‘Wheel of Fortune’ player was one guess from winning $40K — then lost it all with terrible letter choices

Anyone who's watched ‘Wheel of Fortune’ could’ve seen this Bonus Round blunder coming
PUBLISHED JUN 24, 2025
A picture of 'Wheel of Fortune' host Ryan Seacrest (L) and contestant Tamika Starr (R) on the sets of the show. (Cover Image Source: YouTube/Wheel of Fortune)
A picture of 'Wheel of Fortune' host Ryan Seacrest (L) and contestant Tamika Starr (R) on the sets of the show. (Cover Image Source: YouTube/Wheel of Fortune)

Wheel of Fortune’ contestant Tamika Starr got the fans fuming! The singer from Triangle, Virginia, who works with the armed forces, had a great start and was scoring high until the Bonus Round. Starr had earned $16,400 ahead of the round after beating her competitors Max Nussenbaum and Rebecca Levin. The Virginia native had to pick between three categories: ‘Person,’ ‘Thing,’ or ‘What Are You Doing?’ And she chose the latter. That was when the puzzle popped up and it read: “_ _ _ _ N _ / _ R _ _ N _.



 

The next thing that Starr had to do was guess four letters that could formulate the words, or at least give a hint of what they are. Among ‘The Wheel of Fortune’ fans, it is a renowned fact that the ‘What Are You Doing?’ category often has words ending in ING. So, it wouldn’t make sense to guess the letters. However, Starr’s letters of choice left the fans dumbfounded. She picked “I, G, C, and D,” which completed the puzzle halfway, but didn’t give enough clues to guess the words. Starr failed to make a correct guess, and the phrase was revealed as “Joking Around,” which cost her an extra $40,000.



 

Viewers couldn’t help but point out that Starr’s silly mistake cost her a round where she had a chance of winning big. “Nothing makes me more angry on this show than… Someone saying I & G on a ‘What Are You Doing’ final puzzle,” one fan wrote on the ‘Wheel of Fortune’ Reddit forum. I SCREAMED at the TV tonight. When they pick I and G and lose, I scream, ‘Serves you right!!!’” Another angry fan wrote. “I’m so glad I’m not the only one,” a third social media user remarked.



 

“Called a gerund phrase: Washing the dog, Making breakfast, Running errands ... this has bugged me too! Of course, in What Are You Doing, the first word will end in I N G,” another fan explained. “Totally agree and thought last night's contestant just blew it with those obvious letter choices,” a fifth Reddit user wrote. “WAYD bonus rounds seem to be a trap I'd avoid,” the same user added. “Ha! Last night I said I and G are such a waste of letters!” another fan quipped. Perhaps it’s the pressure of the game that makes the contestants fumble. But it could apparently happen to anyone, even the show’s host.



 

Recently, the fans lashed out at host Ryan Seacrest, blaming him for a contestant’s loss. On March 31, Todd Meyer faced off against Sheree Corder in a crossword round, and the category selected was “Party.” After Corder's guess went wrong, the chance went to Meyer, and he nailed it, guessing all four words correctly: Party Time, “Party Animal,” “Party Decorations,” and “Party Bus.” But the host deemed him incorrect! Why? Because he added “Party” before every word and Corder instead emerged as the winner. Fans were angry with Seacrest for not explaining the rules at the start and costing Meyer a huge win.

RELATED TOPICS WHEEL OF FORTUNE

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'From' star Catalina Sandino Moreno hinted that season 4 could arrive soon this year, teasing new dangers and long-awaited answers ahead
2 hours ago
'Mayor of Kingstown's' future takes a turn as Sheridan’s Paramount exit leads to a trimmed final season and tense questions, which is far from ideal.
2 hours ago
The fifth season 3 episode of the drama series will feature a pool party where gossip starts swirling around Lucy
3 hours ago
Together with Genie Francis's Laura, Geary maintained his throne as one of the most popular daytime actors of all time
3 hours ago
Drew Cain's life hangs in the balance after Willow's shocking move, sparking exit rumors around Cameron Mathison and dividing 'General Hospital' fans
5 hours ago
Following Willow's dramatic acquittal, fans were left hanging when the episode failed to air on Tuesday
6 hours ago
The teaser features the 'Venom' actor as the star, the writer, and showrunner of the six-episode series
16 hours ago
The images, revealed by CBS, show new characters part of the show slated to release March 1
19 hours ago
The weeks ahead trailer of 'A Knight of Seven Kingdoms' promises high-octane action and drama
19 hours ago
Willow’s shocking decision leaves Drew helpless and sets up significant fallout in upcoming episodes of 'General Hospital.'
20 hours ago