'American Horror Story 1984': Sarah Paulson has a surprise cameo and we're hoping she's the big bad

In a recent interview, Paulson teased that she might 'pop up' in the upcoming ninth season which bears eerie similarities to season 2, 'Asylum'.
PUBLISHED SEP 12, 2019

While fans were still getting used to the idea of a Sarah Paulson and Evan Peters less 'American Horror Story' season, Paulson has now given them something to cling on to. In a recent interview with Entertainment Tonight, Paulson teased that she might 'pop up' in the upcoming ninth season, titled 'American Horror story: 1984', and that has got us wondering whether she could be the big bad villain this time!

A veteran on the show for the last eight seasons, Paulson's most remarkable performance was in the form of journalist Lana Winters in the second season of the show, called 'Asylum'. What's more striking is that the ninth season, aka '1984' has some eerie resemblances and possible connections to the past, circa the setting of 'Asylum'.



 

The main element of horror in season 9, '1984' happens to be an escaped murderer from a psychiatric ward. The murderer, dubbed as Mr. Jingles, is an ax-wielding psychopath who targets a group of young kids at a lakeside camp, in a very 'The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, and 'Cabin in the Woods' style. He wears a mask and while he might bring back memories of Leatherface from the chainsaw massacre horror, or even Michael Myers from the 'Halloween' franchise, Mr. Jingles also bears certain resemblances to the 'Asylum' murderer, Bloodyface.

In 'Asylum', we saw Bloodyface as the serial killing psychopath Dr. Oliver Thredson, played by Zachary Quinto. Oliver worked at the titular asylum where Paulson's character Lana was held against her will for conversion therapy after she was outed as a lesbian back in the 60s setting of the season. Oliver showed her a route to escape but it was all a ruse to kidnap her and impregnate her with his child, for some sick twisted needs of his. But even though Lana managed to escape Oliver's confinement, she did end up getting pregnant, gave up the child for adoption, thus giving rise to Bloodyface 2.0 with severe abandonment and mommy issues.



 

Now, the reason why we think Mr. Jingles could be the same old Lana Winters, aka Paulson 'popping by' this season, is because 'Asylum' had ended with Lana shooting her son, aka Bloodyface 2.0 in a final face-off. Our theory is that Lana was taken captive at the time, following the murder of her son, and admitted back to a psychiatric facility and 20 years later, in '1984', she has broken out of the ward to resume her son's unfinished business, because well, that's how the twisted ways of Ryan Murphy's storytelling works. 

All of this is just speculation though, but it's not that difficult to connect the dots. As of now, we are just thrilled that the possibility of seeing Paulson still lingers in the upcoming season nine, arriving this September 18, at 9 p.m. only on FX.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

As fans eagerly wait to witness what the future holds in the upcoming 'Stranger Things' episodes, a clip recently revealed the fate of Derek Turnbow
51 minutes ago
The seventh episode of 'Pluribus', titled 'The Gap', introduced viewers to the Darién Gap between Colombia and Panama
1 hour ago
The Straw Hats enter the dangerous Grand Line as Season 2 teases bigger battles, new enemies, and the arrival of fan-favorite Tony Tony Chopper
1 hour ago
With 'Bridgerton' Season 4 set to premiere on January 29, 2026, fans are speculating if the makers would drop the trailer on December 25
2 hours ago
Season one premiered on Apple TV+ on Oct. 10 and comprised 10 episodes
1 day ago
Chappelle announced his show before the main event during the Jake Paul vs. Anthony Joshua fight night
1 day ago
An unexpected decision shakes the ‘NCIS’ universe, casting uncertainty over Tony and Ziva’s next chapter
1 day ago
Matt and Ross Duffer teased the the fan-favorite character's fate using Funko Pops on 'The Tonight Show'
1 day ago
 "All the Things She Said" by t.A.T.u. was one of the most viral songs back during its release in 2002
1 day ago
‘Heated Rivalry’ is officially skating into season two, with HBO Max doubling down on Shane and Ilya’s story after the breakout first season.
1 day ago