Ex-Playboy model alleges Stephen Colbert made her feel uncomfortable on live TV: "Worst moment..."

"Yeah it was an extremely awkward, probably the worst moment of my life," she told later while recalling the moment.
PUBLISHED FEB 24, 2025
Stephen Colbert and Sarah McDaniel during 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' )
Stephen Colbert and Sarah McDaniel during 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' (Cover Image Source: YouTube | 'The Late Show With Stephen Colbert' )

Sarah McDaniel, a former Playboy model, criticized Stephen Colbert for making her feel uncomfortable, despite the fact that the veteran television host typically injects a good dose of professionalism with humor on his late-night show. McDaniel appeared on the show in 2016 after attaining internet fame as an influencer and model, she wore a brown colored tube dress with a plunging neckline that showcased ample cleavage. Her hands occasionally covered her dignity as she battled with the neckline during the interview, "Can I get you some duct tape or a poncho?" the comedian interjected watching her struggle. At one point while the Instagrammer was teaching Colbert quick lessons to ace a selfie the latter couldn't take it any longer and covered her spilling cleavage with a napkin. 



 

As per The Things, the viral moment garnered over 49 million views on YouTube, it was then picked up by streamer HasanAbi on his Twitch session in 2021. The model then had a conversation with the YouTuber about the embarrassing incident. They rewatched the particular segment together and HasanAbi reacted with disgust, "Kind of very f**ked up, it's very f**ked up," to which McDaniel cut in, "It is a little bit." She added, "Yeah it was an extremely awkward, probably the worst moment of my life." "You think he'd be able to do that s**t with like a Hollywood actress or something?" the young streamer continued to condemn Colbert's actions towards the unexpected wardrobe malfunction



 

McDaniel then tried to play the victim by stating that she was abused on live TV because she was not a star. "No way. It's because I was a nobody." However, fans were not convinced that Colbert behaved badly with the 'Some Kind of Drug' music video actress. According to The Things, the seasoned anchor was commended by viewers for his ability to retain composure and level-headed eye contact. "As a woman, I feel so bad for her that was probably so awkward. But I feel like he did a good job at making light of it so it wasn’t as awkward," a viewer commented under the viral video. "Can I get you some duct tape?" I'm dead. That was the best line in this whole awkward video. Girl, fire your stylist because that person hates you," a fan praised. 

Stephen Colbert attends Apple TV +'s Primetime Emmy Party at Mother Wolf on January 15, 2024 in LA, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by David Livingston)
Stephen Colbert attends Apple TV +'s Primetime Emmy Party at Mother Wolf on January 15, 2024 in LA, California. (Image Source: Getty Images| Photo by David Livingston)

"Stephen is being such a dad in this, I love it my father would flip if I had ever tried to leave the house in that!" an online user wrote in jest. "You have to admire his skill at keeping eye contact," another fan complimented Colbert for his gentlemanly behavior. "This got to be the worst designer piece somebody ever wore. She is literally covering herself with her hands. Awful," a fan slammed McDaniel. Meanwhile, Colbert did not list the model as one of his worst guest experiences, and she never made a comeback on the show. Her appearance in the music videos for the songs 'Summer Breaking' and 'Daffodils,' by Mark Ronson and Kevin Parker, further cemented her profile as a celebrity. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Kate Sharma and Anthony Bridgerton were the leading pair on Season 2 of 'Bridgerton' and will now make a return in the ongoing season.
6 hours ago
The scene from the library saw Benedict and Sophie have a conversation in French, which wasn't translated by Netflix.
8 hours ago
Season 4 of 'Bridgerton' is based on the book 'An Offer From A Gentleman' written by Julia Quinn and will be out in two parts.
8 hours ago
Brandon Sanderson's Cosmere is headed to Apple TV, which is developing 'Mistborn' as a feature film and 'The Stormlight Archive' as a television series
9 hours ago
A masked ball, a hidden romance, and a powerful new family set the stage as ‘Bridgerton’ Season 4 returns with secrets waiting to spill.
10 hours ago
The Premiere Ceremony will be streamed live at grammy.com and on the Recording Academy's official YouTube channel
11 hours ago
'Bridgerton' Season 4 kicks off with Part 1 premiering on Wednesday, January 29, followed by Part 2 on February 26
14 hours ago
As fans await Homelander's fate on 'The Boys', Antony Starr has secured his next TV role in Netflix's newly approved series
14 hours ago
Ahead of its highly anticipated release, Netflix recently released the first few minutes of 'Bridgerton' Season 4, Part 1
16 hours ago
Before the next chapter even drops, Netflix's courtroom hit got a vote of confidence, hinting that Mickey Haller's toughest fight is still ahead
18 hours ago