Jay Leno asked Jonathan Taylor Thomas an inappropriate question about his sexuality: "Did it just..."

Before asking the awkward question, Jay Leno said, "When a rumor starts, it spreads like wildfire..."
PUBLISHED MAR 21, 2025
(L-R) Jonathan Taylor Thomas in Los Angeles, California, United States;  Jay Leno appears on 'The Tonight Show' on July 7, 2004, at the NBC Studios in Burbank, California; (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | (L-R) Photo by Kevin Winter; Jeff Kravitz, Film
(L-R) Jonathan Taylor Thomas in Los Angeles, California, United States; Jay Leno appears on 'The Tonight Show' on July 7, 2004, at the NBC Studios in Burbank, California; (Cover Image Source: Getty Images | (L-R) Photo by Kevin Winter; Jeff Kravitz, Film

Jonathan Taylor Thomas, the teen heartthrob best known for his role as Randy Taylor on 'Home Improvement,' was no stranger to media attention in the '90s. However, during an appearance on 'The Tonight Show with Jay Leno,' the young actor was put in an uncomfortable position when Leno asked an inappropriate question about his sexuality. Leno kicked off the conversation by addressing the rumors that had circulated about Thomas. "When a rumor starts, it spreads like wildfire," he said, before elaborating, "Like, about two years ago, people went, 'Jay, he's gay. Jonathan Taylor Thomas is gay. My friend knows a guy, who knows a guy, who knows a guy..." He then asked Thomas, "Did it just drive you nuts?"



 

Thomas responded with remarkable composure, saying, "Well, you know, I mean, pretty much in Hollywood you're not anyone until it's rumored that you're gay, so, you know, I wasn't that upset about it." Leno chimed in with, "And not that there's anything wrong with that," to which Thomas quickly agreed, repeating the phrase. He then added, "But they're rumors, and you should always be kind of careful with that internet stuff." Throughout the exchange, the 'Tom and Huck' star remained calm and composed, refusing to be rattled by the host’s intrusive questioning. Despite Thomas addressing the rumors, Leno pressed further, asking him directly, "Are you gay?" Thomas, maintaining his cool, simply laughed and replied, "No, no, no." Even after receiving an answer, Leno continued, adding, "You know, it's fine. You know if you want to come out, it's fine."

Jonathan Taylor Thomas during 1997 Cable ACE Awards in Los Angeles, California, United States. (Photo by Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic, Inc)
Jonathan Taylor Thomas during 1997 Cable ACE Awards in Los Angeles, California, United States. (Image Source: Photo by Jeff Kravitz/FilmMagic, Inc)

Fans in the YouTube comment section of the interview video shared their reactions to the exchange. One fan wrote, "Oh okay, thanks for clarifying! I never understood where those rumors came from. Some people have way too much time on their hands online, smh." One netizen said, "What an awfully horrible and inappropriate thing to ask anyone on television. This show would be canceled if that happened today." A third one shared, "Jay Leno really put Jonathan on the spot when he asked that question. What if he was gay and wasn't ready to come out yet?!?! How embarrassing! Poor J.T.T.!"



 

Years later, Thomas gradually distanced himself from the entertainment industry. According to Us Weekly, he once told Premiere magazine, "You can't be trapped in this bubble called the acting industry. The industry is neurotic and weird, and so when I go home and I play basketball with my friends, I'm not Jonathan Taylor Thomas. I'm just Jonathan. I don't like hanging out with other actors and actresses."  The actor is now enjoying life away from the spotlight. "I’d been going nonstop since I was 8 years old,” he told PEOPLE in 2013. “I wanted to go to school, to travel, and have a bit of a break." He also added, "Never took the fame too seriously. It was a great period in my life, but it doesn’t define me. When I think back on the time, I look at it with a wink. I focus on the good moments I had, not that I was on a lot of magazine covers."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Fire Country' is inspired by the California fire department, but its actual shooting spots are quite surprising.
14 minutes ago
Production designer shares what each house in 'Your Friends & Neighbors' represents and where exactly fans can find it.
1 hour ago
After Jessica Jones, two other major characters from ‘The Defenders’ will possibly return to NYC in ‘Daredevil: Born Again’ Season 3.
5 hours ago
A longtime cast member's future hangs by a thread as ‘Grey’s Anatomy’ Season 22 nears its finale.
6 hours ago
Andrew 'Coop' Cooper is cleared of murder in 'Your Friends & Neighbors' Season 1, but in Season 2, he returns to more risky and criminal habits.
7 hours ago
‘The Chosen’ reaches its most intense chapter yet as Season 6 sets premiere date, with a bold release plan and a big-screen twist ahead.
8 hours ago
Season 2 of ‘Your Friends & Neighbors’ deals with darker themes as Coop continues to push his luck, and Jon Hamm gives a major update.
1 day ago
While no official date has been set for 'The Pitt' Season 3, reports suggest that it will premiere next year, without this fan-favorite character.
1 day ago
'The Pitt' has already been renewed for a third season by HBO Max and is currently in the writing stage.
1 day ago
Raj Dar and Mir Dar's fortunes took a turn for the worse following the death of the criminal mastermind father, Baba Dar.
1 day ago