‘Wheel of Fortune’ contestant was on a massive winning streak — until one bonus round word cost her $75K

Despite missing out on $75K, ‘Wheel of Fortune’ contestant still scored a trip to Vegas and big cash prizes
A screenshot of contestant Cindy Koenig during an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune' Bonus Round (YouTube/ 'WOF')
A screenshot of contestant Cindy Koenig during an episode of 'Wheel of Fortune' Bonus Round (YouTube/ 'WOF')

'Wheel of Fortune' is one of those hit reality TV shows where dreams really can come true — but for Cindy Koenig, that dream barely lasted a few minutes. In a recent episode, Koenig, from San Diego, appeared on the show with her husband Alex and daughter Lauren. She competed against Wanda Coleman from Country Club Hills and Brent Bates from Las Vegas. Koenig took an early lead, winning the Toss-Up Round, the Express Round, and the Mystery Round, racking up a total of $18,500.

She had also won a sparkly Million Dollar Wedge, and an exciting trip to MGM Grand in Las Vegas, worth $7,500, while Coleman and Bates wound up with only $1K and 43K, respectively, as per Andy Nguyen's blog. But things took a dramatic turn when Koenig entered the Bonus Round. She picked the dreaded category "Phrase," and after picking up the golden envelope, she faced a four-word puzzle with —R, S, T, L, N, E— filled in. 

A screenshot of Cindy Koenig winning the million-dollar wedge during an episode of 'WOF' (Image Source: YouTube/'WOF')
A screenshot of Cindy Koenig winning the million-dollar wedge during an episode of 'WOF' (Image Source: YouTube | Wheel of Fortune)

Koenig chose the consonants and a vowel to be M, G, P, and I to finally reveal the puzzle that read, "I T _ _ G G E _ M _ M E M _ R _." As soon as the timer started ticking, Koenig gave two quick answers, "It joggles my memory," "It juggles my memory," but neither of them was correct. Her confidence started shaking as she realized her race against time was coming to an end. When the clock ran out, host Ryan Seacrest exclaimed, "Oh, take a look up there. You're right on the edge of it," revealing the correct answer, "It jogged my memory." "Argh," Koenig gasped. 

A screenshot of Cindy's Bonus Round Puzzle during an episode of 'WOF' (Image Source: YouTube/'WOF')
A screenshot of Cindy's Bonus Round Puzzle during an episode of 'WOF' (Image Source: YouTube | Wheel of Fortune)

Seacrest further revealed the $75,000 on the envelope, which Koenig had missed out on winning. While Koenig handled the loss with grace, fans weren't as forgiving. On the YouTube comment section of the video, a fan of the show wrote, "Wow, I can't believe she didn't get that! I said it immediately." Echoing the sentiment, another viewer of the show added, "How did she get 'JOGGLE' when there’s no L??" Noting the show's pattern, a YouTube user said, "These contestants need to get their act together in the bonus round; this season is just getting started."

A screenshot of Ryan Seacrest with Cindy Koenig during Bonus Round (Image Source: YouTube/'WOF')
A screenshot of Ryan Seacrest with Cindy Koenig during Bonus Round (Image Source: YouTube | Wheel of Fortune)

Meanwhile, another 'Wheel' viewer penned down, "She’s one of those people who butchers common phrases and doesn’t know it was 'jogged.” I mean, “joggled”?" However, a viewer defended and contestant and wrote, "They're only easy if you know it." Drawing a playful comparison between Seacrest and longtime host Pat Sajak, one YouTube viewer quipped, "a YouTube user also wrote, 'Aren't we glad it wasn't the million this time? Ryan's had two shots at it now (unless my math is off), but the contestants aren't pulling it off! (In the old days, Pat would jokingly thank the players for ensuring the show would be able to have its Christmas party, or something along that line, whereas if they won big, he'd sometimes say, 'Well, there goes the Christmas party!')

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

‘Marshals’ welcomes one new face and expands the role of a familiar character in the upcoming season.
1 day ago
Ahsoka and Sabine remain stranded on Peridea as Thrawn moves to bring war to the New Republic.
1 day ago
‘The X-Files: I Want to Believe’ featured just one name when released in 2008; now it honors three more luminaries
1 day ago
Season 1 ended with Sybylla’s story at a turning point, leaving her future open, with Miles Franklin’s sequel is hinting at more to come.
1 day ago
'Stuart Fails to Save the Universe' received an exciting update after the 'TBBT' spinoff became HBO Max's second-biggest comedy launch worldwide.
1 day ago
'The Rookie' star is bringing a familiar role back to the DC Universe in 'Mister Miracle,' adding another appearance to his growing series of roles.
2 days ago
‘Silo’ Season 3 Episode 7 ends with major revelations about Kennedy, Knox, the Safeguard Protocol, and the mysterious origins of the silos
2 days ago
Earlier reports indicated that Disney+ had begun development on the project in March 2025
2 days ago
Everything you need to know about when ‘Lanterns’ premieres on HBO Max, including the release date and time.
2 days ago
Juno Temple addresses Roy and Keeley reunion rumors in 'Ted Lasso' Season 4, with fans wondering where their relationship is headed
2 days ago