'World of Dance': Derek Hough says no to Maddy, fans are shocked he didn't like her 'exceptional performance'

Derek has always been a fan-favorite judge because of his objectivity but he left viewers upset with his decision about Maddy
Maddy Penney (NBC)
Maddy Penney (NBC)

Derek Hough has always been appreciated on the 'World of Dance' for being a fair and objective judge. He pays close attention to the technical aspects of the movements, understands the nuances involved and judges all dance forms without any biases. But on the latest episode of 'World of Dance', even the fan-favorite judge had a slip-up moment that left viewers slamming him.

The final qualifiers round featured none other than the two-time winner Youth America Grand Prix — Madison Penney aka Maddy Penney. The famous ballet dancer came on the show to showcase her incredible contemporary ballet dancing skills and bust the myths associated with the dance form. After performing a jaw-dropping contemporary ballet routine to Noah Cyrus's 'Lonely', the 16-year-old dancer looked at the judges with high hopes for their feedback. While the judges praised her for her bold dance moves, they weren't too sure about how she would fit in the competition. So, Ne-Yo decided to give her a call back option while Jennifer Lopez decided to give a yes. It was finally Derek's turn and he decided to pass on Maddie and told her a no. Although Maddie eventually made it to the duels round, when Ne-Yo decided to change his mind and give Maddie a yes, fans weren't happy with Derek.



 

Several fans expressed surprise and disappointment with Derek's judgment. A fan tweeted, "Did Derek actually say 'no' to Maddy? What the heck? she was amazing #WorldOfDance." Another fan wrote, "Can't believe Derek said no. She's incredible and (if you didn't know), she's literally a YAGP winner and is considered to be one of the best ballerinas of her age in the world!" One more unhappy fan said, "What is going on this season? She is a world class dancer. There should have been no question about her moving forward. And a no from Derek?! I loved the last seasons of this show, but this year has been disappointing so far." Another fan shared, "Wow! I never been disappointed in Derek at all until now. She definitely doesn't deserve a no. I'm so glad she made it through." One pointed out, "Wow! This performance should’ve gotten all 3 yesssss! I’m disappointed in Derek. I thought he’d definitely notice how exceptional Maddie was. I don’t know what they didn’t see but I saw her emotions and her lines were amazing!"

'World of Dance' Season 4 airs every Tuesday at 10/9c only on ABC. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Joanne and Noah prepare to live together as Sasha and Morgan face a connection neither has acknowledged.
2 hours ago
A New Year’s Eve celebration brings old friends together before the night takes an unexpected turn.
4 hours ago
‘The Shards’, starring Kaia Gerber and Homer Gere, aired its season finale on September 9
9 hours ago
‘The Rainmaker’ follows underdog lawyer Rudy Baylor, played by Milo Callaghan, who takes on powerful opponents in court
12 hours ago
CBS’ latest sneak peek for ‘Cupertino’ features Busy Philipps along with Mike Colter and Rachel Keller in the lead
12 hours ago
'The Office' spin-off released all the episodes of its second season on September 9, 2026, on Peacock
12 hours ago
'Chicago Fire' will return with Season 15 on Wednesday, October 7, 2026, at 9 p.m. ET on NBC
15 hours ago
‘Rivals’ fans finally have a date to circle for the return of Season 2
15 hours ago
Scott Speedman's ‘R.J. Decker’ Season 2, set to premiere on September 15, will shed light on R.J.’s childhood
15 hours ago
The full trailer for Mike Flanagan’s ‘Carrie’ reveals a familiar story in a new setting
16 hours ago