'The Third Day' Episode 5 Review: A deep dive into grief as Helen and Ellie's past is revealed at Osea Island

The episode ends on a sobering, hard-hitting conclusion as Helen comes face-to-face with Jude Law's Sam
(HBO)
(HBO)

Spoilers for 'The Third Day' Episode 5 titled 'Tuesday - The Daughter' 

Midway through the fifth episode of HBO's 'The Third Day', Helen (Naomie Harris) is urged to embrace her grief. The death of her son has left a hole in her heart. She can't just leave it at that and she needs to embrace the sorrow, fall deep into the hole and let go. At the same time, elsewhere on the island, her daughter Ellie (Nico Parker) is opening up about some details surrounding her dead brother. 

This exchange coincides and reveals details that have been kept from the audiences so far. This information sure fills in the gaps in the storyline providing a much-needed backstory to their characters. In Episode 5 of 'The Third Day' titled 'Tuesday - the Daughter', we focus on the daughters of the past and the present. As it stands today, these young girls hold in their hands the future of the island. They just don't know it yet.

Written by Kit de Waal, Dean O’Loughlin and Dennis Kelly and directed by Philippa Lowthorpe, 'The Third Day' begins with consternation surrounding the delivery of Jess's (Katherine Waterston) baby. Helen offers her help when it comes to Jess, but bear in mind that she has no idea who Jess is, her one-night connection with Sam (Jude Law), and the offspring possibly being their child, the heir to the island. But no one helps her in her pursuit of looking for her husband. If anything, they only make matters worse by either lying to her of gaslighting. 

It is important to point out here about the Martins' shrewd presence on 'The Third Day'. Played by Paddy Considine and Emily Watson, Mr and Mrs Martin seem to drive the devil's chariot around on Osea Island. While Watson's 'take-no-'s**t' demeanor keeps most people at bay, it is Mr Martin's sugar-coated words that brings them around. When Helen finally confronts them about the truth about the whereabouts of her husband, they go on and on in circles. Throughout the sequence, the couple is building up to the fact that Helen should leave the island with her children. And perhaps it works because Helen stays back.

The episode ends on a sobering, hard-hitting conclusion as Helen (or shall we call her Caz now as Sam once had?) comes face to face with Sam, the man she had come looking for at Osea Island. Only this time, the question remains if she is meeting her husband and the father of their daughters or is she meeting the leader of the Odea Island. With only one final episode left, we will be answered next week. 

Episode 5 of the miniseries packs a surprising deal of intrigue despite the overbearing feeling that everything is going in circles. While it moves at a slow pace, it will be worth it to stick around for the upcoming finale episode. 

'The Third Day' airs 9 to 10 pm EST on HBO. The episodes will be available to stream on HBO Max following the airing.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Scola and Nina face a major relationship crossroads on 'FBI' as John Boyd addresses his future on the show
2026-11-17T06:36:49.000Z
Several actors, including Benedict Wong, will reprise their roles in ‘3 Body Problem’ Season 2
2026-11-17T05:01:11.000Z
Prime Video is adapting another book by Jack Carr from 'The Terminal List' universe
2026-11-17T03:50:27.000Z
Coughlan explains why she has no plans to watch the upcoming 'Harry Potter' series
2026-11-17T03:24:16.000Z
The early order makes the Emayatzy Corinealdi-starrer the second-longest-running original drama on Hulu
2026-11-17T03:18:14.000Z
CBS confirms winter returns and new premieres, with changes ahead for ‘Matlock’, ‘Ghosts’, ‘Cupertino’ and Matthew Gray Gubler’s ‘Einstein'.
2026-11-16T20:28:45.000Z
‘The Body’ faces competing petitions as fans defend the Netflix drama and its creators discuss how Season 1’s cliffhanger could lead to another season.
2026-11-16T14:17:52.000Z
The news comes ahead of the seventh season airing and just a couple of days after star Olivia Cooke said it is unlikely the show will go beyond Season 8
2026-11-16T14:05:53.000Z
'Landman' Season 3 invited cheerleaders and students to participate in its production
2026-11-16T10:02:15.000Z
‘Virgin River’ scores an eighth and ninth season on Netflix
2026-11-16T08:34:37.000Z