'Portals to Hell': Jack Osbourne and Katrina Weidman run into old bones, grizzly murder and a sheriff's secret

Jack Osbourne and Katrina Weidman, paranormal investigators dig into Old Paulding Jail and find something shocking sealed away inside a false well
Katrina Weidman and Jack Osbourne (Travel Channel)
Katrina Weidman and Jack Osbourne (Travel Channel)

When the current owner of what was once the old Paulding jail bought the building, she knew that some unwanted things may pop up. But she had no idea just how bad it would be. From slamming iron doors, shadow figures, disembodied voices, apparitions to pulling and pushing people and scratching them, the property is a hotspot for paranormal activity. Here's the real story behind this eerie 150-year-old establishment that hides many secrets, from mobsters to murders to allegations of a sheriff covering it all up.

Six-decade old unsolved murder of a teen

The death of Nancy Eagleson, a 14-year-old girl from the town, is puzzling. She died in 1960 and her body was found almost within an hour of her being reported missing by two hunters. She had been kidnapped and raped and then killed as she was walking home. Her personal belongings had simply just vanished. No one knew what happened to her. 

Years later, in 2013, when renovations began, a small-sized ladies black shoe and a torn piece of clothing was found in the building. The family later identified it as Nancy's. What were her belongings doing in a closed jail basement inside a hidden tunnel-like space? 

Who killed Nancy?

Many theories floated around to figure out the story. The place was under the thumb of mobsters, giving them the space to eliminate anyone they would have wanted. It is believed that Sherriff John Keeler, the resident charge of the jail, had something to do with it.

Although it was never proven, many people believe that Keeler tried to cover up whatever gruesome fate Nancy went through, which is why her spirit roams the jail's basement. Keeler is also thought to be a resident spirit in jail. The shoe was tested for DNA back in 2013 but no profile could be established. It could be because of the age of the object or her killer precautions.

Human bones?

Paranormal investigators Jack Osbourne and Katrina Weidman dig into this property and find something shocking sealed away inside a false well — Two bones that are too large to be from an animal and a little too small to be from a human adult. They guess it could be from the scapula bone and note something interesting. The bones looked like they had been cut cleanly with a sharp object, sliced right through. The bones have not been identified yet by the local police.

Whatever the outcome, this has got to be one of the most haunted places in Ohio. The history is murky and the fact that a jail had false walls that were sealed off with no record of orders being given to do so, is an investigation on its own.

'Portals to Hell' airs every Friday at 9 pm ET/PT on Travel Channel.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'The Gilded Age' is enjoying its strongest season yet, with viewership nearly 20% higher than the previous instalment
2026-11-19T20:50:24.000Z
This ‘Off Campus’ star reveals why his planned Season 2 return fell through, leaving questions about Allie and Dean’s story and his future.
2026-11-19T20:32:39.000Z
NBC reshuffles its Thursday lineup after 'Law & Order: SVU' celebrates its 600th episode, leaving fans waiting for the next instalment
2026-11-19T19:54:30.000Z
‘The Beast in Me’ expands its Season 2 cast as filming begins, with a ‘Daisy Jones & The Six’ reunion among the new additions.
2026-11-19T17:35:35.000Z
Eddie Redmayne’s assassin has unfinished business as ‘The Day of the Jackal’ Season 2 gets its first teaser and a fresh release update.
2026-11-19T15:55:05.000Z
Mary Jo’s present-day appearance gives Gibbs a new lead in his search for Lala, while fans wonder who will play her older self.
2026-11-19T14:26:35.000Z
Probie, who went out disgraced from Firehouse 51 earlier this season, will return to 'Chicago Fire'
2026-11-19T10:00:23.000Z
The teachers will accompany the school's Step Team on a trip to Disneyland Resort when the show returns
2026-11-19T09:18:50.000Z
Violet's fate hangs in the balance as her mother's heartbreaking request threatens her future
2026-11-19T08:02:33.000Z
The latest promo of 'Chicago Med' reveals why Dr Connor Rhodes is back at Gaffney after seven seasons
2026-11-19T06:00:35.000Z