'The Curse Of Oak Island' Season 8 Episode 12: Did Christopher Columbus sail to the island? Fans slam Rick's joke

The question remains, is it really a key?
Rick Lagina (History Channel)
Rick Lagina (History Channel)

There was so much in this episode, that fans still can't process it. For starters, the team found a key. Could it be the key to the treasure vault? The team is 'gobsmacked' by their discovery and are mulling over numerous theories. For the past few episodes, they've been sure that they're close to the Money Pit and going by the looks of it, they might have just found it at long last. This key is an exciting discovery for them...not for fans, who remain skeptical as ever. Rick Lagina is sure that they're on the right path to solving the treasure mystery that has been plaguing researchers, scholars and historians since the 1790s. 

The question remains, is it really a key?

Here's what the fans have got to say. "I'm gobsmacked over at lever wit a square ole in it," a fan tweeted, making fun of the team as usual. Another wrote that it looks like an Ikea tool. "Come on...it looks like an IKEA tool! #OakIslandCursers #curseofoakisland," the fan wrote.  "Gary Drayton has discovered something...that could be...a moderately interesting discovery," another tweeted. Other fans couldn't help laughing at the 'inane' discoveries the team has been making throughout the course of the show. "#curseofoakisland #oakislandcursers If I made a parody show of Oak Island, I would need a good sounding voice that could make the same 10 statements over and over, 100 pieces of cloth, leather and nails, a few coins and 100 snarkers... Let's do it!!" a fan tweeted. "On an alien planet there is a prank TV show where they plant random shit on the island. whichever alien team gets the #curseofoakisland boys to spend the most money chasing their planted item wins," another tweeted.

Fans want to go back to the serpent mound, as they feel that would be a more productive dig. "Can we go back to the Serpent Mound....I feel like we might be more productive there.," one tweeted. Others had some legit questions. "Another question: if there are so many booby traps around the money pit, how did the first searcher teams get so much further than this team with the modern technology at their disposal? #OakIslandCursers #CurseofOakIsland," one asked. Meanwhile, the team theorizes the shoe they discovered is from 1492, and Rick makes a joke that Christopher Columbus sailed to the island. Of course, fans didn't let that one go. "Columbus sailed the ocean blue in 1492... yeah, that’s right, m’fers. OakIslandCursers #CurseofOakIsland," a fan tweeted. "1492 COLUMBUS SAILED THE OCEAN BLUE. TO OAK ISLAND?," another asked.



 



 



 



 



 



 



 



 

Tune into History Channel, on Tuesdays at 9 pm. 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Samuel L. Jackson takes centre stage in Taylor Sheridan's crime universe as 'Frisco King' unveils its first trailer
2026-11-18T19:22:07.000Z
‘Ginny & Georgia’ Season 4 first-look photos tease pregnancy drama, strained friendships and family secrets ahead of the Millers’ Netflix return.
2026-11-18T18:42:27.000Z
Muse Watson explains why working with Mark Harmon felt familiar, while Kyle Schmid recalls a reunion that left the ‘NCIS: Origins’ set silent.
2026-11-18T14:52:34.000Z
‘The Joker's Wild’ is coming back with its signature trivia format, giving contestants a chance to compete for jackpots worth up to $50,000
2026-11-18T09:47:22.000Z
The CBS drama will be back sooner than its previous seasons, with a new Sunday night lineup also in store
2026-11-18T08:49:37.000Z
'NCIS: Origins' takes Mark Harmon's Gibbs to the past to find answers about Lala's disappearance
2026-11-18T07:32:52.000Z
Jon Cryer is back on CBS with a guest appearance that puts him in a very different position from his iconic sitcom role.
2026-11-18T06:39:09.000Z
Torres begins the episode undercover with a drug gang, but the operation quickly takes an unexpected turn
2026-11-18T05:33:40.000Z
Ralph Fiennes has a playful idea for Robert Pattinson's next major role, years after they shared the screen in 'Harry Potter'
2026-11-18T04:13:45.000Z
'The Innocent' follows Matt Hunter, whose life begins to unravel when he and his wife try to buy a house in his old hometown
2026-11-18T03:34:18.000Z