Luke Bryan wasn’t interested in ‘American Idol’ — then came the unexpected pitch that made him say yes

"I’m at my beach house, and my manager, Carrie, she calls me and says, ‘We’ve been contacted about the reboot of 'American Idol,'" Luke Bryan recalled.
PUBLISHED MAY 25, 2025
'American Idol' star Luke Bryan reveals he is quitting the show (Cover image source: Instagram | @lukebryan)
'American Idol' star Luke Bryan reveals he is quitting the show (Cover image source: Instagram | @lukebryan)

'American Idol' has remained a fan favorite since its debut in 2002, producing chart-topping stars and unforgettable moments. With Season 23 wrapping up recently and Jamal Roberts taking home the title, the show continues to draw millions of viewers every year. While the judging panel has evolved over time, Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie have been familiar faces since the ABC revival. But in a recent appearance on Bobby Bones' Bobbycast podcast, Bryan admitted he was initially reluctant to join the show until one surprising twist changed everything.



 

"I’m at my beach house, and my manager, Carrie, she calls me and says, ‘We’ve been contacted about the reboot of 'American Idol.' We had already seen some headlines around Katy Perry; they signed Katy, and you knew the show was coming back, so they reached out to my manager, and I must say, I was 70% against it." Bryan continued to add "At that moment, I was at the height of stadiums and didn't want to get my mental focus going down."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Luke Bryan Official (@lukebryan)


 

Needless to say, Bryan's career was flourishing as a country music artist. He stated how he didn't want to go to Los Angeles or New York to do a meeting he didn't want to do, as reported by Screen Rant. However, the executives were persistent, so they flew in to meet Bryan to pitch the show to him. "They started pitching it, and I told them, 'I’m really probably not interested.' What's funny is that they have no idea about Luke Bryan. They don't know I'm doing soldout stadiums and double amphitheaters." Since Bryan was hesitant to accept the offer, he went back home and called his friends, Blake Shelton and Keith Urban.



 

Blake Shelton had been a coach on 'The Voice' for 23 seasons, while Urban was a judge on 'Idol' for four seasons. Bryan stated, "Those are two guys that I love and trust," as he continued to say, "I called Blake, and we had a great talk ... he was like, ‘Luke, TV opens up another domain and dynamic.' And I called Keith, and he said, Man, he had loved it." Bryan then stated how 'Idol' agreed to his "crazy" salary demands: "I threw them out a number, and damn it, they paid it."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Luke Bryan Official (@lukebryan)


 

As stated by Bryan, the country singer was at the peak of his career when 'American Idol' contacted him. He released 'What Makes You Country,' his sixth studio album, in December of 2017. Bryan then went on to go on a 'What Makes You Country' tour across America. The tour began in February of 2018 and lasted up until October of 2018. All this while, Bryan was also continuing his farm tour, where he performed in rural areas to celebrate farmers. 

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Emma Roberts will star in a Peacock series loosely based on the 2009 rom-com starring Anne Hathaway and Kate Hudson.
46 minutes ago
Before 'Industry' Season 4 finale, which premieres one hour earlier than usual, HBO announces a major update on the future of the hit TV show.
1 hour ago
Netflix dropped major updates on 'The Boroughs', the Duffer Brothers‘ supernatural mystery series, created by Jeffrey Addiss and Will Matthews.
3 hours ago
'Game of Thrones' star will be the main antagonist in the 'God of War' (2018) game and in the upcoming series on Prime Video.
4 hours ago
The Crave-HBO Max series 'Heated Rivalry' now gives its viewers a chance to stay at the cottage as the feverish wait for Season 2 continues.
5 hours ago
With Season 2 underway, ‘Paradise’ deepens its post-apocalyptic narrative while viewers wait to learn whether Hulu will renew the series for Season 3.
5 hours ago
Taylor Sheridan’s next ‘Tulsa King’ chapter is moving forward, with new details emerging ahead of filming for the highly anticipated series.
6 hours ago
AMC chief Dan McDermott shared a promising update on the future of ‘Dark Winds,’ as the acclaimed thriller continues to gain momentum.
7 hours ago
CBS’ new series ‘CIA’ follows mismatched agents tackling covert threats, with a surprise cameo from ‘FBI’ star Jeremy Sisto.
7 hours ago
The ‘Scrubs’ revival brings back beloved doctors, leaves out key originals, and introduces fresh faces to a changed Sacred Heart.
7 hours ago