'Chicago Fire' Season 8 Episode 18: Sylvie Brett is left heartbroken with loss and fans don't think it's fair

In the episode, just as paramedic Sylvie Brett prepares to spend more time with her birth mother Julia and her unborn sister, the writers cruelly ripped Julia away
PUBLISHED MAR 26, 2020
(NBC)
(NBC)

Spoilers for 'Chicago Fire' Season 8 Episode 18 'I'll Cover You'

While most people are hunkering down to practice social distancing amid the growing coronavirus outbreak, many are tuning in to the TV for distraction and to forget about what's happening in the world. This week's episode of 'Chicago Fire' may have succeeded in doing that, albeit in the wrong way.

In the episode, just as paramedic Sylvie Brett (Kara Killmer) became certain of wanting to spend more time with her birth mother Julie, and her yet-to-be-born younger half-sibling, the writers cruelly ripped Julie away, leaving Brett an older sister to a girl who would grow up without knowing her mother just like her.

To recall, earlier this season, Sylvie was contacted by her birth mother, asking for a meetup. It took a couple of episodes for Sylvie to make the decision to meet her, but after she did, she and Julie have been meeting in nearly every episode, learning more about each other.

Throughout all this, Captain Matthew Casey (Jesse Spencer) has been beside Sylvie, and he was in this episode as well, as Sylvie received the devastating news about her mother, who died during childbirth. 

Though the situation is dire, Sylvie's younger sister is safe and healthy and the episode ends with Sylvie holding her newborn sister and crying for the loss of their mother. Fans were understandably upset as Julie was growing on viewers. 

One fan tweeted, "This one hurts. She just came back into Sylvie's life and now gone. In real life: As a mother, I tell people all the time when a pregnant woman goes in and comes back alive...give thanks because a lot don't get to see their babies. #ChicagoFire #OneChicago."

Another wrote, "Wow they killed Brett's mom off! Wowwwww... kinda speechless. #chicagofire," while a viewer observed, "Sylvie grew up without her birth mom and now her sister is too! This is so not fair!! #ChicagoFire." One viewer tweeted, "Not. Enough. Tissues. And, it has nothing to do w hoarding. #ChicagoFire."

Fans wondered why the show killed Julie so soon after Sylvie met her. One fan wrote, "Why bring her mom back only to kill her off like this? Sylvie was so happy and looking forward to being a family, you took that from her. Julie shouldn't have been killed off. Poor Sylvie and her baby sister. #ChicagoFire."

Another tweeted, "Man why did yall to that to Sylvie. She didn't deserve this and now I'm gonna go cry. She finally meets her birth mother and yall Took her away from her. You guys are so mean. At least she was able to hold the baby. I hope the baby's dad lets Sylvie see her. #ChicagoFire."

That's the hope on all viewers' minds now — that Sylvie gets to be a part of her younger sister's life. 'Chicago Fire' airs on NBC on Wednesday nights at 9/8c.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The finale saw him pip runner-up Channing Wilson and third-place Cassidy Daniels
2 hours ago
‘Heated Rivalry’ stuns fans as Episode 5 earns a rare perfect IMDb score, putting the queer drama in the same conversation as TV’s all-time greats
3 hours ago
The key art features Okarun and Momo, along with Turbo Grammy, against the backdrop of Bamora donning her Kaiju suit
4 hours ago
The 'I Love LA' stars Sennott as Maia, an ambitious influencer manager balancing complex personal and professional relationships
5 hours ago
‘Black Clover’ returns in 2026 with a dark new trailer, signaling Asta’s most dangerous battles are finally about to begin.
8 hours ago
Apart from Ms. Pat herself, the fifth season will feature series regulars Vince Swann, Tami Roman, Williams-Lee, and J. Bernard Calloway
8 hours ago
With Season 3 confirmed, 'Landman' faces shifting power, unresolved cartel threats, and returning stars, but not everyone will survive what comes next
8 hours ago
As fans eagerly wait to witness what the future holds in the upcoming 'Stranger Things' episodes, a clip recently revealed the fate of Derek Turnbow
10 hours ago
The seventh episode of 'Pluribus', titled 'The Gap', introduced viewers to the Darién Gap between Colombia and Panama
11 hours ago
The Straw Hats enter the dangerous Grand Line as Season 2 teases bigger battles, new enemies, and the arrival of fan-favorite Tony Tony Chopper
11 hours ago