'Nancy Drew' Episode 2 sees the teen sleuth being haunted by Dead Lucy as Carson's association with the dress arouses suspicions

Nancy meets her father and questions him about the bloody dress she earlier found in the attic, but is his response really true?
PUBLISHED OCT 17, 2019

Spoilers ahead for episode 2 of 'Nancy Drew' titled 'The Secret of the Old Morgue'

Last week, the premiere episode of The CW's 'Nancy Drew' ended with the teen sleuth finding something rather astonishing in her own attic. After Horseshoe Bay's infamous sea queen Dead Lucy told her via the medium Harriet (Pamela Sue Martin) to look for the dress that she was found dead in, Nancy was drawn to her attic in the middle of the night. That is when she found the bloody dress in a trunk in her attic. 

"What is the dress of a girl who was murdered 20 years ago doing in my attic?" she thinks to herself. 

She begins to suspect her father Carson (Scott Wolf) to having something to do with this. While she doesn't ask him outright about Dead Lucy's dress in their attic, she is suspicious about Carson's involvement in this. Especially since she discovered he is dating Karen (Alvina August) shortly after the death of his wife. Upset with his decision to move on rather quickly when she is stuck coming to terms with her death. 

This leads her to the police station where she is set to investigate Lucy Sable's murder but is cut short by the police. Through the episode, Nancy is haunted by visions of Dead Lucy. Whether it is in the old morgue where she is looking for evidence for Tiffany Hudson's (Sinead Curry) murder or breaking into a car to steal the door pass of the coroner, Nancy can see Dead Lucy everywhere.

After being arrested for breaking in to steal evidence for Tiffany's murder from the morgue, Nancy meets her father when being held in jail. She questions him about the bloody dress she earlier found in the attic. Carson doesn't bat an eye as he tells her that the dress was a prop from once upon a time and was used as a running gag by Nancy's parents. But then, several years ago, Nancy had seen her mother and father dig up a trunk in the backyard as a young girl. But at that time, her mother tells her that it is all a dream. So he tells her that the trunk belonged to her grandmother and contained miscellaneous stuff she once owned. 

Seemingly satisfied with this answer, Nancy lets her guard down. At the end of the episode, she makes a promise to Dead Lucy - "I'm going to figure out who killed you too." 

But if it was only just a prop, why would Carson Drew burn the dress? How is he related to Lucy Sable's murder? And by extension, her mother?

'Nancy Drew' airs on Wednesdays at 9|8 c. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

The final season will be trimmed down to eight episodes after having 10 for seasons 1 to 4
10 hours ago
The series follows international supermodels dying mysteriously with Kutcher at the center of it all
11 hours ago
A latest rumor doing the rounds now promises a big year for the live-action Netflix series
13 hours ago
Daniel Ezra recently shared a sneak peek from the upcoming eighth and final season of the sports drama show
15 hours ago
'Jeopardy! Champions Wildcard' is produced by Sony and will air new episodes exclusively on Hulu and Peacock
15 hours ago
As fans form their own theories about how 'Outlander' will end, Heughan made a surprising revelation about the series
16 hours ago
Fans believe that 'Stranger Things' Season 5 includes a secret Episode 9 set to release on Wednesday, January 7
18 hours ago
Anthony Geary, who remained a part of 'General Hospital' for almost four decades, passed away on December 15, 2025
18 hours ago
The eighth episode of 'Landman' Season 2 finally gave Tommy some respite as he found his perfect replacement
19 hours ago
Despite strong praise, Harlan Coben's 'Run Away' will not be getting a sequel and the reason makes total sense
19 hours ago