Josh King gave up his shot at 'American Idol' Top 7 — his next move left judges and fans in tears

Josh King's heartfelt gesture towards other contestant Mattie Pruitt has made him a fan-favorite despite being eliminated from the show: "Class Act."
PUBLISHED MAY 8, 2025
Screenshot of the host Ryan Seacrest and contestant Josh King from an episode American Idol'(Cover Image Source: YouTube | an episode of 'American Idol’)
Screenshot of the host Ryan Seacrest and contestant Josh King from an episode American Idol'(Cover Image Source: YouTube | an episode of 'American Idol’)

Making tough calls is not something new for the 'American Idol' judges; however, this season, with talents like Mattie Pruitt, Jamal Roberts, the rockstar Thunderstorm Artis, Gabby Samone, and Josh King, there is no denying that judges Lionel Richie, Luke Bryan, and Carrie Underwood are constantly having to rack their brains when it comes to picking the right contestant. During the May 5 episode, judges had to face a similar situation where they had to choose between the bottom two contestants, advancing one to compete with the top 7 of season 23 while sending the other back home.



 

The two contestants were none other than 16-year-old Pruitt and 23-year-old King. As the judges exchanged words on whom to save, King did something that stunned everybody on the set. He nodded his head towards Pruitt, hinting to the judges to pick her. Followings, the judges saved Pruitt and sent King home, as reported by People.

This gesture once again stole many hearts, prompting fans to start a "Josh King Appreciation Thread" on Reddit. One user described his gesture as a "Classic act." The second added, "He was pretty damn good this season." "Is there any other way someone as endearing and playful as Josh would exit the competition than by singing the lyric 'I wanna go home' over and over? We love you," wrote the third. 


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

Fans didn't shy away from expressing their feelings on King's Instagram post as well. One fan wrote, "Seriously THE sweetest and kindest heart. You made me cry as you gestured to the judges to vote for Mattie. Best of luck, Josh, reach for the stars!!!" Another added, "You had a great performance, but my heart exploded when you kept motioning for the judges to pick Maddy! That was so selfless! You have a bright future ahead of you, Josh!"



 

It was undoubtedly a surprising move, especially after King had opened up about how much the 'American Idol' experience and friendships meant to him. In an earlier episode, which aired on April 16, just ahead of his performance of 'All By Myself,' King made a surprising revelation: "Growing up, I was not a loner by choice, but not have that many friends." He continued, "I never had a place for me. Coming to ‘Idol’ changed all that. They’re some of the greatest friends I’ve ever had, and I love them for that,” he said, visibly choked up.



 

With a tense voice, he added, "But it’s that fear in the back of my mind that once this ends and this journey ends with ‘American Idol,’ things will go the way they used to be.” “I want to have as many good memories with everyone for as long as possible,” he told the camera. Later, during the judges’ feedback, Richie assured King, “I want you to believe this. Since Luke and I have been here, there has never been a class this talented, ever, for us. You will never, ever be alone again in your life. Never.”

RELATED TOPICS AMERICAN IDOL

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Set to premiere on January 26, 'American Idol' will be hosted by Ryan Seacrest, along with judges Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie
16 minutes ago
The 'One Chicago' trio of shows previously released two crossover events back in 2019 and 2025. The next crossover episode will take place in March.
1 hour ago
The upcoming Season 3 of 'Percy Jackson and the Olympians' is based on the third Rick Riordan novel, 'The Titan's Curse.'
2 hours ago
The prequel to the 'Legally Blonde' movies, 'Elle', stars Lexi Minetree, Gabrielle Policano, Chandler Kinney, and Zac Looker in key roles
3 hours ago
Season 2 finale ended with a confirmation that season 3 will return later this year
14 hours ago
Jennifer Morrison gets a quick glimpse as First Lady Jenny Hagan in the official trailer
16 hours ago
The hit Netflix show premiered in 2020 and ran three seasons before Netflix shelved the fourth
17 hours ago
Rob Perlman was seen in an unnamed role as a Super Mutant on 'Fallout' Season 2 Episode 6, along with The Ghoul, played by Walton Goggins.
17 hours ago
William Shatner's comments come afterStephen Miller, the White House Chief of Staff's criticism of the show
18 hours ago
'Fallout' Season 2 Episode 6, titled 'The Other Player', teases The Enclave's growing importance in upcoming episodes
18 hours ago