Stephenie Meyer wanted Henry Cavill to star in 'Twilight', NOT Robert Pattinson: 'Henry doesn't need s**t on resume'

Twitter is abuzz with chatter whether Henry Cavill's career would have been ruined had he played the sparkling vampire Edward Cullen in the 'Twilight' movie series
Robert Pattinson and Henry Cavill (Getty Images)
Robert Pattinson and Henry Cavill (Getty Images)

In news that may just blow your mind, we just got to know that 'Twilight' series author Stephenie Meyer initially wanted DC hero Henry Cavill to play the role of the sparkly vampire Edward Cullen. (We, meaning us non-committed Twilight stans)  She had him in mind, but the studio never approached him and the role went to Robert Pattinson instead and the rest is history. Fans are busy debating on the Internet whether that would have ruined Cavill's career, but honestly...Pattinson is now Batman and Cavill is Superman, so everybody wins, right?

For those unaware of the joy that was the 'Twilight' saga: It's one of those franchises that people love to hate on, but still watch it to trash it. It brought Kristen Stewart into the limelight along with Robert Pattinson as Bella Swan and Edward Cullen, respectively. Bella was your average-gawky nervous high-schooler, who all guys fall for, but she falls in love with the gorgeous 110-year-old vampire, Edward. After his valiant efforts of trying to push her away from him, he finally accepts that he is madly in love with her, but their future is far from rosy. In the beginning, he is constantly on edge as he fears that he has pushing her into danger, which causes him to leave her for a while in the second book 'New Moon'. Then Bella finds solace with Jacob (played by Taylor Lautner in the films). Obviously, he falls in love with her, and she loves him too, but not as much as she loves Edward. So it becomes a gigantic messy love triangle, while they fight off other thirsty creatures. Bella marries Edward and has a child with him and Jacob imprints on her. The books and films have been trolled enough and people still can't stop mocking it and the phrase 'Still a better love story than Twilight' has become an accepted expression, in today's day and age.

While it now seems unimaginable that Cavill could ever play the role of the brooding vampire, we really don't know how that would have panned out. He could still have become Superman--- a role that was greatly appreciated in a series of films that received much hate and flak. You wanted Superman, but got Batman instead (Sorry, the jokes keep coming). The question is, would Cavill have been a better Edward Cullen? It's hard to answer that question because the role of Edward just demanded one to be rather deadpan and blank-faced, with occasional moments of nose-twitches when a human gets near. You never know. 

Cavill is doing pretty well for himself right now, just like Pattinson is, it's only Stewart who is trying to find a strong footing at the moment in the mess that is Hollywood.  

Fans are sniggering right now and the snarky tweets are a joy to read. "Imagine living in an alternate reality where one of the major complaints about Henry Cavill as Superman is, “the dude from Twilight?," one fan tweeted.  "How is this news every semi-committed twilight stan here knows this. ALSO the movie would've been a lot funnier is very grown up henry cavill was playing ethernal 17 year old," another noted. "Good. The Twilight movies were basically a talented cast trapped in hell together. Cavill doesn’t need that kind of shit on his resume," one wrote. Others say that they still find it hard to dissociate Pattinson from Cullen. "I love Cavill, but I don't think I'd watch that cheesy, horrendous movie even for him. As it is , it's hard to disassociate Pattinson from whatshisname vamp," one tweeted. 



 



 



 



 

Well, you never know. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Joseph Eckert’s novel follows a father whose time jumps keep getting longer
2026-11-19T07:04:37.000Z
Vin Diesel reunites with action as a cemetery groundskeeper in his upcoming action thriller
2026-11-19T04:00:25.000Z
Originally released in March 2026, the film earned over $600 million worldwide and received positive reviews from audiences and critics
2026-11-19T03:29:04.000Z
Nearly two decades later, Jason is ready to return. Here's what we know about his next movie
2026-11-18T20:00:17.000Z
Denis Villeneuve opens up about the qualities he wanted in his new 007.
2026-11-18T19:56:17.000Z
‘The Comeback King’ trailer sends Glen Powell’s country singer back to college after a breakup scandal involving Madelyn Cline’s pop star.
2026-11-18T17:39:32.000Z
Brad Pitt wants to play Robert Pattinson's villain in Denis Villeneuve's 'James Bond' movie
2026-11-18T03:38:08.000Z
Josh O'Connor reportedly hesitated over screen tests as concerns about fame and the franchise's demands factored into his decision
2026-11-18T03:08:21.000Z
Tom Holland’s ‘Spider-Man: Brand New Day’ adds 10 minutes of unseen footage as fans await ticket sales and showtimes for the film’s return to theaters.
2026-11-17T15:33:01.000Z
Brad Pitt shares ‘Ocean’s 14’ filming is delayed to late 2027, though the original cast praises the script
2026-11-17T10:16:01.000Z