in search of the right one. Olivia is a charming and convincing character thanks to Krakow’s sincerity and passion in the role.

Daniel Lissing’s portrayal of Chris is grounded and endearing, making him a perfect match for Olivia’s thoughtful and compassionate nature. Lissing and Krakow also share palpable chemistry that builds naturally throughout the film, keeping viewers invested in their relationship. All in all, Santa Tell Me has all the elements of a holiday hit, thanks to its beautiful mix of romance and suspense set against the dazzling lights of the holiday season. While the plot may be predictable, the joy of Santa Tell Me lies in watching Olivia navigate her feelings and learn to trust her heart, making it a delightful watch.

'Santa Tell Me' preview



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’ Season 27 finale promises an intense case, rising tensions, and difficult choices for the squad.
7 hours ago
The upcoming 'Law & Order: SVU' finale will also offer some sort of resolution between Benson and her new boss, Chief of Detectives Kathryn Tynan.
7 hours ago
The upcoming eight-part series 'Carrie,' is directed by horror maestro Mike Flanagan, of 'The Haunting of the Hill House' fame.
9 hours ago
The showrunner promises major changes, emotional twists, and new challenges for Voight and the Intelligence Unit in 'Chicago P.D.' Season 14.
9 hours ago
Where is Mackenzie Shirilla now? Netflix's 'The Crash' shares some gruesome details behind tragic incident
10 hours ago
'Dutton Ranch' continues Beth and Rip's story in Texas with family drama, rivalries, and the gritty tone fans loved in 'Yellowstone.'
11 hours ago
With Season 1 of 'Nemesis' now out, the focus has already switched to the possibility of a second installment.
12 hours ago
Chace Crawford weighed in on his character's run in the finale, while also addressing the wagers placed on his fate in 'The Boys' Season 5.
15 hours ago
A month after the debut season’s premiere, ‘Big Mistakes’ received an exciting update on its future.
15 hours ago
Season 1 of ‘Off Campus’ series is based on Elle Kennedy’s 2015 novel, ‘The Deal.’
15 hours ago