'Killer Prom' Review: Yvonne Zima's lead will creep you out even if plotline is something you expect

If a murderer in heels is your type of 'stay in' movie night, this might be the perfect Lifetime thriller for you
Yvonne Zima in 'Killer Prom' (Lifetime)
Yvonne Zima in 'Killer Prom' (Lifetime)

Spoilers for 'Killer Prom'

If a murderer in heels is your type of 'stay in' movie night, this might be the perfect Lifetime thriller for you.

A young woman named Sienna is enthralled by the life of the rich and succumbs to being a murderer in the first five minutes of the movie. A shocking beginning and a predictable narrative, this is your typical jealous woman joining into the family of the woman she murdered to take over her entire life — her husband, her home and her children. Thing is, Sienna didn't just take over a stranger's life, it was that of her cousin, Hannah Wilson.

The Wilsons seem to have it all — Tony Wilson is a doctor and his wife, Hannah seems to be climbing high on the corporate ladder. They have two children, a daughter Cayleigh who is excited and gearing up for her prom, a rite of passage for a young woman. and a son Luke. What they didn't expect is a distant cousin Sienna Markle to be the bearer of their tragedy. After Hannah experiences a near 'accident' while boating, Sienna waits 7 months before she claws her way into the Wilson family.

A jealous and seductive young beauty, she easily captures the hearts of Tony, Luke and especially Cayleigh, who misses a mother to talk to.

Cayleigh, who seems to have lost the wonder of her world after the death of her mother, suffers long with her little brother Luke who has constant nightmares. When Sienna's manipulation allows her valid entry into the family home, things start looking up. The kids are excited again, and their dim light starts to shine bright. However, Sienna's obsession with making sure that Cayleigh has the perfect prom night gets out of hand. Nothing seems to be out of her agenda, including murder.

We don't want to give too much away, although we can tell you that while you may enjoy the movie, there is nothing that you haven't seen before. You will definitely expect the stalkerish vibes and the murderous agendas. Yvonne Zima who plays the role of murderer Sienna Markle does an excellent portrayal of creepy and evil step-mother want to be. From her laugh to the way she delivers her manipulations, she will definitely give you the creeps. She reminded us of Leighton Meester in the 'The Roommate'!

The movie seemed to have lacked a spark that would help it stand out from other productions that have used the same storyline. It is however still an interesting watch and definitely a Lifetime production with its charm and elegance. A big home, big cash, bright shiny characters seem to take the forefront, when a crazy woman behind the scenes unleashes a hell that, although expected by viewers, is still quite shocking.

'Killer Prom' will premiere on April 19, 2020, at 8/ 7c on Lifetime.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘The Joker's Wild’ is coming back with its signature trivia format, giving contestants a chance to compete for jackpots worth up to $50,000
2026-11-18T09:47:22.000Z
The CBS drama will be back sooner than its previous seasons, with a new Sunday night lineup also in store
2026-11-18T08:49:37.000Z
'NCIS: Origins' takes Mark Harmon's Gibbs to the past to find answers about Lala's disappearance
2026-11-18T07:32:52.000Z
Jon Cryer is back on CBS with a guest appearance that puts him in a very different position from his iconic sitcom role.
2026-11-18T06:39:09.000Z
Torres begins the episode undercover with a drug gang, but the operation quickly takes an unexpected turn
2026-11-18T05:33:40.000Z
Ralph Fiennes has a playful idea for Robert Pattinson's next major role, years after they shared the screen in 'Harry Potter'
2026-11-18T04:13:45.000Z
'The Innocent' follows Matt Hunter, whose life begins to unravel when he and his wife try to buy a house in his old hometown
2026-11-18T03:34:18.000Z
From a royal murder to a British version of ‘Brazzos,’ the upcoming season has plenty of surprises in store
2026-11-17T17:50:47.000Z
An alien offer of peace clashes with Thomas Wade’s warning in the first ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2 teaser ahead of its Netflix return.
2026-11-17T16:27:21.000Z
‘Line of Fire’ Episode 8 takes Nia’s investigation in a new direction as another killing pushes her to seek Jane’s help.
2026-11-17T14:03:00.000Z