Katy Perry called his voice ‘wild’ — but this laid-back 'American Idol' contestant barely reacted

Katy Perry also added, "You’re really good. Your voice makes us melt. It doesn't have this crazy range."
PUBLISHED APR 22, 2025
(L-R) Screenshot contestant Aaron Westberry from an episode of 'American Idol'; Screenshot of Katy Perry from an episode of 'American Idol'(Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)
(L-R) Screenshot contestant Aaron Westberry from an episode of 'American Idol'; Screenshot of Katy Perry from an episode of 'American Idol'(Cover Image Source: YouTube | American Idol)

Aaron Westberry may be one of the most laid-back 'American Idol' contestants. The Greenville boy who worked at a grocery store landed in the auditions of season 20, where he performed Sam Hunt's '2016' while playing the piano. When judges asked him, "Are you in college or anything?" Westberry replied, "I haven't made any big decisions yet." Hearing this, Katy Perry chuckled, "He hasn't made any big decisions; he is just appearing for American Idol." When he casually sat on the piano and started to sing, the judges Katy Perry, Luke Bryan, and Lionel Richie were surprised by his voice and the emotions he put in the lyrics.



 

Wrapping up the performance, Westberry walked back to the center of the stage, expressionless and with his hands in his pockets, looking at the judges. Curious about his easy energy, Richie couldn't help but ask, "Do you like working in the produce department? I mean, do you just have a passion for that produce? Westberry replied with a slow, drawling voice, "No." Richie asked again, "I didn't hear that." Westberry said it more enthusiastically this time, "No!" To which Richie replied, "There you go! That's what I was trying to tell you." Then he asked another question. "Do you want to be on American Idol?" "Yes!” replied the boy with an unimpressive tone.



 

"No, no, no. I’m going to ask you that again,” Richie said. "My bad, yes!” Westberry answered, this time raising his voice. “Understand that passion is the key here. You got it?” Richie, then, advised. Perry also added, "You’re really good. Your voice makes us melt. It doesn't have this crazy range. It doesn’t need this crazy range. It’s wild.” Bryan also didn't hold back and commented, "You have a heartbreak tone, man." "You can sing some stuff, and it pulls us in. We’re just like, ‘Oh my God, this kid is breaking our hearts. And you’re doing that with that tone you just gave us," he added. Bryan even went on to compare his performance with James Taylor. "You know James Taylor?" Bryan asked the young boy, who replied honestly, "No," shocking the judges and leading Bryan to say, "You are so raw, it isn’t even dead yet." Later, he also told Westberry, "You’re like walking melatonin."


 
 
 
 
 
View this post on Instagram
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

A post shared by Utah’s Live Comedy Scene (@happyvalleycomedy)


 

The judges sent the boy away with constructive advice, urging him to bring more passion and power to his vocals before delivering him three yesses. As the judges erupted with excitement, "You are going to HOLLYWOOD!" Westberry maintained his calm demeanor. He smiled while softly muttering, "Thank you very much," and then casually reached for his golden ticket, leaving the judges wide-eyed and speechless, totally stunned by his laid-back reaction to a life-changing moment!



 

Per the Greenville News, speaking of his success in the audition, Westberry said, "It took a while before it set in. I don't know; it was like the big stage and everything was going on... It just didn't hit immediately." The outlet also revealed that the 20-year-old discovered his passion for music during the COVID-19 pandemic while learning the tune of 'Pirates of the Caribbean' and hasn't stopped since. He told the outlet, "When we were quarantining, I had a lot of time and realized this was kinda fun, and it built slowly from there." He added, "I like a wide variety of music, and my style will be popish going forward."

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Lara Jean's sister, Kitty, moved to stay with her in New York ahead of completing her senior year in Season 3 of 'XO, Kitty.'
16 minutes ago
Yuri and Juliana share many meaningful moments throughout the season, all of which come to a head at Kitty's 18th birthday party.
3 hours ago
Much about the plotline for Season 4 depends on how 'Shrinking' Season 3 ends for Paul and Jimmy, and we'll find that when finale airs on April 8.
3 hours ago
With April underway, we offer a quick detail on everything we know about 'The Boys' Season 5.
4 hours ago
In Season 3, Kitty has her heart set on New York University, while Min Ho wishes to pursue a career as an entertainment manager in Seoul
5 hours ago
The latest episode of the medical drama series finds Dr. Charles overwhelmed after a series of stressful events, leading to his eventual breakdown.
6 hours ago
Lamar Odom's life comes under renewed attention, including his net worth, after the release of his Netflix documentary
7 hours ago
The 'One Chicago' shows on NBC are affected, along with other networks like ABC, CBS, and Fox, to air President Trump's live address to the nation
7 hours ago
Kate Bishop faced Kingpin in a fight that didn't have a conclusive winner, but why is she seen missing from 'Daredevil: Born Again' Season 2?
21 hours ago
Pippa Fitz-Amobi began her adventures on the debut season of 'A Good Girl's Guide to Murder' by investigating mysterious disappearances in her town.
23 hours ago