Showrunners of 'Lucifer' reveal what could have happened in Season 4 if the show was not canceled by Fox

The question of if you could fall in love with the devil would have been answered in Season 4. However, showrunners are hoping some other network can save their show
Caste of Lucifer (Source:Getty Images)
Caste of Lucifer (Source:Getty Images)

It is only natural to ask what could have been. 

Fans of 'Lucifer' were left heartbroken last week when Fox canceled the show after three seasons. The final episode that aired on May 14, left a problematic cliffhanger as Chloe saw Lucifer's devil face for the first time.

Co-showrunner Joe Henderson admitted that they wanted to keep it open-ended on purpose as they knew their fate may likely get sealed. 

"We knew we were fighting for our lives, so we created a season finale that demanded our return," Henderson told Deadline.

"Set up exciting new character dynamics that you couldn't wait to see come to life next season. We were still pretty confident on renewal, so we wanted to push things over the edge and make it impossible to cancel us. Oops!" he exclaimed.

His co-showrunner, Ildy Modrovich added, "We had no idea that we wouldn't get a chance to wrap up our story in some way."

The showrunners knew it was time for Chloe to know the truth. "We really are sorry to our fans if we won't be able to explore the fall out of that discovery," Modrovich stated.

While we may never see what follows next, Henderson teased the storyline we would be witnessing had the show been renewed. "That was the big thrust of season 4, exploring Chloe dealing with those ramifications, and how it affected her relationship with 'Lucifer'. Both professionally and personally. Can you work with the Devil? Can you love the devil?"

Modrovich also shared that surprise was in store for the fans.

"We also had an exciting character from Lucifer's past who was going to come in and mix everything up. A very personal, intimate figure who we won't reveal the identity of yet… until we find out if we get the chance to tell the tale on a new network."

Henderson affirmed that there are "many more stories to tell" for the show, while Modrovich said they were "hopeful" for another network to pick it up.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Tonight's episode of 'Jeopardy' saw Shannon Leigh Godwin competing against Spencer Murphy and Stefanie Landeweer
2026-10-29T09:41:51.000Z
The new Alfonso Cuaron series follows a documentary filmmaker who investigates a mysterious 20th-century cult
2026-10-29T08:57:38.000Z
Michael Weatherly reveals why he left ‘NCIS’ in 2016, as Tony DiNozzo returns in Season 24 as the agency’s new director
2026-10-29T08:11:15.000Z
'Chicago P.D.' Season 14 Episode 4 focuses on a robbery in the 11th district, where Voight collaborates with a new officer played by Naiqui Macabroad
2026-10-29T06:27:31.000Z
‘Chicago Fire’ Season 15 revisits Kelly Severide’s decision to turn down an OFI position and remain at Firehouse 51.
2026-10-29T04:53:48.000Z
‘Chicago Med’ Season 12 Episode 4 forces Dr. Abrams to confront family struggles
2026-10-29T03:18:53.000Z
Spencer Hudnut reveals why his idea for a Kayce and Rip team-up never reached the screen.
2026-10-28T20:07:53.000Z
Claire Danes returns as author Aggie Wiggs in 'The Beast in Me' Season 2, with a new family connection set to add another layer to Netflix’s thriller.
2026-10-28T19:34:48.000Z
Colin Farrell and Emma Fogarty’s 'The Slightest Touch' explores enduring friendship, Fogarty’s life with a rare skin condition, and their journey.
2026-10-28T19:21:08.000Z
Hannah Dodd and Masali Baduza take the lead as Francesca and Michaela navigate grief and a second chance at love.
2026-10-28T18:44:23.000Z