'Prodigal Son' Episode 2 'Annihilator': Who is the girl in the box Malcolm thinks he saw in his father's study?

A nightmare of "a girl in the box" keeps coming back to Malcolm. He is desperate to find out what it means and who she is.
PUBLISHED OCT 1, 2019

Spoilers ahead for episode 2 'Annihilator' of 'Prodigal Son'

When a quadruple homicide is brought his way by the NYPD, Malcolm Bright (Tom Payne) jumps at the chance to work with Gil Arroyo (Lou Diamond Phillips). This time around, there are four victims at the dinner table on the crime scene with the head of the family tied in such a manner that he could see the misery and pain of the rest of the family before dying. As Malcolm tries to get into the mind of the killer to know how he went about the killing, he finds himself dealing with something else. 

Last episode, Bright had paid a visit to his serial killer father Dr Martin Whitly (Michael Sheen), who is better known as The Surgeon, in the psychiatric facility where he is kept. While this visit somewhat pushes him on the right path for the investigation, the repercussions of seeing his father for the first time in several years doesn't sit well with Bright. His mental health begins to deteriorate - he starts getting frequent night terrors, tremors, anxiety attacks and PTSD. 

It is one particular nightmare that keeps coming back at him relentlessly. 

It is revealed at the end of episode 1 that when Dr Whitly was arrested in the 90s, it was Bright who had phoned the police on his father. This is also where he meets Gil Arroyo for the first time - he is Dr Whitly's arresting officer. Following the arrest, Bright doesn't meet his father for long but is haunted by one vision. There is a girl in a box that Malcolm had seen - a girl crouched shut into the box and terrorised, in his father's study. Her face is not visible to Malcolm neither is it shown on the screen, but there is something disturbing about the way she is crammed inside. And then, he wakes up. 

These nightmares keep coming back to him, but he cannot seem to make a thing of it. At the same time, his father's persistence that they are both the same could mean that there is a possibility that the "psychotic inclinations" that he was fired from the FBI could, after all, mean that the father-son duo is not all that different. 

But Bright is more interested in finding out the mysteries that are hidden away in his childhood. Tormented by these terrors, Malcolm is faced with a question: are his dreams just nightmares or did they actually happen? 

When Malcolm tells his mother Jessica (Bellamy Young) about these nightmares and his urge to find out the truth behind it, she puts it aside - as she has all these years. We are guessing that Malcolm's mother might know more than she lets on. Who on 'Prodigal Son' has the answers? 

'Prodigal Son' airs on Mondays at 9 PM ET/PT.



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

Season 2 of 'Beef' introduces class conflict as a prominent theme, set against the backdrop of an elite Southern California country club.
8 minutes ago
Samira Mohan was a senior resident during Season 2 of 'The Pitt,' but she plans to move into geriatrics once her residency at the hospital is over.
3 hours ago
The psychological drama ‘Husband, Father, Killer,’ highlights the troubling crimes of Steven Pladl which culminated in a triple murder and suicide.
4 hours ago
A post-credits moment in ‘The Pitt’ finale swaps tension for chaos as two doctors blow off steam, ending the heavy season on a surprising note.
8 hours ago
A shocking ER C-section in ‘The Pitt’ Season 2 finale pushes doctors to the edge, bringing realism with risk.
10 hours ago
The spin-off show’s fifth season aired a year ago, on April 17, 2025, and ever since there have been no renewal updates.
10 hours ago
A tense finale at ‘The Pitt’ brings shocking reveals, emotional goodbyes, and uncertain futures, leaving fans guessing what lies ahead in Season 3.
13 hours ago
Dr. Mohan’s sudden exit from ‘The Pitt’ sparks backlash as Noah Wyle explains the reason, but fans aren’t convinced and demand answers.
13 hours ago
The network bets big on fresh blood, holding back top performing hits to make room for new content
22 hours ago
‘Running Point’ Season 2 premiere brought stars, surprises, and early episode reveals — here’s everything that went down at Netflix’s big night.
23 hours ago