Doesn't America have enough singles? ‘Love Island USA’ slammed for Aaron Evans' casting

Aaron Evans quickly makes a connection with 'Love Island USA' costar
Aaron Evans is a reality TV star from UK and the winner of 'The Traitors' UK Season 1 (@peacock)
Aaron Evans is a reality TV star from UK and the winner of 'The Traitors' UK Season 1 (@peacock)

LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA: The latest season of 'Love Island USA' has stirred up controversy with the inclusion of British contestant Aaron Evans. Known for winning the first season of 'The Traitors UK', Aaron’s presence on the American dating show has left many viewers puzzled and questioning the casting choice.

Fans have taken to social media to voice their confusion and displeasure, with tweets highlighting the contradiction of a British contestant on a show marketed as 'Love Island USA'. The core of the backlash seems to be that Aaron’s British nationality feels out of place on a show that typically focuses on American singles, leading fans to argue that the show’s authenticity is compromised.

While Aaron’s fame from 'The Traitors UK' might make him a familiar face to some reality TV fans, it doesn’t necessarily translate to the American audience. As the season continues, it remains to be seen if Aaron can win over skeptical fans or if the controversy will overshadow his journey on the show. 

"WHAT THE HECK IS AARON FROM TRAITORS UK DOING ON LOVE ISLAND USA!?" a fan said. "Bringing someone from the UK makes zero sense to me bc there's no way an actual relationship will work #LoveIslandUSA i also just remember aaron crying on traitors UK," said another. 

"I’m so confused why Aaron is here lol. I love the British accent & he’s hot but.. he doesn’t live in America??? Surely they can’t think him being on the Traitors UK would be a pull for viewers?? I’m so lost lol," added one. 



 



 



 

Aaron Evans develops connection with Kaylor Martin on ‘Love Island USA’ Season 6

On 'Love Island USA' Season 6, Aaron Evans and Kaylor Martin quickly developed a strong connection that captivated viewers. Their bond began over a shared love of food, as Aaron expressed his happiness, saying he felt like he was on top of the world when he was with Kaylor.

Kaylor also shared her feelings, contrasting her experience with Aaron to her previous interactions. She mentioned that her kiss with Rob wasn't as great as it was with Aaron, indicating a deeper connection and chemistry with Aaron.

In her confessional too, Kaylor described Aaron as "really hot" and expressed her admiration for their connection. She revealed how much she enjoyed their conversations, pointing out that they formed a great bond early on. Their mutual attraction and genuine connection made them one of the standout couples in the villa in the debut episode itself. 

'Love Island USA' islander Kaylor Martin is a college graduate student (YouTube/@
'Love Island USA' islander Kaylor Martin (@youtube)

Aaron Evans is the winner of ‘The Traitors’ Season 1

Aaron Evans, who won the first season of 'The Traitors UK' on BBC One, is now making waves on 'Love Island USA' Season 6. The inaugural series of 'The Traitors' aired from November 29, 2022, to December 22, 2022, and concluded with Aaron Evans, Hannah Byczkowski, and Meryl Williams emerging as the triumphant trio.

Currently, Aaron is working as a deckhand, a job that suits his adventurous spirit and physical skills. Given his knack for thriving in different environments, there’s also speculation that Aaron might complete a reality TV triple by joining a season of 'Below Deck' once his time on 'Love Island' ends.

'Love Island USA' contestant Aaron Evans is a mama's boy (YouTube/
'Love Island USA' contestant Aaron Evans (@youtube)

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The remaining five celebrity dance couples will be featured in the highly anticipated ‘DWTS’ Season 35 finale.
2026-11-18T05:11:46.000Z
Ezra Frech and Harry Shum Jr found themselves in the bottom two in the latest episode of 'Dancing with the Stars' Season 35
2026-11-18T02:34:32.000Z
'The Circle' returns with a new host, celebrity contestants, live audience voting and a revamped episode schedule for its eighth season.
2026-11-17T21:11:49.000Z
Whitney Leavitt, Joey Graziadei and JaNa Craig join ‘The Traitors’ Season 5 as 23 stars head to Alan Cumming’s castle for a game of betrayal.
2026-11-17T19:57:27.000Z
CBS has confirmed when ‘Survivor’ Season 52 returns with a change to its weekly episodes and new viewing details for fans of Jeff Probst’s competition.
2026-11-16T17:06:37.000Z
‘The Mob’ Season 1 Episode 8, titled ‘What Would Tony Soprano Do?,’ featured Maria, Chelsea, Harry, and Shane as the final four contestants
2026-11-16T08:24:35.000Z
Applicants may face background checks, interviews, and medical evaluations before producers decide
2026-11-14T03:06:32.000Z
13 years later, FOX is reviving one of its biggest reality competitions
2026-11-13T20:31:30.000Z
NFL quarterback Sam Hartman will lead the franchise's 30th season, which premieres in March 2027 after a hiatus.
2026-11-13T15:44:16.000Z
The next lead is usually selected from the preceding season of ‘The Bachelorette’
2026-11-13T09:26:56.000Z