‘The Voice’ runner-up Jaelen Johnston finally breaks silence on forgetting the lyrics: 'The worst thing...'

"When you forget lyrics on stage. It really is the worst side of it, to be honest," Jaelen Johnston shared.
PUBLISHED MAY 23, 2025
A still of Jaelen Johnston from the finale of 'The Voice' Season 27 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @jaelenjmusic)
A still of Jaelen Johnston from the finale of 'The Voice' Season 27 (Cover Image Source: Instagram | @jaelenjmusic)

'The Voice' finalist Jaelen Johnston failed to remember the lyrics of a song during his finale performance. During part 1 of 'The Voice' Season 27 finale, which aired on May 19, Johnston, who was on Kelsea Ballerini's team, performed a rendition of 'What Was I Thinkin’ by Dierks Bentley. At one point during the performance, Johnston forgot the lyrics of the song, and to control the situation, he began humming for a couple of seconds. Regardless of the error, Johnston continued and finished his performance on a high note. As per Us Weekly, after Johnston's performance ended, Ballerini told him, "I know you had a moment early on where you got nervous. But the thing is, this is the most nerve-racking thing you could do. And the only thing that matters is how you recover.”



 

Then, Ballerini comforted Johnston by saying, "Everyone loves you. That was the most impressive part; you really showed up. I’m so proud of you.” During an interview with Entertainment Weekly after the finale, Johnston was asked to shed light on the best and worst parts of the NBC singing show. At first, Johnston decided to name the worst part and uttered, "I think the worst thing is when you forget lyrics on stage. It really is the worst side of it, to be honest." 



 

During the finale performance, when Johnston forgot the lyrics of the song, the only thing that was going through his mind was "What's the next line?" On the other hand, it was a piece of cake for Johnston to share the best part. "Making connections and friends, and it's been amazing. Everybody out here deserves to be here. They're phenomenal, phenomenal artists, even better people," Johnston told the media outlet. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by NBC's The Voice (@nbcthevoice)


 

While having a conversation with Parade ahead of the finale, Ballerini revealed the reason behind selecting Dierks Bentley's 'What Was I Thinkin' for Johnston. Then, the 'Cowboys Cry Too' hitmaker explained, "We picked ‘What Was I Thinkin" by Dierks Bentley, and it’s a fun moment. You get to see his grit, his edge. He picked on his own [song], ‘Cold’ by Chris Stapleton. I will be honest with you; I was worried. We got to rehearsal, and he sang it, and I said, ‘I think that's it. I think that's the moment.' Because I've been his coach for months now, and I didn't know he could sing like that until he sang that song, and so I think everyone will be as impressed as I was.”



 

Ultimately, Johnston's efforts fell short as Adam David from Michael Bublé's team was announced as the winner during the thrilling finale. However, Johnston remains grateful for the 'The Voice' experience. After the finale, Johnston took to his Instagram page and wrote, "What an absolute journey this has been!! To get second place in a competition I never thought I’d be in has been the most surreal feeling. It’s definitely a bittersweet thought knowing that it’s over, but the excitement of what’s to come makes it all worth it! I want to thank each and every one of you from the bottom of my heart for your constant love and support throughout this journey; there’s no way I would’ve been where I’m at without all of you."

RELATED TOPICS THE VOICE

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Sheinelle Jones' project was delayed twice after she took time off following husband's death in May 2025
10 hours ago
The revised airdate is now February 26, and will be the first episode after NBC’s Winter Olympics coverage
13 hours ago
The streamer dropped the updates at Apple TV’s 2026 Press Day on February 3
13 hours ago
'American Idol' Season 24 will be available for live streaming on Disney+ alongside its regular ABC broadcast
15 hours ago
Set to premiere on Friday, February 27, Monarch: Legacy of Monsters' Season 2 will reunite heroes and villains on Kong's Skull Island
17 hours ago
Ted Danson's inquisitive retiree isn't ready to stop poking around, with a fresh announcement teasing another mystery
17 hours ago
A 'Fallout' Season 2 post-credits moment drops a dangerous hint, pointing toward an old weapon and a terrifying new future
19 hours ago
As the New Vegas chapter ends, the wasteland expands again, with a new location teased and the future already locked in
20 hours ago
A past-timeline scene subtly foreshadows 'Fallout' Season 3's setting when The Ghoul and his wife joke about fleeing
20 hours ago
With Season 5 already secured, Mickey Haller's story keeps growing as bigger possibilities quietly hover in the background
21 hours ago