'The Third Day' Episode 5: Confused fans say one needs to smoke 'something really good' to understand the show

'I started watching The Third Day on HBO and it’s like one giant scary movie flag after another. Like I’m sry but whatever happens to you ppl in this show is your own fault,' a fan wrote
(HBO)
(HBO)

Spoilers for 'The Third Day' Episode 5 titled 'Tuesday - The Daughter' 

'The Third Day' aired its penultimate episode earlier tonight. The HBO miniseries that follows a husband and wife as they travel to a mysterious island and somehow become intertwined with the odd, rather creepy happenings there. The latest episode packed a fair bit of intrigue with high tensions, which, despite running at a slow pace, finally offers some much-needed insight into the storyline and character backstories.

In Episode 5, Naomie Harris' Helen, who arrives on the island looking for her missing husband (Jude Law), is without a doubt the star. Well, the actress has been the star of the show ever since Episode 4 when 'The Third Day' moved to its second chapter. In the penultimate episode of the miniseries, the actress makes revelations about her dead son, is continuing the search for her missing husband, helps a pregnant woman, delivers the baby of said pregnant woman without knowing the father is actually her husband, puts her (surviving) daughters' lives in jeopardy yet again and then heads on to confront her husband. 

For fans of the actress, this is a delightful treat. "Naomie Harris is five-alarm great in tonight’s The Third Day, the rare miniseries that has me dying to see what’s going to happen as we head into the finale," tweeted a fan.



 

At the same time, however, many viewers simply can't get over the fact that characters put their life in peril despite receiving warnings of otherwise. "I know Ellie is a kid but I'd never be alone in a cave with anyone with such dilated pupils, talking about gods, lighting candles and shit. #TheThirdDay," tweeted a fan, when Ellie (Nico Parker) followed the stranger (played by Freya Allan) into the cave. 



 

Why would you do the very thing that ten others are asking you not to? Disregarding every horror movie trope, characters on 'The Third Day' arrive at Osea Island and, well, fall in trouble. "I started watching The Third Day on HBO and it’s like one giant scary movie flag after another. Like I’m sry but whatever happens to you ppl in this show is your own fault," tweeted another fan. 



 

And many others can only agree. "Me watching The Third Day on HBO is like me giving multiple chances to people who will never change but I decided to give a chance anyway," one fan quipped. 



 

Meanwhile, some fans still haven't gotten a grip of what is going on on Osea Island and 'The Third Day'. Five episodes in, with back stories revealed and plenty of context provided, many viewers might not find the show confusing but even with all that, 'The Third Day' makes for a tricky watch specifically because of its storytelling technique. "I have given #TheThirdDay everything I got and I am still confused AF! I have come to the conclusion you have to be smoking something really good to get this. I give up. #hbo #overit," wrote a fan. 



 

'The Third Day' airs 9 to 10 pm EST on HBO. The episodes will be available to stream on HBO Max following the airing.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Netflix announced the return of the Omar Sy's gentleman thief coming back to screens after a lengthy hiatus.
5 hours ago
Netflix released the photo and teaser of the series currently on the floors in Atlanta, and pencilled for a 2027 release
6 hours ago
Season 3 of 'High Potential' is expected to release in January 2027, and the show's star shared her two cents on what she wanted to see
6 hours ago
In an exclusive sitdown with MEAWW, Darin Toonder also recalled the one fan comment that left him in stitches
7 hours ago
Supriya Ganesh's exit at the end of Season 2 drew a ton of backlash from fans, who suspected on-set drama was to blame for her unexpected departure.
8 hours ago
The third installment of the series is based on the second half of the video game 'The Last of Us Part II' and will focus on Abby's story
10 hours ago
Apple TV achieves EGOT status with ‘Schmigadoon!’s ‘Best Musical’ win at 2026 Tony Awards
12 hours ago
'FROM' is created by John Griffin and focuses on a small town that traps everyone inside
12 hours ago
Pauley Perrette played forensic scientist Dr. Abby Sciuto and often shared the screen with Brian Dietzen's Dr. Jimmy Palmer
12 hours ago
Lestat takes over the world as a rockstar as new relationships and more twists surface in the 'Immortal Universe.'
17 hours ago