'Memories of a Murder' Full Cast List: Meet Isabella Pisacane, Jamie Donnelly and rest of the stars from Lifetime thriller

The film formerly known as 'Souvenirs' centers around Gail (Isabella Pisacane) who runs a 'murderabilia' shop and starts being taunted by an anonymous killer, who leaves trophies from unsolved murders at her doorstep
'Memories of a Murder' stars Isabella Pisacane as Gail (IMDB)
'Memories of a Murder' stars Isabella Pisacane as Gail (IMDB)

Serial killers' jackets may not be on most people's shopping lists, but in Lifetime's movie 'Memories of a Murder', "murderabilia" has its takers. The film which was formerly known as 'Souvenirs' centers around Gail (Isabella Pisacane) who runs a murderabilia shop and starts being taunted by an anonymous killer, who leaves trophies from unsolved murders at her doorstep.

Let's now meet the cast behind what promises to be a memorable watch for the most bone-chilling reasons.

RELATED ARTICLES 

'How I Met Your Murderer' Full Cast List: Meet Rachele Schank, Chris Zylka and rest of the stars from Lifetime's psychological thriller

'A House on Fire': Live stream, release date, plot, cast, trailer and all you need to know about Lifetime film based on a true story

Isabella Pisacane stars in 'Memories of a Murder' (IMDB)

Cast

Isabella Pisacane as Gail 

Isabella Pisacane plays Gail the young murderabilia shop clerk, who also gets to discover some dark family secrets as she sells gruesome souvenirs. Pisacane has previously been seen in 'Daredevil' and in 'Law & Order: Special Victims Unit'.



 

Jamie Donnelly as Margot

Jamie Donnelly is a cult figure who has been part of not one, but two of the biggest pop-culture sensations, 'Grease' and 'The Rocky Horror Show'. Donnelly played Jan, one of the Pink Ladies from the musical 'Grease', and in the early 1970s, she starred in the premiere of 'The Rocky Horror Show' as Magenta and the Usherette. Besides being in front of the camera, Donnelly is also passionate about writing screenplays and spending time with her horses.

Jamie Donnelly stars in 'Memories of a Murder' (IMDB)

Abby Awe as Alexa

Before 'Memories of a Murder', Abby Awe was seen in roles in projects such as 'The Tick' and 'Shoplifters of the World'.



 

Rosa Gilmore as Janice

Rosa Gilmore is known for her work on popular shows like 'Elementary' and 'The Handmaid's Tale'. She was also part of the sci-fi series 'Expanse'.

Rosa Gilmore stars in 'Memories of a Murder' (IMDB)

Who are the other stars? 

'Memories of a Murder' also stars Craig Walker, John V. Barbieri and Sophie Bolen. 

Creators

'Memories of a Murder' is directed by Anna Mikami and written by Matthew Sorvillo. 'Memories of a Murder' premieres on Lifetime on Saturday, May 8, at 8/7c. You can catch the trailer for the film formerly known as 'Souvenirs' below.



 

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

A centuries-old vampire experiences love for the first time in 'Pretty Kill Machine,' a new supernatural romance set in Joshua Tree, California.
2026-11-03T18:35:39.000Z
An ‘Orphan’ favorite takes on a world where heartbreak can kill in Beth Fletcher’s debut feature, a sci-fi thriller already filming in Massachusetts.
2026-11-03T18:15:33.000Z
Robert Pattinson stars in 'Primetime,' a thriller inspired by the real-life controversies surrounding a hit television sting operation.
2026-11-03T15:58:12.000Z
Jason Statham and Guy Ritchie’s new film returns to familiar territory, with Netflix backing a story that takes their partnership back to its roots.
2026-11-03T15:45:17.000Z
Two 'Avengers' stars lead 'A Speck in the Sea,' a survival thriller based on a lobster fisherman’s fight to stay alive after falling overboard.
2026-11-03T15:16:52.000Z
With ‘Pirates of the Caribbean 6’ in development, Johnny Depp discusses playing Jack Sparrow again, and what could shape his decision.
2026-11-03T14:17:58.000Z
The 'Slow Horses' star calls James Bond speculation 'flattering' and finally broke his silence on the casting rumors.
2026-11-03T11:41:43.000Z
This comes after 'Scream 7' opened with $63.6 million, the biggest opening weekend in the franchise's 30-year history
2026-11-03T06:49:19.000Z
Casey Cott enters a dangerous game in first details of upcoming thriller ‘Games We Play’
2026-11-03T03:16:18.000Z
A canceled influencer’s attempt to escape online life spirals into psychological horror in 'Get Off Your Phone', starring Maria Bakalova.
2026-11-02T20:20:22.000Z