'Making The Cut' called out for starring designers who can't sew, fans ask: 'Is this common in the industry?'

The show has spoken about it being a design competition and not a stitching one
Martha Gottwald, Sabato Russo, Esther Perbandt (Amazon Prime Video)
Martha Gottwald, Sabato Russo, Esther Perbandt (Amazon Prime Video)

Amazon-backed fashion competition series 'Making The Cut' is making quite the wave on social media. Fans seem to be loving the show and are vocal about their opinions on it. But, there's a niggling issue that bothers the viewers and it's the fact that some of the designers don't know how to stitch garments, not even the basics. 

Sabato Russo, Esther Perbandt and Martha Gottwald have all tasted the last-minute rush that not knowing how to stitch brings with it. Sure, these designers have years of experience behind them. Some have boutiques while others have participated in fashion weeks. But isn't stitching a crucial technical skill when it comes to the construction of clothes? It is.

Martha simply used pins to put together her two-look collection for one of her assignments. She broke down and was having a tough time trying to figure out her designs for the runway. Had she known how to stitch, she could have utilized those few hours that she spent being anxious and uncertain about what was coming her way. Eventually, she used safety pins to hold her dress together and that put off the judges.

Same with Esther. She panicked when she had to hand stitch a part of her garment because the seamstress assigned to her didn't finish the construction, leaving her with an incomplete dress. Although she won the challenge, it would have done her a world of good if she had known at least the basics of stitching.

Sabato too is in the same boat. In the recently-concluded episode that tasked the contestants with a collaboration challenge, Sander Bos found himself doing most of the stitching after their clothing came in half-done. Sabato put all of their pinned garments into one bag whereas he was supposed to segregate them into two because each designer is assigned only one seamstress. Even though he regretted his mistake, Sander was forgiving and instead said that everyone was allowed to make mistakes. 

Meanwhile, fans think it's weird that a fashion competition series like 'Making The Cut' allows designers who have no clue of basic stitching. 

"The designers are still working but so far it is definitely a huge change of pace to see how many designers don’t know how to sew, pattern make, etc. it’s not impressive TBH," a viewer shared. Another wrote: "How on earth can you be a fashion designer and not know how to sew or make a pattern? It’s like trying to write a song without knowing how to play an instrument or read music? I don’t get it. #MakingTheCut."

"@MakingtheCutTV I'm loving the show&designers. I know 'it's not a sewing competition' but it's been messing with my mind that there are designers who are unable to make a pattern or sew. Is this common in the industry? Sincerely curious! #MakingTheCut," another tweeted.

"Episode 3 of #MakingTheCut, WHY do they cast people who CAN’T sew or cut a pattern. Is this Drag Race?" a user posted. 

Catch all the new episodes of 'Making The Cut' on Amazon Prime Video.

GET THE BIGGEST ENTERTAINMENT STORIES
STRAIGHT TO YOUR INBOX.

MORE STORIES

'Ted Lasso' released its season four finale on Wednesday, October 7, 2026, on Apple TV
1 hour ago
'Ted Lasso' Season 4 starring Jason Sudeikis is currently streaming on Apple TV
1 hour ago
LL Cool J reprises his longtime role as Sam Hanna in the latest CBS spinoff
3 hours ago
The Season 24 premiere brings Michael Weatherly’s Tony DiNozzo back into the NCIS fold with a surprising new role
4 hours ago
The ‘All’s Fair’ lawyers face new conflicts as season 2 brings Kim Kardashian and the ensemble back to Hulu.
12 hours ago
Rose Byrne and Meghann Fahy lead Peacock’s ‘The Good Daughter,’ a gripping thriller about sisters confronting a mystery tied to their family’s past.
12 hours ago
‘Boston Blue’ Season 2 brings fresh challenges for the Silver family as political tensions and a dangerous investigation create new trouble.
14 hours ago
Roku’s ‘Scarlett Holmes’ puts a romantic twist on the famous detective legacy, following a sharp-minded heroine who solves love and dating mysteries.
17 hours ago
'NCIS: New York’ expands the hit franchise with LL Cool J leading a new team through high-stakes cases in the heart of New York City.
18 hours ago
Tony DiNozzo returns as 'NCIS' Season 24 picks up after Torres' standoff and an unresolved gunshot.
18 hours ago