'American Rust' Episode 3 Fan Review: Mixed opinions as murder whodunnit chugs slowly

Some felt that it was time to give the show a hard pass, while one section of the audience said the show had the potential to go the distance
Alex Neustaedter as Billy in 'American Rust' (Dennis Mong/Showtime)
Alex Neustaedter as Billy in 'American Rust' (Dennis Mong/Showtime)

This article contains spoilers for 'American Rust' Episode 3: 'Forgive Us Our Trespasses'

'American Rust' continued to crawl and impress the few faithful who tuned in religiously for the last couple of weeks to catch the Jeff Daniels-starrer. While the reviews on social media were largely mixed, there was some chatter about the latest episode that sees Billy Poe (Alex Neustaedter) being named the killer in the murder of former police officer Pete Novic (Jim True-Frost).

The rest of the episode centers around Isaac's (David Alvarez) journey to the West, and Lee's (Julia Mayorga) affair with Billy while her husband was still in New York. Fans took to Twitter to share their thoughts on the episode. "They went too far with this episode. Great cliffhanger but I hate when implications are not enough and writers feel the need to push.

RELATED ARTICLES

'American Rust' Episode 3 Review: The walls close in and secrets tumble out

'American Rust' Episode 2 Fan Review: Showtime show has 'potential'

The show was going great until Issac was pushed off train #AmericanRust," one of the tweets read. "What is with people on this show not doing better? Lol #americanRust" a tweet read. "Time for #AmericanRust hopefully episode 3 picks up. 2 was slow but it wasn’t terrible. Isaac please find a guy better than Billy," a fan opined.

Some felt that it was time to give the show a hard pass. "FYI, even if you love @Jeff_Daniels like I do, dont waste your time watching #AmericanRust on @Showtime Its a love letter to MAGA & is all in on the media driven so called “Economic Anxiety” BS that gave us Trump. Hard pass!!" There were contrasting views by one section of the audience as well. "Trying #AmericanRust it got more interesting after the 1st episode. It’s sorta unfair tv shows have to be all the things on episode 1. But that’s our current reality."

"I really want to like #AmericanRust, but I’m having trouble staying interested. Just me?" a fan remarked. 'American Rust' had their faithful still gunning for the show. "I may be watching too many shows right now. However, I absolutely love @Jeff_Daniels & #mauratierney so I had to add #americanrust today! I’m caught up & it’s GOOD!"



 



 



 



 



 



 



 

What are your thoughts on Episode 3 of 'American Rust'? 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Chris O'Donnell discusses his experience on '9-1-1: Nashville,' working with new cast members, and the possibility of more franchise crossovers.
2026-11-10T19:33:56.000Z
Netflix is adapting Edith Wharton's classic novel 'The Age of Innocence' into an eight-episode period drama led by Camila Morrone.
2026-11-10T17:37:21.000Z
'Chicago PD' Season 14 Episode 5 features a subtle family photograph that honours a beloved character from the show's past.
2026-11-10T17:26:15.000Z
Daniel Radcliffe bluntly reveals if he’ll watch the new ‘Harry Potter’ reboot
2026-11-10T09:33:32.000Z
Sonny discovers a possible link between Tracy Marks and Ellen in Episode 5, while Connie Britton reveals how makeup and VFX transformed her appearance.
2026-11-10T08:22:15.000Z
As ‘VisionQuest’ approaches its finale, Terry Matalas shares his hopes for more stories involving Vision and Ultron
2026-11-10T07:14:46.000Z
The series follows Benny, a former football player and homecoming king who forms a close relationship with Carmen
2026-11-10T05:54:22.000Z
Torres finds himself undercover in his latest mission, where a mysterious character complicates things for him
2026-11-10T04:10:28.000Z
Cher Horowitz has a teenager of her own in the Paramount+ sequel, and one of her former classmates is returning on screen and in the writers’ room.
2026-11-09T20:01:16.000Z
‘VisionQuest’ reportedly saves its only mid-credits scene for the finale, sparking theories about a possible ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ connection
2026-11-09T17:56:28.000Z