Lionel Richie says 'American Idol' comes down to popularity — fans agree it’s no longer about the best voice

'American Idol' fans slammed the show for being more about popularity contest than about singing competition.
(L-R) Photo of Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and host Ryan Seacrest from 'American Idol' (Cover image source: Instagram | @AmericanIdol)
(L-R) Photo of Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, Luke Bryan, and host Ryan Seacrest from 'American Idol' (Cover image source: Instagram | @AmericanIdol)

As 'American Idol' Season 23 nears its grand finale on May 18, the show has evolved into more than just a singing competition. Given that at this point in the game, judges have no say and all the power is in the voter's hands, even Judge Lionel Richie didn't resist pointing out, "It's an even playing field, but it comes down to popularity. How many fans do they have that like them as people?" he said in an interview with People. Having heard that, it's clear that audience votes are influenced not only by talent but also by contestants' personal appeal and fan engagement. This aspect has turned the competition into an interesting ride.


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

Unlike earlier, where viewers used their vote to make the best talent win, thanks to social media, contestants can now earn their fan base through personal connections or personal branding, engaging with them outside the show. This allows hopefuls not only to show their side but also gives fans an outlet to see their favorite contestants' performances or updates from their lives, even long after their journey on the show has ended. This change, however, saw a flood of criticism from fans. After Slater Nalley and Thunderstorm Artis got eliminated from the Top 5 episode. In a Reddit thread that reads, "I feel like some of y'all need to understand this isn’t a vocals competition," one person wrote, "This has never been a vocal competition since season 1… It’s a connection competition." The second one said, "Agree."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by American Idol (@americanidol)


 

Asking 'American Idol' makers to bring 'honest judges on board, one wrote, "I have to agree. I miss honest judging because now all they do is skew the audience's opinions, along with the soap opera sad life stories that shouldn’t have anything to do with a talent competition! This show hasn’t been about Star talent for many years. As an IDOL, one needs top talent, singing, performance fitness, entertainment factor, and, especially, personality and charisma. They are out there, but so far there have been too many years of mediocre talent, ho-hum judging, and the people’s vote. Winners aren’t close to IDOL status! I want honest judges, not afraid to ruffle feathers."



 

On the other hand, 'American Idol' has consistently proven itself as a launching pad for artists, regardless of their final standing. Gone are the days when people thought nothing beyond the elimination. However, history proves that many contestants who didn't clinch the title also secured record deals and achieved significant success in their lives after the show.   A famous example is Jennifer Hudson, a finalist of season 3, who went on to become an EGOT (Emmy, Grammy, Oscar, Tony) winner after her exit from the show. Other famous names who made it big despite leaving 'American Idol' include Chris Daughtry, Adam Lambert, and Katharine McPhee (to name a few), as reported by Yahoo.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The Season 2 finale is out, and the cast is already gearing up for another round of the Harrigan family saga
2026-11-20T12:42:07.000Z
Harry outsmarts Kat and saves the Harrigans, but Eddie’s botched bombing leaves Jan’s fate uncertain in the dramatic ‘MobLand’ Season 2 finale
2026-11-20T12:17:52.000Z
Netflix series ‘Altruists’ revisits the FTX scandal, but the real-life stories of its two central figures, Sam Bankman-Fried and Caroline Ellison, have taken very different turns
2026-11-20T09:14:03.000Z
The medical drama revolves around Lucia, a first-year resident at a prestigious Phoenix hospital
2026-11-20T07:02:02.000Z
After Tim and Lucy’s abduction, the crew gears up for a dangerous rescue mission
2026-11-20T06:18:08.000Z
Trevor Jackson's return to Grey Sloan takes an unexpected turn in the ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Season 23 fall finale, leaving his health in question
2026-11-20T05:51:21.000Z
Mark Grayson takes on greater responsibilities as he struggles to protect Earth while navigating the personal toll of being a superhero in Season 5
2026-11-20T05:27:48.000Z
Hooks was stabbed to death during private yard time, prompting the FBI to investigate anyone who may have had a motive
2026-11-20T04:31:44.000Z
'The Gilded Age' is enjoying its strongest season yet, with viewership nearly 20% higher than the previous instalment
2026-11-19T20:50:24.000Z
This ‘Off Campus’ star reveals why his planned Season 2 return fell through, leaving questions about Allie and Dean’s story and his future.
2026-11-19T20:32:39.000Z