'SYTYCD' Season 17: Fans react to Matthew Morrison removal, hope 'they bring back Nigel'

While many were guessing who Matthew had messaged, they were also making comparison to his 'Glee' character, hoping that Nigel Lythgoe would return
(L) Matthew Morrison and Nigel Lythgoe (Photos by Dimitrios Kambouris and Kevin Winter/Getty Images)
(L) Matthew Morrison and Nigel Lythgoe (Photos by Dimitrios Kambouris and Kevin Winter/Getty Images)

Season 17 of 'So You Think You Can Dance' is already facing some challenges with the primary one being the dissatisfaction from longtime viewers, who aren't liking the new format of the dance reality show. 

On the other hand, most of the performances so far have won over fans, with the most recent ones being that of Armando "Decoy" Munez, Essence Wilmington, Camila Schwarz, and Waverly Fredericks. The show, however, has had its fair share of controversies in the past, and has been struck by one yet again! This time around it's Matthew Morrison, who has stirred the pot by sending "flirty direct messages" to a contestant. While an investigation revealed that they "didn't have sex" or meet off the set, it was confirmed that the messages had "crossed the line," making the contestant feel "uncomfortable," who in turn got the producers and Fox involved.

READ MORE

Who will replace Matthew Morrison? 'SYTYCD' judge FIRED over 'flirty' texts to contestant

'SYTYCD' Season 17: Fans speculate Camila Schwarz is the 'girl Matthew dm’d'

Fans were quick to weigh in on the controversy, hoping the showrunners would bring Nigel Lythgoe back and making comparisons to Matthew's character on 'Glee.' "With Matthew Morrison fired as a judge, I really hope they bring back Nigel Lythgoe as a replacement for Morrison once the live voting shows start (as long as Lythgoe's willing to do it & doesn't have any scheduling conflicts)! #SYTYCD," a fan tweeted. "I hope Matthew’s replacement is Nigel, since he should’ve returned to judge this season in the first place #SYTYCD," shared another. 



 



 

"Matthew Morrison getting fired from So You Think You Can Dance for being creepy with a contestant is just another example of the lines between him and Mr. Schue continuing to be blurred. Oh and naturally he sang international creeper song Blurred Lines on Glee. #SYTYCD #Glee," a fan opined. Another seconded, tweeting "Matthew Morrison has been fired from #SYTYCD. Apparently he was super creepy in real life as he was in “Glee”. He will be seen on the show until Mid June."



 



 

Some even started to look at him differently, tweeting, "Did I just never realize how creepy Matthew Morrison is until tonight, as I try to figure out which contestant he DM'd inappropriately... and find EVERY thing he says to EVERY girl is making me uncomfortable to watch? #SYTYCD."



 

'So You Think You Can Dance' Season 17 airs Wednesdays at 9 pm ET/PT.

Disclaimer: This article contains remarks made on the Internet by individual people and organizations. MEAWW cannot confirm them independently and does not support claims or opinions being made online. 
 
 
 
 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Malik has no idea Hondo knows his secret, and Adain Bradley says their story is far from over.
2026-10-17T20:45:16.000Z
Jo’s resignation raises questions about her future as ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ begins a new era in Season 23
2026-10-17T18:23:30.000Z
‘Tulsa King’ Season 4, starring Sylvester Stallone, streams every Friday on Paramount+
2026-10-17T10:36:40.000Z
Pavi and her long-lost twin Nisha hunt for their origins as the Havens cheer the last Avatar’s death
2026-10-17T08:37:00.000Z
Season 2 of the HBO Stephen King prequel jumps back to 1935 and a gang of bank robbers
2026-10-17T06:52:24.000Z
‘Fire Country’ season 5 episode 2 reveals Jake’s fate after the shooting as the team uncovers the attacker’s motive
2026-10-17T06:41:28.000Z
Wes ends ‘Sheriff Country’ Season 2 Episode 2 in the hands of Stoyanovs after exposing bakery bug
2026-10-17T05:35:47.000Z
Chad Lowe is the executive producer on ‘9-1-1: Nashville’ and has also directed many episodes
2026-10-17T05:07:28.000Z
Issa López returns as showrunner for a Jamaica Bay story with ties to ’Night Country’
2026-10-17T03:12:59.000Z
Oklahoma’s governor and Dwight’s love interest board a private jet in the first episode of Season 4
2026-10-16T09:30:07.000Z